Tue Nov 13, 2007 11:58AM EST
See Comments (30)
Here's a new one: One Consumerist reader's PlayStation 3 croaked, so he sent it in for warranty service since it was still under its coverage period. A week later, he was told he would not be receiving a replacement. The reason? It had too much dust in it.
This tale gets stranger as you read it. First he's told his console wasn't covered because he didn't have a receipt. (It had been a gift.) Finally, he was told that while it was eligible for coverage, the technicians had peeked inside, taken pictures, and found it simply too dusty to merit coverage under the warranty. He requested the pictures to see for himself. Sony said no, not without a subpoena. (Outraged, he noted that if he were to open the case and taken the same pictures, he would have voided the warranty himself.)
He's now left with two choices: Getting his old (broken) PS3 back or paying $150 for a repair.
Should the writer's dusty PS3 have been covered by warranty? Or did he neglect it by failing to keep the unit in a dust-free area? I expect we'll start to hear numerous additional reports of PlayStations failing due to dust accumulation, a big problem if you leave it running all the time.
The important lesson for you, of course, is to keep your gaming console, and your PC, as dust-free as possible. While you can't open a console case without voiding your warranty, like you can with a PC, you can use a vacuum to suck some of the dust out through the vents even when you can't crack open the box. Of course, also keep the area around your gaming consoles as dust free as possible to keep it from getting inside in the first place.
Click here for more information on dusting and cleaning computer equipment!Â
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
What I find most disturbing about this is that there is really absolutely no proof that there was any dust issue. Their response of "get a subpoena" was what troubles me the most. It is basically saying, "take us to court to prove we are lying and see who wins". Which of course a company which probably pays more for lawyers then some small countries make in a year is going to win. So now I am left with a choice between Sony, Microsoft, or Nintendo. Is it any wonder the Wii and Xbox are kicking the living daylights out of PS3?
The dust thing may or may not be a good reason...without being able to see just how dusty it really was. But that's the point...supposedly they had taken pics? well they should at the very least prove to him it's not a lie and go ahead and send him the photos. My PS3 is running fine and has a little dust on it, sure. I like Sony products but I definitely am NOT a fan of their customer service. However, unfortunately it is rare that I find a product I love that has the service to match, or vice versa(sp?).
Maybe Sony shouldv'e put an external filter on the outside so we wouldn't have that problem. Besides that it sounds like Xbox and Sony are going to do the same thing screw the cosumer. Glad I bought extended warranty at Best Buy...
It's downright abuse actually. Mr. Null, you didn't speak about the terms of the warranty. It said that "acts of God" are not covered by the warranty, which was what Sony claimed the dust was. I find it really sad that Sony did this. I really hope they don't do this with every person who claims this.
I'm with 5.
Do they still make PS3's
HAVE YOU SEEN THE PICS? The pics obviously showed the boy was at fault. No way a PS3 can get that dusty unless it was in some sort of dirthole.
This is why Microsoft and Nintendo will continue to dominate Sony in terms of customer relations and console sales. Microsoft admits their "red ring" mistake and extends everyone's warranty, and I have heard that Nintendo will fixed modded Wii's that have been bricked(removing the chip of course) caused by updating the NTSC system with a PAL update for European games as long as they are under warranty. Sony won't fix one because of some dust? Come on...
I'm with #4 on this one no matter how much u clean there's going to be dust and static electricity is no friend of any electronics Sony needs to pony up Ive been a loyal PS customer since they first came out and i must say i am very disappointed with the way they have been handling things as of late enough so that I'm seriously thinking about XBOX or Wii as an alternative
Ps3 blows anyways. Get the new 360.
well i can say i've delt with the mircosoft coporation technical support and it is one of the best out there in my opinion, i'm agreeing with the people that say sony is at fault because first of all if the PS3 is in a "sealed" environment then how can dust get in, the only way for dust to get in would have to be that he bought the PS3 with dust in it.
I wouldn't touch it let alone repair it. It's NOT too much to ask that a piece of electronic equipment is kept clean of FILTH in order to maintain the warranty. Pick up a duster and clean your house!
This is typical of all Sony's products. They make good products, but lack in support.
I think that we would have to see a picture of this PS3 before we make any conclusion. I know some people who place there consoles in many bad places (camping outside and playing with generator powered stuff) or (placing a PS3 near an open window to "cool it down") So maybe sony looked at it as abuse. I would need to see a picture
i'm a big PS fan was seriously considering buying a PS3 cos i thought it would look great beside my ps2.but after reading this,i will definitely look up an xbox or a wii.seriously bummed by sony.
I agree with the Wii comment! My wii (accidentaly) fell into some water. I dried it off and voliÄ it still worked!
my advice. get a wii, or an xbox. both for less the money, less hassle, but much, much more fun and reliable.
I learned 2 years ago not to buy from Sony.They don't stand behind the hd tv's either.
It appears that the level of quality in the PS3 hasn't changed not one bit. I went through 4 PS2's and my friend had to take his PS2 back a week ago, that he brought for his son's birthday. On those occasions it was the store warranty that covered me and my friend not the factory warranty. That is why I brought an Xbox 360 better quality, better games as well as sharing the same that are available on the PS3 and a much more in depth online network, best in the industry in my opinion. I haven't had a single issue with my 360. Get with Xbox 360, down with Sony their gaming systems have been far overrated for too long all the while providing horrible customer service and poor hardware quality.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by nmkyus123 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:39PM EDT Report Abuse
I live in a college dorm and the AC has no filter. The floor above me is all girls so finding long hair in my room as a guy is normal. The room gets covered in a thin layer of dust every 24hrs. So with that said I would need to clean my computer and game systems every day to keep my warranty b/c of dust. I also have OCD so I clean most things daily but I didn't think of games and PC. It is wrong to say no because of dust that some people can't control.