Thu Jan 25, 2007 12:12PM EST
See Comments (9)
As I wrote in my previous post on parental controls, there are other options besides software applications for helping your kids avoid inappropriate web sites and to search the Internet safely. Here are a few ideas worth trying before loading software on your computer.
Start with using existing browser and search filters. You'll find at least some limited filters in some browsers and search functions.
For searching the web, you can put some limited filters in place, too. On the Yahoo! Search bar, click on the web search box and then on "search preferences." If you put the SafeSearch feature on, it will filter adult video and image search results, but that's all. Similarly, on Google, go to the home page, click on "Preferences" to the right of the search box. Go to "SafeSearch Filtering" and click on one of three dials, strict filtering to avoid explicit text and images, moderate filtering to filter explicit images only, or no filtering. MSN's SafeSearch does the same with three settings—strict, moderate, and off. Click on "Options" at the top of the search results page, and choose your preferred setting.
Hardware solutions. Some wireless routers also offer parental controls often through subscription services. I wrote about a few hardware options in this post, but have since learned Linksys has discontinued parental controls support on the WRT54GS; I'm following up to find out why.
Other hardware options stand separate from routers. One is D-Link's SecureSpot Internet Security Device, which costs about $100 plus $80 for a year of service. Kind of pricey. You hook up the SecureSpot box with Ethernet cables to your computer and wireless router. Via the web, you can set up time restrictions for individual family members and block specific kinds of content and web sites, limit email and IM lists, and get reports on family members' computer and Internet usage.
That's a quick look at some of the options available. Let us know which you choose, reader Annie, and how it works out. And if anyone has a software or hardware parental control solution they are happy (or unhappy) with, post away.
Related:
Extra Eyes for ParentsJoin in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
The perfect answer to protect your entire home network: Just connect it up, set desired parental controls to block the type of sites you don't want, and Presto! every computer in the house is instantly protected. It's magic. Unfortunately, D-Link doesn't tell you how the magic can go wrong. The box doesn't know about bad web sites. Instead, every time your browser requests something, the box phones home to D-Link to check it. D-Link approves or blocks it based on your preferences. It's not just once per page - every picture, every ad, every element from each URL address is checked with D-Link. On a regular web site, the box phone home dozens of times. While checking a few web e-mails, it may be hundreds. If for any reason the box can't connect to D-Link, you are in big trouble. You are dead in the water, basically no internet at all. The password override won't help you, because even password override is controlled through the D-Link web site, so if you can't get to that site, you can't even temporarily disable the broken service. When was the last time Google was down? If D-Link operated like Google, depending on their computers might be OK. Unlike *free* Google servces, *paid* D-Link services are a disaster. At any random time, you become aware that 'Hey! The internet is *really* slow today!'. 20 minutes to log into web-based e-mail? But it is NOT the internet that is slow - it is D-Link's computers. Not enough capacity for busy times, or maybe hackers don't like them and they get hit with DOS (denial of service) attacks. Google and others providing *free* services deal with all these issues. D-Link's with a *paid* service chooses not to. This is a nightmare, especially if you use computers for anything important (weather, e-mail, homework...). Worse, D-Link customer service will not even acknowledge the problem. If you need your internet working, you must physically bypass the securespot box. It's easy to move a couple of cables. Then every few hours, you can change it back and see if D-Link is running yet. In case you are not there when D-Link dies, you can train your spouse, kids, guests, friends etc. exactly where the box is and how to quickly bypass it. Whoops! Now everybody not only knows how to bypass it, they are even trained to be in the habit of regularly bypassing it. That sounds like no protection at all. Presumably D-Link sees your $80 subscription as a gift, and they choose not to spend it giving you services you thought you bought. You can also worry about information D-Link collects. The box gives them more detail on your surfing than Google dreams about. Unlike Google, they can tie it to a person, an address, and a credit card. A reputable company would never use that information. But if D-Link are careless with a service you are paying for, how carefully will they treat your data? Bottom Line: Securespot is brilliant when it works. But it's a service, not a box. And the service doesn't work. Avoid it.
I have come across this discussion and want to let you know that I'm using Linksys WRTG54GS for a couple of years, and been able to renew the service this year w/o any problem. If you have this model of router (or you buy one built with the parental control feature - probably pre-2007) you may be able to still use the service - use the following address to find out if available: "Linksys Parental Controls Support" Regards
The Linksys parental control will be discontinued. This message appears on the website: "The Linksys Parental Controls service is no longer accepting subscription renewals. We apologize for any inconvenience and encourage you to look for other Parental Controls options before your subscription expires." I do like the router-based filtering because it is a one-point management for all devices and it works on all devices even the ones that you cannot install a software, such as a Nintendo-DS with a browser, while allowing pass-through using MAC adresses for other devices if needed.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by marshbman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:09PM EDT Report Abuse
I actually work in communications and have been looking for something for one of my clients who needs open access for their site however they have very strict requirements for the connection. I have a wrt54gs and just started playing with it trying to set up some parental controls. I don't know where its going to get me yet however I found barracuda networks has a piece of hardware that looks like it might be the solution that we are all looking for. as for the post by bakerman_2001 you can teach your children all you want but they have free agency to make their own decisions, mine do all the time however I have say in what comes into my house and what doesn't, as far as my kids going to others houses and surfing for porn I try to make it so my kids have their friends come over to my house because I know my rules and how I keep my house, I would much rather have my kids at home where I can keep watch than have them go to someone else and rely on their judgement. The problem is finding that balance where you can keep control in your own home and making it a place where your kids want to be rather than going to someone's house who doesn't care...