It's not a netbook!

Wed Jun 3, 2009 12:01PM EDT

See Comments (39)

Q: How do you make the world stop buying so many netbooks?

A: Stop calling them netbooks.

That's the bizarre advice from Microsoft, suggested by one corporate overlord at this week's Computex trade show in Taipei.

His beef? The term "netbook" implies a notebook that is useful only for surfing the net, but since today's mini-notebooks do so much more than just that, the term should be retired.

His suggestion for replacing the term? The exquisitely Microsoftian "low cost small notebook PC."

Semantics in this space are getting increasingly complicated, though whether you call them netbooks, mini-notebooks, smartbooks, or, ahem, low cost small notebook PC, most of these machines do pretty much the same stuff. (The only real difference in this group is the smartbook, a term which is now being used to describe a notebook-type machine that runs a smart phone operating system like Android or, someday, the iPhone OS.)

But Microsoft is doing everything in its power to move the market away from $400 netbooks and toward $1000-plus traditional laptops. Windows 7 Starter Edition, the egregiously stripped-down version of the company's upcoming OS, will be so severely hamstrung that Microsoft has offered the stated goal of encouraging users to upgrade to a more premium version of Windows 7.

The etymological approach is another step in that direction, I suppose, a subtle jab that your computer isn't powerful enough. The term "netbook" sounds kinda cool. "Low cost small notebook PC" sounds like something designed for a child.

As with many of Microsoft's great ideas, my hunch is that manufacturers will nod enthusiastically at the suggestion... and summarily ignore it.

Viva la netbook!

Comments on It's not a netbook!

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 8 Posted by kr_write@ymail.com on Wed Jun 3, 2009 6:56PM EDT Report Abuse

    I like the name netbook. It didn't occur to me that it would just surf the net when I first heard it. Netbook is alot like notebook. I think Microsoft's ideas are silly. I have the acer netbook pictured in your article. I got it for $300 at Walmart. I am very satisfied with it. I can't believe I got such a powerful little computer for such a price and how easy it is to take with me everywhere. I also got the ATT connect card that fits in the USB port. I'm good to go and life is good!

  • 9 Posted by generalche22 on Wed Jun 3, 2009 7:17PM EDT Report Abuse

    You guys have to take under consideration that netbooks are cheap. From the standpoint of a computer savvy person netbooks suck despite their low price tag. But from the standpoint of an average Joe consumer their first thought will probably be "$300 for a laptop! I'll take it!"

  • 10 Posted by kr_write@ymail.com on Wed Jun 3, 2009 7:47PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have a desk top and a reg. notebook computer. I still think the netbooks are a great idea and work well. Of course, the size limits things somewhat. When I got my net book i also had to buy a portable cd writer to install office and one note on it. I consider myself fairly computer savvy so I think people can know something about it and still accept current limitations, for the price and size, netbooks are great. I use mine as part of a home business and also to take to college classes. I love it.

  • 11 Posted by anthonygreavesjr on Wed Jun 3, 2009 10:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    I don't think changing the name will make a difference. Initially, many people were attracted to netbooks because of there user friendly appearance. They have few features and cost much much less than the standard 15" or 17" notebook. Unless you are computer savvy, who wants to pay $1500 for a notebook that has 101 (mostly useless) features, and that seems so high maintenance, you need a degree to use. If microsoft can convince people that larger and more expensive notebooks are just as easy to use as netbooks, more people would buy them.

  • 12 Posted by mrb186 on Thu Jun 4, 2009 7:00AM EDT Report Abuse

    Why bother with a netbook?? Are you kidding me!! 1- They come with XP, NOT Vista (that alone is worth the price) 2- They have as much horsepower as most notebooks did 5 years ago running XP. So why do we need dual processors and 3 gigs of ram?? 3- Very portable and low price = sweet deal 4- 160 Gig HD's, card readers, Bluetooth, XP, Wi-Fi for 350 bucks! 5- You need to check out MSI's U-100 series. (Amazon)

  • 13 Posted by jtfochtxp on Thu Jun 4, 2009 9:18AM EDT Report Abuse

    The Starter Edition of Windows has not been pre-installed on any netbook, desktop or notebook that I'm aware of. Who would want to NOT have the ability to persdonalize their computer, play DVDs and apparently watch movies and music. Also that three app limit is rediculous as well. Apple is probably laughing at any fool that would buy the starter edition of Windows. I mean comon, the ability to customize your computer was a BSIC right that I though every computer user; Mac OR Windows was entitled to. I mean with out the ability to play DVDs and stuff, personalixing the computer is about the only fun thing you can do.

