Fingers-on Review: Piano Wizard

Tue May 29, 2007 11:09PM EDT

See Comments (11)

When the three piano players in my house (none of them me, all age 14 and under) first started tinkering with Piano Wizard, a computer program that works in tandem with a MIDI keyboard to teach kids how to play piano, they found it confusing. But they agreed that's because they are each a few years away from when they first learned fingerings and notes. After starting with Piano Wizard's beginner lessons, we could see that by taking it step by step, a novice player could learn finger positions, then notes, and become comfortable on a keyboard.

Allegro Rainbow provides a fun way to introduce kids to playing a keyboard without expensive weekly lessons with a piano teacher. Kids can start out by choosing the background they like —such as a dinosaur age landscape, a rock concert—and what they want the moving target on the screen to be. (A pterodactyl egg is pictured.)

The keyboard comes with color-coded stickers to affix to the keys in a pattern and connects to the computer via a USB drive. There are four levels of learning—beginner, intermediate, transition, and advanced. At the beginner level, the dinosaur eggs (or whatever icon you choose) move up from the bottom of the screen. As each hits an onscreen keyboard key, the student must hit the actual keyboard key that corresponds to the color and key on the computer screen. The correct note sounds if the timing and key choice are correct.

Once that level is mastered, kids can advance from colors, to note fingerings, to note names. Then they can try right hand, then left hand, then hands together. From there, the screen can transition from a vertical layout to a horizontal layout, and from colors to actual notes moving across the screen. With each lesson and song played, Piano Wizard keeps track of a student's success rate and then lets her know how well she did by the percentage of notes hit correctly at the end.

There was definitely enough going on to keep my 10 year old interested in playing. There are lots of songs to choose from, and she really liked the "jam" feature that allows you to create your own songs and see the notes, long and short, appear on the screen by name as you play.

But for the $200 Piano Wizard Premier package to be more than an expensive computer game, it will take the same thing that working with a piano teacher requires to learn how to play: practice. And following along in the order that makes the most sense to learn correct finger positions and note names.

At the very least, it's a good way for parents and kids to gauge whether kids want to undertake piano lessons. At most, it's a wonderful, fun approach for kids with an aptitude and a desire to learn to play the piano but who don't have the time and money for years of lessons. If your kids were to emerge from hours of computer games with the ability to play an instrument, that would be a good thing.

If anyone has tried Piano Wizard at home, let us know what you think.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on Fingers-on Review: Piano Wizard

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 6 Posted by markdean321 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:07PM EDT Report Abuse

    Expensive weekly lessons? Take in account that it would probably take months for them to play simple songs with this game, where a teacher would have them playing more complicated songs in weeks. If you need a game to decide whether your child should take lessons or not, then you shouldn't. Piano is only for people that understand that it is as involved of an endeavor and takes as much time and devotion as a child going through school.

  • 7 Posted by dolphins1817 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    vukili is right, no one really can replace the real makings of a real piano teacher.

  • 8 Posted by m_petuca on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:32PM EDT Report Abuse

    I am a piano teacher with a doctorate in music and appreciate all the comments about the importance of a real piano teacher. There is so much more to playing piano and making music than what a computer program can provide...

  • 9 Posted by digikeys on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:43PM EDT Report Abuse

    I've used the program and understand that the developers are not trying to replace a piano teacher. Fear seems to rear its' ugly head whenever technology is used to stimulate interest in an area that teachers are involved in. Relax, and appreciate the fact that programs like these will add to the number of available interested piano students. Instead of slamming a program that frightens you, look at the positive side. Many young people will begin a new journey into the world of music instead of vegetating in front of the latest version of Doom on their computers. The documentation that was provided to me with the program made no claims concerning the fact that their program would replace a teacher. I would suggest that teachers look at recommending this program as a way to get a young persons' appetite wetted for lessons in the future. If a teacher is a good piano teacher, they should not be threatened at all by these types of programs-they would be confident in their ability to provide a level of learning far beyond the capabilities of Piano Wizard! Everyone said that digital electronic keyboard sounds would replace the need for real musicians and instruments-they were wrong as time has proven. Let's not be ignorant again with a rush to judgement.

  • 10 Posted by halcsalter on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:15PM EDT Report Abuse

    I am the CEO and Founder of the company and product, and want to clarify our company's position on the role of Piano Wizard and piano teachers. The game is a real breakthrough on a lot of levels, it can teach the notes, and get the kids playing and reading in minutes. As far as practice, being a game, it inverts the whole practice paradigm, you can't get them off the game. That being said, while the game teaches the notes very well, the game CANNOT teach "music". Music is "between the notes" as Jimi Hendrix said, it is the phrasing, the dynamics, the technique, the ART of music, that MUST be taught by a human being, preferably an artist. Our greatest nightmare would be that the game produces a generation of "typists". We absolutely NEED piano and music teachers to use this as a TOOL, it cannot be a replacement. Because of that deeply held belief and conviction, we have been creating a video series called Piano Wizard Academy lessons, that takes each graduated level song in our EASY MODE as a framework for a lesson. The key difference here is that the lessons are NOT geared toward the students, but to the parents, non-music educators (after school programs, etc) and piano teachers, to orientate them how to best use the game, and how to take the kids off the game to a real piano, reading real music, which the game could never do on its own. We are extremely proud of this work, and the results it is already engendering, and invite any and all of you to look at it at www.yourhomeworkmusicwizardacademy.com. We urge you not to take our word for it, but to drill down, get the game and videos, and make an educated decision yourselves from your own experiences, not hearsay. We believe you will find it invaluable for keeping "the rest of the kids" engaged and learning, and we welcome your feedback, ideas and suggestions. We believe music should be a birthright, but we can't do it alone, we need your support and guidance. Our game is just training wheels, the kids need you for the musical journey that should last for the rest of their lives. THANKS Chris Salter CEO Allegro Rainbow

  • 11 Posted by samallott on Wed Dec 26, 2007 11:37PM EST Report Abuse

    Hi Chris Salter Ceo of Allegro. I am a Piano teacher and I am not at all threatened by your product in fact just the opposite. I purchased the product for a student of 3 years that refuses to read the staff but played for over an hour on a computer keyboard on the websites demo. I have to say having played around with your product myself over the last few weeks I am really dissapointed by the quality of the graphics resolution. This if giving me eye strain the game I can't believe so many people have such good things to say about this product when simply viewing it is so dire. What can be done to improve this? Also the game itself would be much improved if there were players histories and progresses included. Has any one else experianced these problems with piano wizard.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.