Mon Jul 16, 2007 3:24PM EDT
See Comments (143)
Here's a trend that has been years in the making. Since the advent of speed dial on land lines, people have been training themselves that memory is unimportant, placing every phone number you could need at the touch of a button. Now science has proven it: Phones, computers, and PDAs are making us dumb.
The stats: A quarter of UK residents (these studies always come out of Britain) don't know their home phone number. Only one-third know the birthdays of their immediate family. Half use one password, exclusively, presumably because they just can't remember any more.
The problem is pretty simple at heart: The less you use your memory, the study says, the worse it gets. The study indicates, shockingly, that people in their 50s and 60s have generally better memory than people in their 30s. Why? The older group was tasked with committing more to memory when they were younger, "training" their brains appropriately. Our gadgets make it simple to offload our memory to electronic devices. That's a good thing when it comes to keeping track of the 1000 people in your address book (each with multiple phone numbers and email addresses), but maybe we're taking it too far?
The good news is that you can exercise your brain without memorizing numbers by rote. Games like Brain Age and Sudoku and other mental stimulation can do just as good a job at keeping your memory sharp (and possibly even ward off ailments like Alzheimer's), the experts say.
Previously: Meetings also make you stupid
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
What constitude dumb anyway? When a reporter found out that Henry Ford had a 3rd grade education and did not know who were the presidents of the US, he was considered dumb. Ford's reply was give him 5 minutes and he'll hire the one who does. How about Einstein?
ok this article is a bunch of bull crap cell phones were invented so thatw e wont have 2 b carrying around a dumb adress book all the time this article should not b called cell phones make us dumb it should just b called cell phones replace ur memory the author of this is probably 4got the meaning of dumb
LOL!! I think i was more shocked that I fit into that category. I'm a Psychologist and honestly, I don't know any of my friends or families numbers by heart. They're all in my cell phone, i know the speed dial number they're all assigned. Technology does make it easy for us to be lazy when it comes to using our brains.
Clearly, there's no way that the introduction of cell phones and other technology in our lives have changed the way "u" and I speak, learn, live. By the way, the education system is not entirely flawed. Yes it is imperfect, but name me one place you'd rather get an education. If you say England you're joking, I've been through the English, Australian, and American systems and they are all just as heavily dependent on memorization as the next. There's a reason for that, take a doctor for example, would you be okay with your doctor having a poor memory? Maybe he didn't quite "memorize" the proper symptoms to be able to "regurgitate" the right diagnosis for your illness. Another important factor in terms of memory. There is a study that claims there is a correlation between Alzheimer's patients and the lack of brain usage. If you don't use your memory, the synapses in your brain do not fire, and thus they break down. Maybe you can at least memorize your phone number, yea?
uhhh yeah thats why all the computer and tech savy people use them so often.....and have the brains to create them...hmmmm dumb article as well as person who constructed the information!
This makes sense. George Bush spends a whole lot of time on the phone.
I think this is really true because like when you use phones.For example say some one told you to save their number and you have no phone or nothing to save it in.Then you can always use your brain for memory and that means that you wont have to forget the number and you can still use your brain to keep track of things so phones wont make you dumb!
so the iphone is still awesome
Just like cars are making everyone fat... right?
this study doesnt prove much in any way shape or form sure we're a little dependent on our electronics, but that doesnt make us stupid this once again proves nothing and also y is not remembering ur home phone number make u stupid i mean come on r u sereous?
andyesquivel is using fallacious reasoning...people in their 50's and 60's had to grow with the technological growth, or not work at all. hmmmm...strongly suspect he is part of the corporate world he decries.
I have personally witnessed phenomena similar to this study. I knew one man, John, who was literally a walking web page. He would emerge from his apartment below mine and blurt out a tag line from the news, then stand there waiting for me to "click on him" by asking more data. Around Los Angeles, at least in the areas I roam, the majority of people I see are "elsewhere", talking to their cell phone or plugged into an MP3 device or staring at the screen of some device. While that does not imply memory loss, it does mean few are "here, now!" I store a total of three numbers on my cell phone. I held out until June 2007 before I even acquired one. The numbers I store are some I seldom use but might need in a pinch. I keep different passwords for almost every site on the web and usually need not refer to my cheat-sheet. Still, I was but a child when television was new and there was no daytime TV - only the evening. Further, TV acting had not yet evolved and TV was really just radio with pictures. I laughed out loud when Bill Clinton promised voters "an information superhighway"! It already existed and was in use by computer-literate people, those who could type a DOS command or deal with primordial Windows. Nothing was pretty or easy, but it was there. In addition to memory loss, I notice increasing claims from parents with children with ADD. No wonder they have no attention spans - childrens network shows give them six minutes of show and then four of commercials. I wonder what result a time measurement of their attention spans would reveal? O well, I cannot change television or movies. They pay me too well!
ihts doesnt really prove anything like taht. besides memory wont make you dumb anyhoww. ihts jus making your memory bad && tahts not a defintion of ta word "dumb" . ihts a whole different point. some people use cell phone becuz iht can be used wen your lost && need help . so this isnt proving anything really. ihts not saying taht ihts making us dumb, ihts simply jus means were gonna having a worser memory bcuz ta moblie phone help us remember more-,-
this is crazy
I think it is not the technology, but our reliance on and usage of it that is causing the problem. Technology never disallowed one to punch in the number rather than picking it up from the address book. Same goes with Nuclear (nucular, sic!) energy.
I would say that this article was helpfull. While on vacation, I lost my cell phone and was completely dis-connected. Asside from the few numbers that I had already memorized, I could'nt get in touch with anyone. But MAKING people dumb? NO, I think that this article only proves that people are getting lazier. I still remember the phone number I had when I was in high school, only because, if I did'nt call home to let my father know I was alright, I would be in a LOT of trouuble! Since my vacation, I have learned to keep a hard copy of all of my numbers on paper or in a notebook. At least the important ones!
Alas!1 What the author apparently doesn't understand is the very value and importance of memory. Why should one remember those hundreds of telephone numbers when they can use the same for remembering something more significant and important. Besides, gadgets exist today not to make us dumb but to enable us to work more intelligently!!!
Um, what does bad memory have to do with dumb?
haha, yeah, we could use less paris hiltons/jessica simpsons around here. :]
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
66 Posted by ladylike3000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:55PM EDT Report Abuse
Based on this article, mobile phones make us LAZY to memorize numbers, or make us lazy, period, but certainly NOT DUMB. A dumb person wouldn't be able to use a mobile phone