Thu Jun 4, 2009 11:50AM EDT
See Comments (17)
How do you pick out a terrorist from the millions of people who board planes each year? You can search through their bags, pat them down, go over their passports and check their IDs, but terrorists, one must assume, are crafty types. Assuming whatever contraband they require has made its way to the plane, all you really have left to ID the perp is what he's got inside his head.
In lieu of brainwave scanners being installed at LAX, the U.S. Army is looking to alternative ways to determine who's got crime on their mind. To wit, the military is looking for proposals for large-scale biometric sensors that would scan travelers and examine their "expressions, gait, and pose" and look for "abnormal perspiration and changes in body temperature" in order to track down evildoers.
It's a lot like a sit-down lie detector, only with the scanning done by a silent "eye in the sky." The idea is essentially that people with something to hide get subconsciously nervous, and that nervousness becomes manifest in excess body heat, sweating, and other erratic behavior. Of course, standard polygraph tests are notoriously "beatable" by prepared test-takers, and it's unclear whether a distant scanning system (even one with extreme zoom capabilities) would be more or less accurate. (While the subject would theoretically be less aware of the scanning going on, the limitations of the scanning would likely make it less thorough than a formal polygraph.)
Naturally, such ideas lead one to wonder about the false positives that might arise due to, say, people arriving late to the airport and running (sweatily) to catch their planes, or the natural confusion and frustration present on many travelers' faces when they find themselves in an airport that's foreign to them or when they have to deal with a couple of screaming kids and long lines at the security checkpoint. Put another way: If you arrive at the airport already upset and angry, you'd be that much more likely to be selected for secondary screening, which will only make you even more upset and angry.
Right now this scanning system is only a research project, and we're likely years away before any serious discussion of actually putting cameras like this into airports begins, and that's if they even prove effective at all. Still, privacy advocates are likely to have a field day shredding this notion, an ominous precursor to Big Brother-like "thoughtcrime" accusations that would make anyone a little uneasy.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Right up there with the dumb idea of having computers "talk" to each other over phone lines.
hmmmm . . . now i don't need a multi-million dollar experimental sweat scanner to know that the woman in the picture looks suspicious . . .
Huuuge waste of money... again... There are way too many unknown factors, and exceptions, for a posture or sweat scanner to be of any use at all. Save those millions for better intelligence on the ground, and stop danger at its source.
. . . this thing will be accused of racial profiling in no time . . . it is common knowledge that certain ethnic groups have more sebaceous glands that other "non"-ethnic groups . . .
oops . . . i meant sudoriferous glands . . .
what happens if you are just hot and sweaty. OH NOES IM A TERRORIST
Whoever thought of that idea should FIRED!!!! That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard and does not make you proud to be an AMERICAN!! What is this world coming to?Wow, way to many STUPID PEOPLE in this world!!!
Of course, the person could also be afraid of flying, horny, worried about someone, nervous about cheating on their wife, excited about an important business meeting or big game. The list could go on forever. This sound even less reliable than lie detectors.People really just need to chill the f*** out. The crips were a bigger threat to national security in the 1990's than terrorist are now. Think about it: membership, funding, people killed, etc. CHILL OUT!!!
I don't think this will do much to prevent terrorists... They're not aware that alot of 'em terrorists are immune to that feeling of anxiety coz they're experts in bombing & killing people... sheeesh!!! You can't depend much on technology to read ppl's mind's & thoughts...
Wow. Whether a good idea or not, it seems one step closer to "1984".
They tried this in Israel but it doesn't work anymore because the terrorists take drugs to pass the scanners.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by wtester100 on Fri Jun 5, 2009 7:48AM EDT Report Abuse
In a way does make sense but there are many who have anxiety disorders, or might be flying in a hurry etc...not sure if this is the best idea.