Tue Jan 20, 2009 7:05PM EST
See Comments (36)
One of the most tenacious myths in the tech world has involved how to delete the data off your hard drive. First off, it's common knowledge that putting a file in the Recycle Bin and emptying the trash does nothing to actually delete the file, you have to overwrite the space where the file once was with something else. But with what?
Paranoid techies will tell you a drive or file has to be overwritten numerous times with random data in order to "securely" delete it. Some say seven times. I've even heard 13 and a whopping 35 times -- just to be sure, they say. (The real nuts don't mess with software and instead tell you to drill holes in the drive to kill it for good... which is awfully wasteful if you ask me.)
But is all that rewriting (which can take days to complete) really necessary? A few years ago I sent a hard drive that had been overwritten with a single pass of zeroes to a high-end professional data recovery firm and they declared all the data on the drive completely unsalvageable, and that's the advice I've given to users ever since: A single overwrite will ensure your personal files are gone for good.
And now I have independent, scientific confirmation: Forensic scientist Craig Wright overwrote drives once under controlled conditions and examined the drive surface with a magnetic-force microscope to see if any traces of data were recoverable. In a nutshell: Nope. If you know exactly on a drive where a byte once existed, the probability of recovering that byte in full is less than 1 percent. And of course, that byte corresponds to a single character of a single file. The odds of recovering even, say, a 10-character string would be infinitesimally small (less than 7.4*10^-21 percent, if you must know)... and even then you'd have to know in advance exactly where to look for the characters in question.
As the linked story notes: Rather than waste time worrying about deleting a file 30 times, you are better off making sure you delete and overwrite all the copies of a file on the hard drive. In Windows, that means regularly deleting temporary files and overwriting free space with zeroes. Of course, if you're wiping an entire hard drive from start to finish, you needn't worry about deleting individual files at all: One overwrite with zeroes will take care of everything.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Yes, those special locations are a worry- if you use standard Windows utilities. Bypass the drivers and write zeroes to absolute track and sector locations. Then wipe the sector / cylinder data. Finish off with a low-level format to create new sectors. Alternatively, put the lot in a huge pulsing magnetic field. If you remove the protective shielding first you can use a smaller field, but you need to keep the platters clean. Of course, deliberately scratching the platters is a fine way to destroy data but re-using the drive becomes problematic.
So how is it, that here in Florida it is always in the news. That someone was arrested, after giving away or selling an old computer. They claim that police are able to recover any and all pornographic images which were many times unknowingly downloaded onto a hard drive. Is this simply media hype, or is it fact? And if this is true, how does it happen that, something can be downloaded "unknowingly?"
Modern drives all have a feature called "secure erase" that overwrites all the data on the disk on power up. Just send it the command and it will overwrite everything. And the encrypted drives from Hitachi, Seagate and Fujitsu have a feature called enhanced secure erase which simply deletes the encryption key, rendering all data immediate cryptographically deleted.
foridude - Because they didn't wipe the drive at all. As for "unknowing" excuses... could be many reasons, but usually people argue that someone else did the downloading, or that they had a virus. It does happen....
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse
Windows saves copies in special locations anyway, so even if you wanted to delete a text file or an image file, it may still be there in a region you cant reach. Throw the drive into a heavy duty chop choker and then grind it into dust. That will get rid of anything on your windows drive.