Hulu: All-you-can-eat TV shows, movies - and ads

Wed Mar 12, 2008 12:20PM EDT

See Comments (67)

After several months in private beta, Hulu-a portal to hundreds of free, streaming TV shows and scores of movies-is finally open to the public. But while you can watch and even embed clips from shows to your heart's content, you'll have to deal with ads aplenty.

I had a chance to check out Hulu (a joint venture of NBC and News Corp., the owner of Fox) last fall, while it was still in beta. The site itself doesn't look all that different now. It still boasts a clean, clear layout for easy navigation, along with a slick video player that lets you zoom in to a full-screen mode.

Now that Hulu is open to the public, however, it's stacked with way more content. The site hosts about 250 TV shows, including hits like "The Office, "30 Rock," "House," "Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles," and "Heroes." It's also got a truckload of older shows, such as "The A-Team," "Adam-12," the unfortunate "Galactica 1980," "Hart to Hart," and "Remington Steele."

Also new are a slew of free movies, including some hits ("The Big Lebowski," "Dude, Where's My Car?" "Mulholland Drive," "Sideways," and "The Usual Suspects") and some misses ("All Dogs Go to Heaven 2," "Attack of the Puppet People"). For other movies-including "Alien 3," "Garden State," "Juno," and "Office Space" ("Did you see the memo?")-only clips are available.

Another cool feature is Hulu's Flash-powered HD "gallery," which for now offers about 20-odd movie trailers. The HD video quality (at 720p) is excellent-clips load quickly with little in the way of pixilation or other obvious artifacts. ABC streams full HD episodes of "Lost" and "Desperate Housewives," but its streams are a little touch-and-go, especially for those with so-so bandwidth.

Meanwhile, the standard TV and movie streams look OK, if not great. TV streams look a bit pixilated, but the video itself looks smooth enough, with a minimum of stuttering. Movie quality on Hulu is pretty variable-some of the movies I saw were in their original aspect ratios, some were panned-and-scanned, others were actually windowboxed (that is, big black bars surrounding the video). That said, all the films-even the R-rated ones-are uncut.

As before, everything is free, and you can even edit clips from the show and embed them into your own website-that way, you get the video, and Hulu gets credit (and presumably, revenue) for the traffic.

Of course, there's a catch: non-skippable ads.

For TV shows, you'll have to deal with four to five commercial interruptions for an hour-long episode, or seven-plus commercials for a two-hour movie. (Clips also begin with a pre-roll ad.) The ads themselves are only about 15 seconds each, and for now there's only one ad per commercial break. (In some cases, you won't see an ad at all.)

That said, I'm sure those commercial breaks will start filling up. And indeed, from everything I'm hearing, advertisers are lining up to buy spots on sites like Hulu.

While I would rather pay a couple bucks for a commercial-free TV episode (or more for a commercial-free movie rental), it sounds like free, ad-supported TV and movies may well be the wave of the future. Guess we'd better get used to the idea.

Let's also keep in mind that Hulu isn't the first site to offer free TV episodes over the Web. Other networks have streamed shows online for months now. Indeed, some of the bigger players-notably ABC and CBS-haven't signed on with Hulu.

What would I like to see from ad-supported video sites like Hulu? A more complete video library, for one, since most of the TV series listed only have streams for a handful of recent episodes (on purpose, apparently, to avoid "cannibalizing" DVD sales).

Also, why not allow downloads to portable media players? Services like the new NBC Direct already allow for PC-only downloads, but nobody is offering free, ad-supported downloads for iPods or other portable players.

Anyway, check out Hulu and report back with your thoughts. Like what you see? Can you live with the ads? What's missing?

Comments on Hulu: All-you-can-eat TV shows, movies - and ads

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 46 Posted by wxyz613 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    Does anyone know of a site that makes hulu videos available overseas, i.e. copies the videos and places them online for open access?

  • 48 Posted by zlatkoshajnoski on Thu Sep 3, 2009 11:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    Unfortunately videos cannot be watched by people living overseas.

  • 49 Posted by leighsajones01 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:48PM EDT Report Abuse

    if you had a SanDisk V-Mate you can download for free and play on your portable media devices... I do for My PSP .. I love it... it works like a VCR Its great.

