Mon Sep 22, 2008 12:00AM EDT
See Comments (57)
Buying music sans a physical backup (as in buying from iTunes) not your bag? Now you'll have an alternative to audio CDs. And no, I don't mean vinyl. SanDisk today is launching a brave new experiment in music sales: slotMusic, which puts audio tracks on a tiny microSD card and which will be sold, preloaded, at retail.
This isn't some podunk trial project: All four major music labels are onboard for the launch, as are Best Buy and Wal-Mart.
Why microSD? The format is being plugged as an alternative for users with music-capable mobile phones, many of which have microSD slots that go largely unused. A consumer can buy a card, pop it into his phone, and be immediately up and running, so there's no need to wait until you're back at your computer to purchase tracks online, and no need to rip a CD. (On the other hand, you will still have to actually physically purchase the music, but if you're out and about already...)
slotMusic will include DRM-free MP3 tracks, typically encoded at 320kbps, so users will get high fidelity music without having to worry about downgraded audio. Most slotMusic cards will be 1GB in capacity. Buyers will be free to back up the music to their hard drives at any time (each card will include a tiny USB adapter; an example—not slotMusic, but close enough—is pictured above), and of course they can overwrite a card later with other data when they're tired of listening to the music on it. Pricing will be dependent on retailers, but SanDisk tells me it will be competitive with CDs and "as expected."
Initially you can expect regular albums to be ported to the slotMusic format, but depending on its success, we might see labels making custom "mix cards" of popular tunes, which would seem to fit well with the grab-and-go consumer who's looking for something to listen to on his phone.
The million-dollar question, of course, is whether the market is big enough and interested enough for slotMusic. I'm a big fan of alternatives in the audio market, and slotMusic so far is hitting all the right notes—no DRM, high bitrate, ostensibly reasonable prices—but I wonder if consumers haven't moved past the "one piece of media, one album" mentality altogether. Also, swapping microSD cards on many phones can be a real pain (some have the card located underneath the battery, ugh), and the tiny cards will be incredibly easy to lose. No one will travel with more than one card in tow for fear of losing it along with his spare change. And even the cheapest MP3 player can crank out hundreds of songs instead of the mere dozen you'll get on a slotMusic card. If you meet a specific set of criteria—need music right away, have no MP3 player, and have a microSD slot on your phone—slotMusic will be a good solution for you. How many people that really comprises, I don't know.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Finally! I thought the industry had passed Science Fiction once. Guess not! Remember A Clockwork Orange. This is cool.
I can't imagine this will succeed. Have to carry the right phone in order to take advantage.
Agree on the movies thing. There should be a little player that has like 10 slots. I for one hate iTunes and it is a PITA to rip. The security comment is moot - people can do the same with CDs now. Some people (not me) have reservations about buying music without any physicality - with this you could basically sell a little "album cover"/liner notes with a little case for the chip. Very cool idea. The chips just need to be a little bigger and clear like a piece of ice.
depends on the Kbps...right? , most Sandisk products cap at 192....If these are to be collected like discs or albums wouldn't 320 be much more of a selling point?
I don't BUY compressed music files (MP3's) -- they're inferior to uncompressed.. I'd rather buy a CD and make my own MP3's as necessary. Since memory is cheap -- I might consider this product if it contained both uncompressed WAV files and MP3's. They could easily fit both formats on one 1GB card. And without artwork or booklet, the price would have to be significantly lower than a CD. Maybe $7.
They should have used standard sized SD cards instead of micro-SD cards - those things snap in half way too easily. BUT t is nice to see the US finally using 15 year old technology to listen to music... One of my oldest DVD players has memory card slots for playing MP3s on them, and my newest ones have USB slots for playing music on them from portable hard drives. So - nothing new - just the music companies finally beginning to embrace what they should have embraced here in the US 10 years ago... In the meantime, CDs have been obsoleted elsewhere in the world...
To me this sounds like a great idea! I love music and would love to make it easier for myself to put this on my phone to listen to. Why should I have to buy an Ipod if my phone has the same capability? Plus, no spending extra time to put the music on a disk myself. I cannot wait for this to come out!
It's not a very smart move. I dont think it will last. I don't buy cd's for the fact that I usually only like 1 or 2 songs on that cd unless its a greatest hits album. I'm not going to buy a micro sd card or anything else when I only have to pay a dollar a song to download the ones I like. cd's are about to be just like the cassette tape. just make it easier to put songs on an sd card for people who don't have all the equipment, like some kiosk at best buy or something. I can do all of it myself, but some people can't or dont have the time.
