Fri Jul 27, 2007 5:34PM EDT
See Comments (78)
Just about every time I write about how some people say that wireless transmissions from Wi-Fi and cell phones are making them sick, it brings an outcry from the faithful who are convinced they're being killed in silent but deadly fashion. Then I defend what I wrote. Then we start all over when the next study comes out.
Well, finally UK scientists (as most of these reports seem to come out of Britain) are trying to bring some sanity to the issue, saying that "allergies" to cell phone radiation are all in your mind, a result of self-delusion brought about by intense belief that radio waves could somehow be making you sick.
Bear in mind, the people studied in the Environmental Health Perspectives report do indeed show real symptoms of illness, but the illness isn't caused by "electro-sensitivity." It's caused by the people themselves, in much the same way that a placebo can "cure" you of a headache simply through the power of self-suggestion. Such symptoms include sweatier skin and higher blood pressure, in addition to general feelings of illness.
The study put dozens of people who claimed this sensitivity (as well as control subjects who didn't claim the illness) in a room, then turned a nearby cell phone tower on or off. Only 2 of the 44 sensitive subjects picked correctly all six trials whether the signal was being emitted: About equal to what you'd expect from random guessing. But if the subjects were told that the signal was turned on, they began reporting symptoms... even if the tower was really turned off.
While this will certainly not silence all the critics who claim that the conveniences of modern life are slowly making them sick (some even claim electricity running through wires in the walls causes illness), it's at least another nail in the coffin that may someday bury this topic for good.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Thank goodness for this study. Now, if only someone will do a study on why my cell phone only picks up a good signal when it feels like it. That makes me more sick than anything else.
I still think the radiation emitted from the signals can be deadly, I mean, it all makes sense! The waves are bad for you.
Robots are stealing your luggage...
I always get a headache EVERYTIME I am on it more than 5-10 minutes. I think that you have to consider the source. Of course people who sell cellphone are going to say that they are fine. Then people who are getting sick from them, know it is them because there is no coincidence about it. I believe that we create our own sickness with our thoughts. Even being a person with that level of awareness, I have to say that it is quite ironic that everytime I am on the cell, I get a headache. Coincidence? Creation? I think it is probably a bit of both.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 Posted by eggboard on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:52PM EDT Report Abuse
"It's caused by the people themselves, in much the same way that a placebo can "cure" you of a headache simply through the power of self-suggestion.": I read the study, not just the coverage, and you're not quite right. I have written extensively about the bad science or wish fulfillment behind most of the EMF-health linkages. But in this case, the researchers stated quite clearly that the symptoms were real and didn't speculate on whether people were causing them themselves. Rather, they stated that with the evidence that people exhibited real symptoms, work should be done to determine the actual cause.