Thu Jan 15, 2009 12:03PM EST
See Comments (114)
In a recent blog post, I mentioned almost as an aside that "the desktop PC [was] well on its way to the grave," figuring this was common knowledge by now and nothing that would raise eyebrows. But I was surprised how this one little comment generated a ton of mail from curious readers looking for more details on the trend.
I'm happy to oblige.
What we have at work here is a trend that's been in the making for a solid decade. In the PC world, the market share owned by laptops has been rising dramatically and steadily, eating into the share owned by desktops. In the second half of 2008, those trend lines finally crossed, as laptops outsold desktops for the first time ever. In 2009, sales of laptops should comprise 55 percent of the PC market, and now many are beginning to wonder when the first major tech company will get out of the desktop market altogether, where profits are lower and equipment takes up much more space on the production floor.
The reasons for the shift are largely obvious. Earlier in the decade, you could rely on desktops to be more reliable, much easier to upgrade, far more powerful, and much, much cheaper than their laptop counterparts. But those advantages have vanished or shrunk dramatically in the last few years. Desktop PCs will probably always outperform laptops, but for general consumers outside the rarified air of high-end gaming PCs, laptop performance is good enough for just about any task, largely thanks to Intel developing low power versions of its CPUs and mobile graphics becoming more powerful, too. Laptop reliability has greatly improved, thanks to better construction quality and advances like accelerometers that automatically park hard drive heads when a fall is underway. And then there's price, where laptops have also found their way to competing against desktops, with capable models available for $500 to $800, about what you'd have to spend to get a decent desktop.
Really, desktop PCs should be in even worse shape than they are now, except the corporate market -- where the mobility of easily-stolen laptops is often a liability rather than a benefit -- has kept the business alive almost singlehandedly. But even that's likely to change in the near future. As Reuters reports, equipment manufacturers are now shifting production away from desktop-size components and towards parts for laptops and other gadgets. And you can't make a desktop PC without a case, a motherboard, and desktop-sized RAM.
Then again, I guess you could always make a desktop using laptop parts.
Lots more commentary in this Reuters story.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
@coolkyle4 Hey...my Dell Studio has 300 gb and my Dell XPS has 400 gb....almost bought a HP with a terabyte.
desktop can't be replaced for the people who actually have some work to do, like creating 3d content, working on graphics where color precision is important, and i don't imagine how anyone can play on a laptop with it's defective TFT technology.. so desktops + CRT if u have some stuff to do
Hello guys,i have some good things to share with you, half year ago my wife lift me ! i did not know what to do . One day i saw a website UniForMedMinGlE Com here.when i sing up there ,haha .fantastic ! beauty,beauty!many many beauty there from all nations ! all of them are looking for love ,you will be happy there . and i had a dating yesterday!wow wow ! it is my favorite! You have any interest to lovers ,you can have a try there!
Laptops do not last as long, they overheat. I have not seen any upgradable other then memory. My laptop is 5 yrs old and not up to par and even if I upgraded the memory, I would need alot done to it just to get it up to par with my desktop. I think that desk tops last alot longer and have better upgrade possibilities. So while I do like a laptop I also see the need for a desktop.
Laptops are not that great, they will never out last a PC, they will never be as powerful as a pc for the money. $600.00 PC would be $1900.00- Laptop. For the idiot that said 70% of thier electric bill was from a PC ROFL at you. Laptops can't be upgraded. Gamers do not like Laptops, and the ones that use them for games COMPLAIN 90% of thier play time.
Desktops are more customizable than laptops. Why would I want to carry around a laptop plus all the extras needed to set it up the way I like? My desktop setup has cordless input and a monitor big enough to watch video comfortably or handle two open Word documents. If I ended up traveling I might someday get a laptop but I don't believe that it would replace my desktop anytime soon.
I love the idea of docking my laptop and using it as my "desktop". I get the benefit of better peripherals without losing the mobility of a laptop. Win-win in my book.
The fact remains that laptops are not "replacing" desktops so much as supplanting them. Everyone pretty much has a desktop, a natural extension is the mobility of that usage. As a PC Tech & Support company owner, I can attest that laptops have a notoriously high failure rate, often completely. Until reliability, and cost of repairs is addressed, I suspect I'll always be a desktop fan.
