Thu Oct 11, 2007 11:23PM EDT
See Comments (10)
Tin whiskers: They sound so cute, so harmless. How could something called "tin whiskers" be one of the most serious problems that will face computing over the next few years? Here's how.
Tin whiskers are tiny filaments of tin, a component of solder, which form on electronics components and cause short circuiting when they bridge from one wire to another. The whiskers form spontaneously and over time, and no one has yet figured out exactly why they grow. And that's the problem... because as electronic components get smaller and smaller, whiskers become a bigger concern. The bridging and short-circuiting effect is simply much easier since components are closer together and the whiskers have less distance they have to cross to cause short the circuit. That's a close-up picture (courtesy Wikipedia) of the whiskers in action (click the pic for a better look).
Tin whiskers are an even bigger problem now because the alternative to tin solder isn't a pretty one: lead. Lead is not as susceptible to the whisker effect, but now that lead has been widely outlawed (in Europe it was phased out in 2006), we're seeing the problem far more than before. That will only get worse as lead is completely eliminated in the U.S.
The solution? For now, nothing. There's no known alternative to lead or tin solder, and since the problem takes months or years to crop up, the issue is largely being ignored. That could change in a couple of years, when failure rates begin to skyrocket with no advance warning. Is your computer crashing for no apparent reason? This might be why.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
I wouldn't count on it. People are more concerned with the environment now than they are at keeping hardware safe. And that is a bigger problem with RHOS compliant hardware as it will fail sooner, thus needing more space for recyclig.
Why not use Silver solder?
Posted by Smokey2000 My plaza TV crashed before it was 2 years old. Every time they put in a new board, it blows a fuse..Could this be from tin wiskers?
#3 Outside of the higher temperatures, silver is just as bad or worse than tin. It is called "Silver migration", and caused severe problems for TI, as well as other manufactures, about 25 years ago.
The Samsung Blast from T-Mobile is a good phone, relatively cheap, and easy to use. How's that possi ...
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 Posted by rogueist on Fri Oct 12, 2007 11:57AM EDT Report Abuse
This is why I warned that RHOS will fail in the end - but that is okay, when the first fully electronically controlled vehicle crashes for "no discernable reason" and more and more follow, eventually they will figure out its the tin whiskers causing a problem. I live in an environment where tin whiskers grow faster than anywhere else (or at least I think so). The life span of most new electronic devices is about 2 to 3 years, then they have to be thrown out and replaced. I just tossed out 6 pieces of stereo equipment yesterday because of this problem. Hopefully someone is actively researching all this.