Blu-ray vs. HD DVD Hits Fever Pitch

Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:52AM EST

See Comments (15)

Every week seems to bring yet another price cut in the high-def DVD world. Late November brought us $99 HD DVD players (which quickly flew off the shelves), and now Blu-ray has dipped below the $300 mark, with one Samsung unit (pictured) selling for a mere $270 at Amazon, $230 off its $500 list price. Can a full-on battle for $199, often considered the "magic number" for consumer electronics, be far behind?

Hardware price drops are only part of the equation, as the studios are pulling no punches in this increasingly expensive battle: Some reports theorize that Warner Brothers may be dropping HD DVD support come January, while speculation continues as to whether Microsoft will integrate HD DVD into a forthcoming Xbox 360 (something it is utterly foolish not to have done with the 360 Elite). Dual-format players continue to arrive, but they simply make no sense: All of them cost far more than buying one of each type of stand-alone player.

But as Ars Technica notes, Joe Average is by and large still sitting this war out, unwilling to pick sides until a winner has been crowned and a single standard chosen. (I know I am.) What's rarely said is that it's not just a question of buying one new DVD player and some discs. I've got four optical disc players connected to TVs throughout my house, plus a portable DVD player for the kids and a half-dozen computers, each with a DVD drive. Upgrading everything to one format or the other would run into the thousands of dollars. What if I pick wrong?

Sure, I probably have more media requirements than other households, but think about your own circumstance. Siding with one format probably doesn't just mean ditching the single, lonely box in the living room... and that's why this war and its stakes are getting hotter than ever.

LINK: Blu-ray vs. HD DVD battle heats up as Christmas approaches 

Comments on Blu-ray vs. HD DVD Hits Fever Pitch

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 8 Posted by m_knopp on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:32PM EDT Report Abuse

    Two aspects which I think get overlooked so often in articles like this is the established market of HDTVs in the average Joe's house and the price of the media. In my close family (cousins, aunts & uncles, and such) only two out of twelve families has an HDTV in the house. So none of them care about an HD-DVD player even less so about Blu-Ray versus HD-DVD. Of the two that do have HDTVs one has a PS3 and the other up samples his DVD collection. The other aspect which makes a difference is the price of the movies. When I look at movies, I can buy the Pirates of the Caribbean 3 DVD for $15 yet in Blu-Ray it cost $23. For Shrek 3 the DVD cost $14 yet in HD-DVD it cost $28. Blu-Ray disc are generally cheaper then HD-DVD and that can be a big difference over a standard movie library which can easily be in the hundreds of titles. Of course both high definition formats are nearly twice what I can buy a standard DVD for and upsample it. Which doesn't require me to rebuy my library which I have been building over the last half decade.

  • 9 Posted by evenbetternb on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:56PM EDT Report Abuse

    Now is a good time to buy a PS3 and get into the Blu-Ray camp. Movie rentals are more readily available (from Blockbuster, where I already have an account). The movies that I'm interested in are available on Blu-Ray, and some will NEVER be available on HD-DVD (keep in mind that Sony owns a movie studio now). It doesn't make much sense to buy movies until the format war shakes out, so I'll be content to rent. The cheapest HD-DVD players only support 1080i resolution, not the 1080p that my new HDTV supports (and PS3 supports). Also, I'll be able to play my old PlayStation games again (and newer High-def PS3 games as well). The older PlayStation games will also look much better in HD! The PlayStation 3 firmware updates will permit future developments in the Blu-Ray format to work on my player. OTOH, cheap HD-DVD players will become obsolete as more advanced features are developed. The way I see it, if I'm wrong about HD-DVD, the players will have dropped to $50 by the time I need to buy one (and the price of HD-DVD movies will have fallen as well). Also, when the $150 million bribe runs out (at the end of next year), Paramount will be returning to Blu-Ray. Had it not been for that bribe (to dump Blu-Ray support), HD-DVD might already be dead. Only Universal was exclusively in their camp. All other studios were supporting Blu-Ray or both formats. The good news is that when the format war is over, many TV shows will be re-released in High-Def, since they were originally recorded on film. P.S. I was in the VHS camp in the '80s, so I have a track record of picking the winners in the format wars. VHS won because of rentals and the ability to record 8 hours on one tape, when Betamax could only record 4 hours. Sony has learned from their past mistakes. You will find that recordable Blu-Ray discs have more capacity than recordable HD-DVD discs.

  • 10 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    According to the specs for the new Xbox releases for next year, they contain HD drives in them. As far as sales of raw units go, HD players are outselling BlueRay players in this area at least by a margin of 4 to 1. I am telling you, its the name. The kids have the BlueRay stuff, but the adults have the HD.

  • 11 Posted by hingarfi on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:19PM EDT Report Abuse

    I agree. One should wait to buy until the HD/BR war is settled. Having said that, I own an HD-DVD player because of the recent lower prices. I have to say that the HD-DVD movies that I rent look great but here is the catch. Regular DVDs look so good on my HDTV (up-sampled in the player to 1080), that I am not sure the HD-DVD was really worth it. If BR wins and players drop to $150, I'll probably buy one.

  • 12 Posted by robertgsummers on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    I bought an HD DVD player for under $200 shipped with 7 free HD DVD because my DVD player was starting to do the stutter thing before they go out. I can't buy a good upgrade DVD for much under $100 so I saw no reason to wait, but that is just my opinion

  • 13 Posted by stepupandfight05 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:41PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have a 1080i HD Monitor in my living room and I really wanted to be able to watch HD Movies for such as Transformers, and Knocked up (both happened to be on HD DVD) well I have an XBOX 360 so I decided to purchase the add on for the 360 (this is before the Toshiba one was 98 bucks) I have been just fine with it. If I feel the need to get a Blue Ray player then I will buy one. There is no since in make this a big long "war". The way I see it consumers should just get what best suits them, not split of into two gangs. Yea thats right I said gangs because that is the way they are acting. It doesnt matter what format is better, or cheaper or how many companies it has backing it up. If one wins ,then Oh well we will just have to deal with it. Even if one does win it is not going to "die". For instance The Bourne series, in say two years, lets say HD DVD loses, does that mean that if all I have is a Blu Ray and an ancient regular DVD player that I wont be able to buy The Bourne Ultimatum in anything but standard DVD (which will still be around probably, cause heck its been 15 years and I can still buy a VCR for 30 bucks) No!!!! they will have no choice but to release it on blu ray. Get my drift... the same will happen if HD DVD "wins". My advice is buy what best suits you, your family and your home theatre system because in the long run whoever loses we "the consumer" still wins!

  • 14 Posted by ljbanner on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    the only people buying at the moment are the hardline movie and games fans.being a hardline movie fan myself i want the best experience from my setup so i am taking the jump to hd dvd and leaving the bluray to the gamers. with the added cost of manufacturing blu ray there is only one place the cost can be offset and that is the consumer.as my mother always said if its not broke dont fix it.

  • 15 Posted by tpk294507 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:18PM EDT Report Abuse

    As a causalty of the VHS/Beta war (still own the most expensive Sony Super-Beta machine they ever sold), I didn't hestitate this XMAS to add a Sony's Blue-ray player their latest generation Sony 1080p LCD TV. No way was Sony going to get KO'ed again! FYI, Blu-Ray disks look fantastic ... plus Sony sends you 5 Blu-Ray disks for buying their player. Like getting another $100+ discount on the player. Blu-ray is the way to go.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.