Thu Jan 11, 2007 8:12PM EST
See Comments (323)
Now that the tech world has had a few days to digest Apple's industry-churning iPhone, it's a good time to step back a bit and dissect the thing. There's no question that, when the iPhone is released this summer, it will be the most advanced and capable phone on the planet...but is that a good thing? Here's a little more on what will probably be 2007's most talked-about gadget.
The OS - The iPhone runs a version of OS X, Apple's standard desktop computer operating system. At first that sounds like cool beyond words...but does it really take a PC OS to make some phone calls? How long will it take the phone to boot up? And how will having such an advanced OS on the phone impact its battery life? These answers are still unclear and won't be hammered out until reviewers have more face time with the device, but my hunch is that the phone's high-power abilities will ultimately outweigh any complexity it has.
Gesture-Based Computing - Remember it's not just a question of the OS, it's how you use it. The iPhone has no buttons, no keyboard, no real external controls: Everything is performed by making taps and zipping your finger along the touchscreen. Called multi-touch, this process will be a revolution in how you interact with the device, which opens up many possibilities...but closes some, too. The big problem? You won't be able to do much with the phone with only one hand, which could be a real pain when you just want to make a quick call.
Wireless - 802.11g Wi-Fi is a good thing, but the lack of 3G service is a terrible oversight. The EDGE data network is simply too slow for regular email usage, not to mention the iPhone's next-generation Internet services like real-time mapping. My spidey sense tells me that iPhone 2 will have 3G front and center in its feature set. It's also worth noting that the iPhone is a GSM phone and only available on the Cingular network. Sprint and Verizon users hoping for a CDMA version shouldn't hold their breath. I highly doubt this will ever happen.
Music - Are people really ready to replace two devices (phone and MP3 player) with one? Signs definitely point to yes on that front, but anyone with an iPod with more than 8GB of storage in it today has got to be disappointed that Apple decided not to create an iPhone with a hard drive in it. On the other hand, the decision to run with flash instead of a hard drive makes perfect sense: Phones get tossed around a lot more than MP3 players, and a hard drive may very well be too fragile for such active use. It would also make the iPhone much heavier. While I doubt 100GB hard drive-based iPhones will appear in the near future, the door's open for 16GB and 32GB models, as flash memory in that density already exists (though at extreme prices). I'd expect these upgrades by the end of the year or mid-2008.
The Cash - Gulp. Then there's the not-so-small issue of price. At $599 for the 8GB phone, the iPhone is out of reach for the vast majority of users who pay $150 or less for their handset. Don't expect prices to fall soon after release, either. That simply isn't Apple's ballgame, and the iPhone will always be a premium product. (Don't expect discounts from Cingular, either. I anticipate that, much like the Nintendo Wii, it will be difficult to find an iPhone on release even at full price.) On the other hand, I've seen $600 (or more) cell phones in the past, and they were hardly anything to write home about.
Bottom line: The iPhone may have flaws, but it is still undeniably cool and will change the cell phone market the same way the iPod changed digital music. There's a reason it was the most talked-about gadget at CES, a show where it wasn't even introduced. I already want one. What about you?
Disclosure: The iPhone is slated to use Yahoo! Mail and oneSearch, which are owned and operated by Yahoo! Inc., which also owns and operates Yahoo! Tech.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Cool device, and Apple lovers will jump all over it, but mostly useless to the other 95% of us. Other than the excellent touchscreen and OSX, it's no different in capabilies than any other smartphone/Blackberry, except it is not enterprise server capable. The overwhelming majority of $400+ phones purchased are by corporations (the company I work for purchased 30k Blackberries last year), and the lack of compatibility hurts the iPhone. Plus most Americans will not pay the $50+/month for data service in addition to their phone service for it to be useful, but I would not be surprised if they sold a million of the iPhones in Silicon Valley alone by the end of the year. I like it, it's another awesone minimalist design by Jobs, but I just do not see a $600 cell-phone (that most people change out every year or two) appealing to the older people who could afford it, and the kids who want it don't have that kind of money.
While the WiFi is nice, the lack of the 3G network features is a serious oversight. It is also far too pricey, but that is Apple for you. This should have been a $200 device. Hopefully we will see different price plans now that AT&T is set to rub out the Cingular brand name come Monday morning.
im pretty sure this will be a big hit for Apple. i already want one!
coolllll can i have one???? puhleeezee!
the cell phone and ipod suk. they dont do anything for you. they are brain washers
Just a shame only for Cingular. I'm on VerizonWireless, and would like to get the iphone, but I'm not gonna switch carriers.
Sounds very good, I think people who have an ipod or want to replace their ipod may go for the iphone because it like an ipod and phone in one device. It will work with itunes too I hope but I know there are sites that work with all mp3 such as www.ipod-vibez.com
cool
$599 dollars for a phone you can't be serious
Nothing impressive here. Apple marketing for the iStupid crowd.
all i went is a phone not all of the bells and whistles that most pople do not use unless your empyoyers are paying your bill.
This phone will beat Play station for sure
Good point about the one-hand issue. I was thinking the same thing. I can pretty much do everything on my Treo now with one hand. Also, not sure if I will stop using my 60 Gig video iPod?...After looking at some bigger issues, the only thing I really like on the iPhone is the real web and html email capabilities. Other than that, I have what I need really with my PSP and 60gig video iPod.
After being on the market for a year or so it will be replaced by somethine else just like every other cell phone...not really all that impressed then again not a fan of the whole touch screen...seen too many problems with them
will the iphone be able to run medical programs such as epocrates and stedmans etc. just curious b/c it would be great seeing that it has an 8 GB harddrive. maybe eventually could sync for electronic records. stylus i think would be nice
I couldn't agree more. As I said on my blog, blendingthemix.com the mobile phone market is just too fast-moving and varied for one device to capture the whole market. Apple had better be prepared to bring out some variations of it to enable it to compete with the vast product range of Nokia and SE. I still want want though and that says a lot about the market as a whole too!
i have stock in apple, stop criticizing and questioning apple, it rules the world and yahoo is but a pee-on in the market
are most of you people retarded.. go on the apple website and watch the introduction to the phone. it will be the best device on the market, an ipod, gps, phone, and computer in one small device. i currently have the razr and that gets 2 hours of talk time, the iphone is going to get 5 hours. if you have ever used a mac, there is barely "boot up" time.
are most of you people retarded.. go on the apple website and watch the introduction to the phone. it will be the best device on the market, an ipod, gps, phone, and computer in one small device. i currently have the razr and that gets 2 hours of talk time, the iphone is going to get 5 hours. if you have ever used a mac, there is barely "boot up" time.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by prakashkondekar on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:18PM EDT Report Abuse
Shallow analysis by Mr Null. Sensible analysis by dgaf_1234.