Wed Jul 9, 2008 11:29AM EDT
See Comments (64)
Has the battle to create a dream product to link online digital media to the TV quietly been won? Despite competition from just about everyone—Vudu, Apple, TiVo, Xbox, and more—humble Roku, which released its Netflix Player set-top box barely over a month ago (making it a distant latecomer to the game), sold out of its first shipment in three weeks. Demand is so strong that the company is air-freighting new units to the U.S. in order to keep up.
Almost thrown off as an aside in a Forbes story about Netflix's online ambitions, Roku VP Tim Twerdahl mentions that later this year the $99 box will be upgraded to stream content from other providers aside from Netflix. (The upgrade will be a simple software download that will enhance existing boxes.) That would make it the first major set-top box to hook into multiple services and could turn what is already a very good product into a category killer.
Even without the extra features, the Roku box is already a hit, and I think it's because it's embraced the idea of simplicity. There's nothing complicated or even sophisticated about the Netflix Player. There's no display on the box, and the remote control is reminiscent of the original Zenith "clicker." Next to famously "simple" products like TiVo and the Apple TV, the Roku player makes them look like baffling mainframe computers in comparison. Anyone who can plug in their television should have no problem setting up the device.
Naturally, the price is another huge boon for the product. At $99, it's cheaper than dinner and a movie. Since the service is free if you already have a Netflix account, what possible objections could anyone have to hooking one up?
Add in more streaming options and the Roku gets even better. Roku teases us by not mentioning exactly what services it will link to, though; they are described only as "other 'big name' providers." My only concern is that the box needs to retain its simple nature. If I have to input a credit card number using a remote with no number buttons on it, I'll unplug it in disgust.
Meanwhile, Netflix is wasting time with other set-top box providers (including Microsoft's Xbox), all of which is just a distraction that keeps it from adding to its 10,000-movie library available for streaming. Does anyone really watch movies on the Xbox 360 as it is? The fan is so loud it drowns out the dialogue.
Memo to Netflix: Stick with the Roku. Expand the library. Dominate the market.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
I am very excited about the Netflix/Xbox360 availability. For one, I dont have to worry about yet another component in my ever expanding entertainment center. Another reason I like it is that I already use the xbox360 media center capability that exists. Running Netflix sounds like a natural progression into this realm. Plus, no additional remotes to clutter the living room. And less switching of my amp from input to input. Its a win-win for me. But I do agree that Netflix needs to add more movies to its database.
The fact that there are a significant lower amount of titles makes this box not worth it...
If you have to watch a movie with the sound that low that you can even hear the xbox, then you're too old to watch it. Plus, a lot of people watch movies on the xbox, because you can stream them from your xbox to your computer, even if they are rented. ^______^
Actually that sound you hear from your Xbox is the disc drive spinning, not the fan. Thats why you wont hear it when you turn your xbox on with no disc in and are just using the menu. The xbox, including the fans, are almost silent when doing anything except loading/reading from a disc.
The fan doesn't run when movies are playing on the Xbox 360. Mine is very quiet when a game is not running. I'm sure this guy tried that before he wrote the article though.
yea netflix on 360 has been confirmed... you can download videos of it on xbox 360... also the fans really arent that bad... i watch movies on my xbox all the time and i have a dvd player sitting right under it.. i hardly ever notice and im excited for netflix on xbox so think about some1 other then urself when you tell netflix to stick to there Roku
Ive said many times before...netflix gets it. Is the selection great...no..Companies do want to sell DVDs but if you are like me and most are it is impossible to see every tv series and older movies...this box gives the chance 30 rock rockford files law and orders etc on demand and also you can take the bo with you anywhere the is a high speed internet....I got mind as soon as it was advertised and love it. Most important they could have charged more the box and they didn't...the biggest problem will high speed cable providers who will probably start capping our usage once this gets very popular
"$99 is cheaper than dinner and a movie"? That's an pretty nice dinner! He probably meant dinner and a movie for two. The Edwards theater in my neighborhood charges $10 per ticket, so that leaves $40 each for dinner, or less if they want to use some of the $100 for popcorn and candy at the movies. $100 isn't much these days.
I like watching movies on my 360 mostly because it lets me stretch the image to full screen. I don't like black bars on the top because I have an old plasma and am worried about burn in. I don't care if the characters look fat due to bad aspect ratio. I don't think the fan is all that loud, either. The only time I ever hear my xbox 360 fan is while playing Halo3. I wonder if Netflix will have "Perfume - Story of a murderer" in high-def. It's available on the 360 in HD but is not available on HD DVD or BluRay.
I got the box when it first came out and I LOVE IT. Everything is very simple and right at your fingertips. I do wish Netflix would add more newer release movies. But all in all it is Great !!
Wouldn't this also work on the PS3? It has no fan noise, no disc tray noise, and has a decent UI. This box along with TVersity makes it a good choice.
I get the same thing but without the box. I have a video cable running from my computer to my T.V. and I only had to buy the longer cable for $9 total.
That is a nice device, though i think Netflix should work with Sony for streeming movies on game consoles. The PS3 is awesome. i always rent Blu-Ray DVDs and watch them on my PS3. Its awesome and Netflix should consider Sony rather than Microsoft (Not that 360s arent good, it just cause of the noise of the fan and all the things people complain about.....so far there werent any negative reports on PS3)
I had this unit less then 30 days. Out of the box it worked perfectly. About three weeks later it would no longer retreive my que from Netflix. I had to deal with India to try and troubleshoot. After an hour on the phone they had to escalate the issue and I never heard back from them. I called Roku to return the box within the 30 day Money back gurantee and they agreed. By the way the return system runs thru India. I will wait until they improve their customer service. FF
This is great I can not wait to get one. Debbie http://www.NationalShowTickets.com
Does anyone really watch movies on the Xbox 360 as it is? Sure do... I watch Movies, Southpark, Aquateen Hunger Force to name a few... All without leaving the comfort of home.. And oh yeah.. MOST of the titles on the 360 are in HI-DEF already..
Wait a minute, you can already stream movies to a computer with a Netflix account. BUT, the movies are old and second rate. Don't think you're going to be watching new releases on this player.
Two things. One, $99 diner and a movie? What part of the country do you live in? I can buy a DVD player and DVDs and still have enough left over to take my wife out for that much. Two, I have two 360s and watch lots of movies on both of them. With my surround sound on nobody can hear the fans and when you do they are nowhere near as loud as my PC. I would much rather stream movies with my xbox than my PC!
Yes i do watch movies on my xbox360 and i love it!
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
26 Posted by cliffistheman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse
I watch DVDs on my Xbox. The one before the 360. It's my DVD player.