  • 14 Posted by ehtaft on Thu Jun 4, 2009 10:20AM EDT Report Abuse

    mrb186: "They come with XP, NOT Vista (that alone is worth the price)" If you had a good experience with Vista, then an XP netbook is not right for you. Lots of people (including myself) did not.

  • 15 Posted by rebrock@bellsouth.net on Thu Jun 4, 2009 11:13AM EDT Report Abuse

    Netbook, Schmetbook, I just call my Wife's Acer Aspire a mini notebook. If you haven't tried one don't knock it, their actually pretty darned good.

  • 16 Posted by sendmailtoken on Thu Jun 4, 2009 12:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    "...a lot of them run Linux..."??? Um, that's not true. More than 90 percent run Windows. Usually XP.

  • 17 Posted by andrew_tei on Thu Jun 4, 2009 6:44PM EDT Report Abuse

    Netbooks are neat, but I'm not sure about any practically. It seems limited. Seems excellent for trips when needing to store and check photos or video from your camera, check up on a little email, or small little tasks, but this is very limited.

  • 18 Posted by tjc450 on Thu Jun 4, 2009 10:24PM EDT Report Abuse

    i agree vixengal. But I would never buy one... I think there pointless... Sorry Compact Travel PC users.

  • 19 Posted by almazora on Thu Jun 4, 2009 11:21PM EDT Report Abuse

    I got a regular PC at home and in the office, a regular laptop that I tote around during business travel and a "netbook" that comes with me wherever I go. It's really more than a netbook ... its my personal notebook. very convenient to use anywhere and very light to carry around. Plus, it has a very long battery life. It's really a great mini-notebook computer. If if your wondering why so many was sold ... two words, "price and size".

  • 20 Posted by johnsonaija@ymail.com on Fri Jun 5, 2009 3:00AM EDT Report Abuse

    this is retarded dont send anymore of this crap to my email !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!if u do there will b heck to pay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!so dont

  • 21 Posted by wtester100 on Fri Jun 5, 2009 5:27AM EDT Report Abuse

    Netbooks are indeed neat but how practical are they?

  • 22 Posted by thefrostine on Fri Jun 5, 2009 11:32AM EDT Report Abuse

    I agree with o2cmefly. Laptops are small and portable enough without sacrificing performance and ergonomics just so that you can have a ridiculously smaller one. Have you ever tried to type on one of those stupid netbooks? The keyboard is so crammed together that I can barely type without my wrists touching eachother. Plus, I think netbooks look dumb. They're awkward to carry around, like you're stuck between carrying a real laptop or just a PDA or superpowered cell phone around. An actual computer might be a good choice, instead? Yes.

  • 23 Posted by nadiamalkawi on Fri Jun 5, 2009 1:11PM EDT Report Abuse

    ok i'm here but what else any more information about the goal of this i'm realy upset

  • 24 Posted by afuenmayor94 on Fri Jun 5, 2009 2:22PM EDT Report Abuse

    is very useful, and ambientalist.... is very nice, i like it. VIVA LA NETBOOK!!!!

  • 25 Posted by vixengal on Fri Jun 5, 2009 3:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    This note for kr_write, and potential netbook shoppers: You can buy a portable DVD drive for your netbook, but if you don't need it all the time, you can simply create a share for a DVD drive on your desktop or notebook, and use that to install software, load files, etc. If you need a DVD drive all the time, then you're probably better off with a bigger notebook with a built-in DVD drive.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.