  • 50 Posted by tvshogal on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    I like most Americans living abroad are furious. I live in Canada. Half the shows on Hulu are SHOT IN CANADA. It is infuriating that in this day and age clearance rights for ALL NORTH AMERICA were not attainable immediately. And when NETWORK sites such as ABC offer free viewing of popular shows they also BLOCK ALL NON US IP addresses, but NOT UNTIL AFTER THE ADS have run. SO I can sit thru an add for Del taco doesnt exist in Canada but then I m told I can't watch the actual eppy of Desperate Housewives because I m not in the US?? And ABC gets to COUNT my click towards "viewership" so they can charge DEL TACO higher ad rates. At least Hulu does let you know upfront their service is only available if you live in the US! But what is also confusing is WHY, Canadians can't access the service since many of the shows are already viewable on TV in Canada. In other words the clearance rights already exist for TV, one form of distribution, I am to believe they do not exist for ANOTHER form of distribution such as ONLINE? Utter nonsense. Europeans, do not hold your breath for Hulu anytime soon. USE I TUNES. Hulu may have some value to some people, but I don't want or need to sit thru ads. I can watch all my fav shows from past and present on tv, and using a DVR I can tape the shows and SKIP over the ads. Also Hulu doesn't stream first run eppys on the day of broadcast... you have to wait until an eppy has aired on tv before viewing it on Hulu. And if they have to wait to air complete series in order to avoid cutting in on DVD sales, then why was Hulu created in the first place. The revenue generated from online ads should be more than enough to offset the small loss of revenue from lower DVD sales or rentals.Sounds like a poorly thought out cash grab.

  • 51 Posted by branka20 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:12PM EDT Report Abuse

    Like thousands of Americans living abroad, I would love to watch shows in my own language. Even commercials in American English will be welcome. I'm not talking abouts downloads, just let us watch something from home!!!!!

  • 52 Posted by butcho1954 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:15PM EDT Report Abuse

    Yeah right. This will drive all cable operators bankrupt.

  • 53 Posted by cinerama144 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    I want my first posting to be about something meaningful that addresses a serious issue that we all face on a daily basis. With that being said, I would like to air my grievances to the model citizens that run nbc.com. I want to ask: why the heck are you trying to turn the web into an extension of television? Do you think while I%

  • 54 Posted by sandbplayhouse on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    What about the US citizens overseas? We are the ones that need this type of service. I can't understand why someone that could sit in there house in front of a TV would want this service. But, the ones like me, overseas would love to have it. There is a big problem with that of product. Don't worry we will still keep you safe while you use it.

  • 56 Posted by cleveled on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:26PM EDT Report Abuse

    I use a 24" widescreen H-D monitor and having watched several of the movies, I'm impressed. The commercials are very short and not a major deal. Hopefully, more shows and movie will be added to the selection.

  • 57 Posted by pleduc@rogers.com on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:14PM EDT Report Abuse

    American TV shows shown on Canadian TV networks, will have the American ads replaced with Canadian ads. We rarely see American ads on Canadian TV, even though the TV show is a direct feed from the US. Unfortunately, HULU has not resolved this, and this service is blocked in Canada. Seems odd that HULU has been in beta for so long and we still cannot use it in Canada.

  • 58 Posted by pelguy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:05PM EDT Report Abuse

    Well, after reading this artical, i decided to give Hulu a shot. I have watched Fox's video feeds to catch up on missed episodes and found it tollerable. Hulu seemed just as capable, if not a little more user friendly. As far as the ads, well yes a bit annnoying, but with only 2.5-3 min of ads per hour episode, i found them easy to live with. To be honest, i spend that much time fast forwarding thru the ads when I watch something on my DVR. I look forward to more content, but for a new service i found plenty to keep my interest. The video quality was quite good, and the only pixelation i ever noticed, happened to, Ironicly, be during the ads.. I was however disapointed the the one movie i watched ( Master and Commander) was in a pan and scan format and edited for content and time conciderations. The only difficulty i came accross was one episode did not load properly on the first try. That was corrected with a second attempt ( better than my home cable servive) Overall, I was impressed with the service. To those networks who do not have content on this service, I must say.....I have found a new show I Ignored until today. NBC has a good show in "Life".. One i never would have taken the time to see in not for Hulu. So i belive that it is a good investment to explore, the streaming video market. Mind you if they keep the amount of ads at there present.