I don't think it will really sell as an anwer to music piracy. Memory cards are getting smaller with more mememory and cheaper. In fact, I could stream my whole 80 GB library of music from my computer at home to my iphone and my computer at work. I could plug in my iphone to my radio in my car and stream to it via 3g.
if they want to get to consumers who carry portable music players, then they should set up a kiosk were consumers can input their new music in to there ipod or mp3 player of their phone. just a few different cords like at the picture kiosk do and then if im at wal-mart and have my ipod with me which i do all the time i can plug into their kiosk and upload the newest albums out there. that is where music needs to go not some cheap little card that your gonna lose in 10 min.
I dont think it will sell, but thats what some said about the cd. And piracy is easy , but lets not forset how easy it is to put it on CD, even Casset. all you have to do is basicly just pop it in the cpu or something and just copy. But some people say, " If i put it in my pocket it will break.", to me saying that, you might as well put a Cd in your pocket.
You got to be joking, This would have been really cool lets say 10 years ago with dial up internet all over the place and the idea of mp3s were kind of a new thing. I think this is behind the times and the music industry as we knew it is gone. I think that this is a lst ditch attempt by distributers to hold on to market share. I think now a days if you got good music, people wil download it and put it on what they please. Since I have been able to burn my collection onto the computer, I havent reached for a CD or anything else for that matter. This seems to be a step backwards for technolgy.
to answer the question about security, what is to keep someone from buying a CD and burning it and giving the CD to someone else? nothing. So the situation we are dealing with is, buy a CD or buy this card as the first point of purchase? I think this should cut down on waste. CD's litter and take up lots of space.
I would by-pass this microSD or any other media cards. Cellphones have come along ways. Just wait and the hard-drives in cellphones will increase in size. By the way, who would want to listen to music on their cellphone and drain the battery and neglect what the cellphone is really used for, like calls? Do you really want to spend that much money on a small mini flash cards for only limited cellphones? Any person who's really dedicated to their music and must hear it all the time already has a iPod or some other music player. Save your money and invest in a good music player.
I can see a market for this. For the real tech savvy, or those comfrotable buying online, it's not going to sell. But for the average soccer mom who just wants to get some songs onto her MP3 player, it will be a boon. I spent 3 hours last night loading up a 1 gb Micro card with music for my celphone. Next weekend I have to do the same for my wife for her phone. My wife wouldn't have music on her phone with out me doing the technical stuff, a solution like this let's her buy, plug and play without my help. Of course, if they go with the single album on a card for the same price as a CD it will flop, however, a $19.99-$29.99 "mix" card with 50-100 popular songs would do quite well.
I can't imagine buying music like this. MicroSD cards are are not as easy to install as SD cards. My blackberry requires you to take out the battery install the microSD card and slide the card cage to lock it in place. I wouldn't want to do that everytime I wanted to change tunes. Services like i-Tunes are easy enough to use and you can put the music right on your i-Pod or sync it to my blackberry with the included media software. MicroSD cards are really small, about the size of your thumbnail and really easy to loose. I would stick to i-Tunes and CDs. Are people really buying that many CDs anymore since Rhapsody and i-Tunes?
hmmm yea I don't much see the point. I have an 8-gig microSD card that I use for my whole (mobile) music collection, and in a few weeks I'll be jumping on the new 16-gig microSD's when SanDisk releases those. Using 1-gig microSD's seems a bit of a waste. All I'd do is copy the albums to my normal card and throw the 1-gig away. Seems much more sensible to set up kiosks to transfer the music to people's devices...or just keep using iTunes, amazon, etc. like we're already doing. Save the cards, use kiosks!
Well I hope it's new music, not like the SACD and DVD Audio. 95% of those were old issues.
how redundant is that? i've been doing that for like a year, standard cards work, i mean i bought the whole pack that has the adapter for the micro, mini, duo and standard sd at walmart on sale for like 20 bucks, and just put my own music on it, plus its 2 gig, (twice the space they are proposing) and it works in my laptop, palm treo, psp, and yep even plugs into my truck stereo, so why would a person even bother, most people would just get lost in transition, and end up buying too many cards, looks like another way to sell the same thing they already make, and add a higher price to it
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by m_knopp on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:32PM EDT Report Abuse
The time for this is just about right, but not for music. This idea of moving beyond spinning optical media is ripe for movies. Instead of buying DVD's which are prone to scratch and are bulky to carry, yet still take up enough hard drive space as to limit the digital protability. I think that this is a good idea for movies. Music on the other hand, well I find this as yet another example of the music industry being too little too late.