I switched back to a desktop about 2 years ago for more power and a better (wireless) keyboard. I don't miss the lap top one bit. I kind of like walking away from the computer too.
The person who wrote this is a numb nutzzz. Must be a Mac lover. I can build a killer rig for nothing and if something becomes outdated boom, pow for a small fee just plug in a new better part. Wife is graphic designer and has tried to work on a very high end laptop and all I ever here is the cussing because the thing can't handle all she has to throw at it. So keep the laptops for minor work and Desktops will still be the workhorse for the big boys. Oh and by the way what kind of crap is that I can't sit at my desktop but for 30 minutes but I can sit at my laptop all day. what are you trying to do sit on your head.
My husband has a laptop and I so very much prefer a desk top. It is what I purchased recently for my business and want to purchase for at home too. I do not like the little keyboard or annoying mousey deal. Even with a separate mouse it still flits around the screen at times. They are nice for workahalics who can't seem to survive without a computer at breakfast,bus,lunch,cab etc. Or for a teeny bopper who connects with whoever instead of real conversations but give me a real,stable,usable computer, Thank you for letting me blab.
Netbooks are getting better everyday, i have a Acer One and plug in to a large lcd at home, a good desktop or on the road setup
I have both but I only use my notebook at school, it runs ubuntu and is stable enough for me to rely on it. My desktop PC is were I do all my gaming, watching movies, downloading etc etc. Notebooks are handy but I would never buy a pricey one due to the fact that they are fragile and will get stolen especially at a university setting. I don't think I would ever replace my actual PC with a notebook.
Just a quick comment...I work as a programmer for a very large (160,000+ people) international firm. Because of potential security risks they recently decided that laptops are to be used as little as possible. Considering that this includes our sales people and other 'field' personnel, there is a bit of an uproar. But corporate is adamant; no orders for new laptops are being issued.
wow some people are real defensive about the type of computer they use. But lets all face the facts here people, all people have different needs. There are good and bad points to both. I personally use both. I am a student and work full time so it is nice to take my laptop with me so I can get some of my CAD homework done on my lunch break at work. But if i try running anything else, it generally gets a little pissy. However I never have the problem with my desktop and it is 6 years old with only a few upgrades (little more memory, bigger hard drive). But I am not gonna box that up everyday and take it to work with me. So yeah depending on your needs one or the other is going to work best for you. But I think the point of the article is saying that in general the common person with common needs can get just as much done on a laptop as they can on a desktop.
It is a heck of a lot easier to get "free" nudge, nudge, wink, wink WiFi signal with a laptop than a desk top. It is also harder for folks you know to snoop you files since you can take your laptop with you.
1. Amazing how so many don't seem to realize that you can hook a full-size wireless keyboard and wireless mouse, and full screen monitor, to a laptop. Then you get the best of both worlds. You should never do heavy keyboarding or mousing with the laptop's own devices. 2. So nice to get away from the noisy fan. 3. I work a lot with audio, and still need my desktop for its sound card. But I'll work out a laptop sol'n to that, too. 4. The way LCDs are becoming so dominant, so fast has surprised me. They're still not ideal--not even contrast to suit me. My money (if I had any) would be on OLEDs. And I don't think it'll be long.
To commenter #11... see a desktop connect to any monitor/TV? Easy as pie, in fact, almost any newer video card (made in the last 5-10 years) has an SVID out and an HDTV/HDMI cable out port. I've been connecting one of my desktops to my 42" HDTV for a couple years now. Learn before spew forth ignorance. Desktops will always be ideal for gaming. Who can use the tiny compacted keys of a laptop for gaming? Not me.
They both have their uses. It's much more difficult to build your own laptop than your own desktop, so for that reason I will always prefer desktop. I'd also like to see a laptop that can run Crysis or Oblivion. Gaming is a huge market for computers. I also feel that the keyboards on laptops are too cramped, for the most part. I do want a laptop, though, for work on the go.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
26 Posted by t311solo on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:54PM EDT Report Abuse
If I wanted to use batteries I would go to Radioshack,Sup (: Desktops rock baby!