Thu Dec 13, 2007 11:21PM EST
See Comments (19)
This is why you have to suffer with Windows Genuine Advantage on your computer: So Microsoft can track down people to sue. The company has now filed 74 cases in 23 countries against counterfeiting rings selling illegal copies of Windows.
Fifteen of the lawsuits target a Chinese group that Microsoft calls the "largest-ever commercial counterfeit syndicate." This group alone, says Microsoft, was manufacturing software, which, if real, would have been worth nearly half a billion dollars.
The real news is how Microsoft tracked these criminals down: Using the reviled WGA software that is now a mandatory part of XP and Vista. When systems fail their WGA validation checks, that sends a flag to Microsoft to investigate further. Presumably, repeated failures with the same or similar license keys can lead Microsoft down a path to discover the identity of the counterfeiter.
I find this news difficult to parse and digest. Yes, counterfeiting is bad, and Microsoft should use every means at its disposal to track it down and stop it. But why does that have to include me? Though I've never used anything but legitimate copies of Windows, WGA has been nothing but a headache, and in some cases, it's caused severe problems that have stopped people from being able to use their computers. I can't help but think that Microsoft should have plenty of other means to track down counterfeiters without inconveniencing, and even outright harming, its users.
LINK: Failed WGA checks lead to a barrage of antipiracy lawsuits
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
I'm old and confused. If Microsoft runs WGA on my system one time and verifies I'm using a genuine copy of XP or Vista, and if I don't change the product key, hard drive, CPU, memory, or anything else that would put up a red flag, why the need to constantly scan my machine? Does MS believe I'm going to take my genuine XP Pro and suddenly say, "Gee... I think I'll install this counterfeit version today."
Microsoft should charge reasonable prices for their OS, and provide people with actual install DVDs when they buy a pc, like Apple do - then they might not be ripped off as much - but then, they ought to stop making their OS altogether as it's so bloody awful!
Yet another reason to use open source software. If you use XP and do not want the hassle of WGA after an initial install, disable the WGA by choosing custom update options and finding the WGA update and choose not to install it at that point as well as ignoring the WGA during future updates. Keep in mind though, for your own peace of mind, always use a valid Windows disk which should have a holographic front or, if it's from Dell, either a green or purple front. If all else fails, give Linux a try :-)
What is mentioned only in passing in this story is that the Chinese are the one's who are doing economically what they are scared to do militarily. Namely, attempting to destroy the West. You can go ahead and slam MS and for many things it is well deserved. What you should not do is slam MS for protecting its intellectual property since that is what makes capitalist systems work. It is not just MS who is faced with massive Chinese counterfeiting. All of the big entertainment and technology companies are feeling the pinch put on them by Asian syndicates who are flooding the US market with counterfeit goods. If you like lead in your kids toys and poison in your dog food, then I guess none of this means anything to you, but those of us with a longer view of things are rightly concerned about China not playing by the rules that Western corporations have been playing by for many years and which protect our economy and YOUR economic well being. Oh, and yes, you can thank corporate greed and consumer greed for alot of this too.
It's actions taken by a relative monopoly to keep their money. 'Nuff said.
MS could give away their OS for free, then charge for updates and support. Do away with new versions, just evolve/update. They are already doing it with their Live OneCare product. Accommodating the customer is the name of the game!
my computer just crashed and I cant recover it! I am traveling in Japan and MS let me down. Its time to buy a MAC!
Although I have a number of original licenses for my computers (but only one sandwich-toaster for all the members in my family! Think about that!), I think I will buy no more MS licenses. Can anyone imagine the hassle in recovering the data from an encrypted hard-disk after my MSI BookPC motherboard crashed? Yes, it is an all integrated motherboard..and the danged windows license thinks I am trying to install windows on a different PC. Dumbasses..of course it is now a different computer! Albeit using the same hard-drive and optical drives. And I have a license and original disk I cannot use anywhere else? No way, and NEVER again...and especially with the LAUGHABLE Vista. My goodness what a boo-boo. I am an accomplished electronics technician and PC USER, and I tell you, I spent HOURS looking to bring up the Microphone input on the mixer to connect my guitar to the sound-card...try it out (hahaha...sorry for laughing) Guys, try open source. Let's be honest, what do you use your PC for mostly? I have turned to the PS2 for games, and just use my PC for office work and internet browsing, as well as the obvious media playing, which is handled extremely skilfully by even the smallest linux distro. Start by using a LIVE Linux CD every now and then. You will be pleasantly surprised, I am sure. I will just leave my notebook PC with XP, and that is just for compatibility with the kids school stuff. Ah...what a relief.
Here's a tidbit for you: you don't have to pay the high price, but you don't have to resort to illegal software, either. At work, I just used my Staples rewards, and got Office 2007 Professional Edition for a whopping $2.59, no that's not a typo on the decimal point. We buy all our supplies from Staples, we are in the new uncapped rewards category. The price of the order you are using your rewards on has to exceed the value of the rewards coupon. I waited for a sale, ordered online, deducted my rewards, and paid the excess, I'll spell it out in words this time: Two Dollars and Fifty Nine cents. Can't beat it. The 2007 edition of Office is so intuitive, you know what you're doing before you realize you know what you're doing...no more painfilled transitions to the new editions.
What I don't like is Microsoft is forcing legitimate users to install their 'genuine advantage tool' and users can't download via the automtic updates for their PP system. I complained about this but still haven't got an answer from microsoft! In other words their is no coordination between different factions of their company! [XP user]
Why are we all surprised to learn this information, Microsft has been doing this for years. in fact, Micrisft is notourious for sending little wizzards into peoples computers and including "Spy" software with it's software that it sells, to hunt these peole down. I mean hey Microsft makes enough money so what's a few million copies going to hurt, HE'S RICH ENOUGH!!!!!!!!!!!!
Scary stuff!
I feel so sorry for the poor greedy ----- s
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by lillgad on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:51PM EDT Report Abuse
Bought a used desktop Dell on ebay, with recovery disk, computer worked fine until I attempted to install Service Pack 2, and found the OS (XP Professional) was a VLP to some corporation and I would have to buy a new OS Disk for the special offer of 149.00. Recovery disk is not for this system. I junked the damm thing and bought a new HP with XP Home.