Xanga Fined for Allowing Underage Kids to Join

Fri Sep 8, 2006 3:55PM EDT

See Comments (22)

It's a safe bet that lots of kids are fudging their birth dates to set up pages on social networking web sites, such as MySpace and Xanga, which require you to be 13 or older to sign up. But the federal government fined Xanga today for $1 million for allowing people to set up accounts even if the birth dates entered make it clear they are not quite 13.

The Federal Trade Commission levied the fine—the largest in FTC history—under the 1998 Children's Online Privacy Protection Act, which says parental notification and consent are required for commercial web sites to collect personal information from children under age 13.

The FTC also said that Xanga's policies regarding children were not clear and that parents had no way to access and control their children's information. The commission estimated that during the past five years, 1.7 million Xanga accounts were registered with birth dates that indicated the members were under 13.

The response from Xanga, now 25 million members strong: CEO John Hiler said that many of the under-13 birth dates may have referred to pets, engagement dates, and "born-again" dates for religious bloggers, Cnet reports. Interesting observation, but the chief also said Xanga will be introducing new rules and standards to make the site safer for children.

It's also a safe bet that many of the parents of the kids under age 13 didn't have a clue that their kids were posting personal information about themselves on Xanga.

Brad Weber was certain his kids were not on social networking sites because he had blocked them on the family computer, and he had set browser controls since the kids were small to determine where they can and cannot go on the web.

But when his wife asked him to look into MySpace, he found that his 13-year-old daughter had created a MySpace page from a friend's computer. She had an open profile that told the public the name of her school and where she likes to shop. "I was so concerned about them downloading something bad," said the veteran software developer.  "It never dawned on me to tell them not to upload anything."

So Weber and Michael Edelson, a dad of three 13-year-old girls, launched BeNetSafe last month to track whether kids are on MySpace and to monitor if their pages are public or private and what they are posting on them. For a monthly subscription of $9.95 a month or $49.95 for a year, parents can access reports via the web or through weekly or monthly email reports. The reports link directly to kids' profiles and any photos they have posted.

Their timing is good. Next week, BeNetSafe adds Xanga to its monitoring service.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on Xanga Fined for Allowing Underage Kids to Join

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by p3dcrane on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:48PM EDT Report Abuse

    I helped my son to created his Xanga site. He is 12 and will be 13 in a few days. I can check it when ever I want. And he has enough good ence to know what online pretidors are and warned me of MYspace. I think if more parents got invovled with thier kids online use instead of shutting them down at every turn this guy's daughter wouldn't have gone behind his back to a friends house to creat a Myspace site on her own (which by the way is FULL of preditors). Instead of bringing Xanga down, he should try to get along a little better with his kid. And sit with them and not block them. Darlene Crane A Xanga Parent.

  • 2 Posted by brightdim03 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:13PM EDT Report Abuse

    seriously who cares, just block it to anyone under a certain age, and after that it should be the parent's job, and thiers alone to keep thier kids safe, it is not the fault of the company if a kid fudges thier age, thats the parents fault for not watchin... get over it and take responsibility for your family, its not the rest of the worlds job...

  • 3 Posted by ladykelien on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:55PM EDT Report Abuse

    My 13 year old has several xanga accounts. My children under 13 don't. Not because I said no or because they couldn't handle it. Just because they aren't interested. It is the parents job to educate children about the internet and preditors but not all children access the computers from home. What about schools? How do we know these children didn't set up the accounts while in school? This is part of why I homeschool. The children that my daughters have befriended who attend public school here scare me. They create xanga's using their real names, put up pictures wearing t-shirts with their school name on it and tell people they are from where we are from all on their xangas. I have personally scared the crap out of several of them when they came over here to the point of tears so they would realize just how important this is to protect themselves. Most parents don't know. In this area we have way to many children being raised by grand parents or parents who dropped out of high school. These people know nothing about the computer other than their kids want one, and aren't on the phone. You have no idea how many grandparents will buy them for their grand kids out of guilt over the fact these kids parents are missing in action. But, they cant set the clock on the VCR much less work a computer to check up on them. My daughter has become the friend police. She lets me know when they are doing stupid stuff. I talk to them about it and if it doesn't stop, I talk to what ever adult is raising them. But, that is a last resort thing because these kids have nothing but their computers. Many are latch key kids just because they have to be. I was a latch key kid. No one thought it was that bad when we were kids. No one thinks anything of it now. Women have to work in this society and jobs from home are few and far between. So yes, the goverment should have fined them for letting kids in under 13, not providing better access to parents who might not understand the computer and actually monitoring and enforcing rules to protect those that are there already.

  • 4 Posted by ont977920 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    A couple of random thoughts... 1 - I would hope that amonggreyfox would leave his children with neither Darlene nor Soccer until at least meeting them. Either may be a wonderful or awful parent. How the heck do I know? I have never talk to them. :) 2 - For the record, the spelling is 'predator' 3 - With regard to level of education and common sense, a lack of formal education does not automatically imply common sense either. Someone can indeed have both or neither. It does, however, follow common sense to pursue an education. 4 - People who act like the rear end of a Clydesdale can, in fact, breed and often do. 5 - Both comments seemed a bit harsh to me. 6 - Darlene did have a good point to make.

  • 5 Posted by danashchigol on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:34PM EDT Report Abuse

    parents are WAY too concerned about myspace and xanga. back off. myspace is harmless. ur kids should understand not to add ppl who they dont know. nd if they do add ppl they dont noe they r probably not even going to talk to them. calm down. parents always say kids should have a childhood. but they dont if they have parents on their backs 24/7

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.