  • 59 Posted by summerlover97 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:47PM EDT Report Abuse

    I would check and double check your computer for viruses after using this site. I tried it out and suddenly my antivirus showed that I had 13 trojans installed on the computer. It's the only site I have gone to recently that is different than the other sites I visit on a regular basis. I run the antivirus everyday and the other ones have not been a problem. Anyway, just a word of caution to all users of this site.

  • 60 Posted by nstern302 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:42PM EDT Report Abuse

    If the internet is being run like a TV station, then there should be federal guidelines for when and what can be shown to children. I don't see that filtering is available especially on visual content. It is a crime to manipulate the minds of the young without boundaries or recourse.

  • 61 Posted by cary39 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:19PM EDT Report Abuse

    I was a tester of Hulu beta and everything was great. Then they added the commercials. I don't mind a few commercials, but why do they have to be so LOUD? I was watching some movies and they just stuck the commercials right in there without fading or any thought as to position. Then your ears get blasted by an add from Chili's, then it goes right back to the movie mid conversation. If they fix this, I can live with it.

  • 62 Posted by moveleft on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Hulu: a dumb name for something that might have been cool three years ago. I participated in the private beta and am shocked at how little they changed. This is what took them months to create?. I have not forgiven greedy Hulu co-founder NBC for pulling their content from iTunes. Thankfully, I watch nothing on NBC but I do miss "Battlestar Galactica" downloads on iTunes. The series airs on NBC-owned SciFi and was among the shows pulled in NBC's revenue dispute with Apple. In my opinion, the best site offering free, ad supported series streams is abc.com. ABC has been streaming free episodes of their series (from "Lost" and "Desperate Housewives" to "Ugly Betty" and "Grey's Anatomy") for more than THREE YEARS! What took Hulu so long to come up with an inferior product? The video quality on the ABC site is excellent and there are fewer commercial interruptions than Hulu. ABC also has a more elegant, intuitive interface. Unlike Hulu, ABC offers FULL SEASONS of their shows online (and past seasons of some titles). Some of the series also offer an HD option. I have not encountered any of the problems with the HD stream that the writer mentions here. I have a DSL line which is fast but certainly not the fastest home connection available. Still, for my money, you can't beat iTunes. You can watch on an iPod, computer or widescreen TV if you have the AppleTV box (which I love). I like the versatility and, with TV series episodes priced at a very fair $1.99, the quality is top notch and there are no commercials. It's also cool that ABC and the other major networks have not followed the NBC model. I get what NBC is trying to do...aggregate all of their content in one or two places that work best for THEM. Sadly, consumers have made it clear that they want to watch programming where and when they want. That's why ABC, CBS and FOX make programming available in many locations online, thereby giving consumers options. A couple of errors and overstatments that The Gadget Hound made in his article: you cannot "edit clips" from the shows on Hulu. The site offers a standard embed option that allows you to drop an entire episode or clips THEY have chosen onto your website or MySpace page. This is nothing new. I'm not sure what he means by the Hulu video player being "slick" as it's pretty standard fare with a full screen mode that leaves A LOT to be desired. I have two new, top of the line computers and the Hulu full screen image looked muddy on both my PC and Mac. Finally, the HD gallery is nothing more than a collection of movie trailers. Apple has offered a much wider selection of movie trailers on their site (apple.com/trailers) for several years and most are also available in HD. Played side by side, the stream from Hulu was no faster than the stream from Apple. The quality of the HD image was much better on the Apple trailer site, even when blown up to fill the screen on my 23" monitor. Hulu just seems like its a day late and a dollar short on all fronts.

  • 63 Posted by moveleft on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Hulu: a dumb name for something that might have been cool three years ago. I participated in the private beta and am shocked at how little they changed. This is what took them months to create?. I have not forgiven greedy Hulu co-founder NBC for pulling their content from iTunes. Thankfully, I watch nothing on NBC but I do miss "Battlestar Galactica" downloads on iTunes. The series airs on NBC-owned SciFi and was among the shows pulled in NBC's revenue dispute with Apple. In my opinion, the best site offering free, ad supported series streams is abc.com. ABC has been streaming free episodes of their series (from "Lost" and "Desperate Housewives" to "Ugly Betty" and "Grey's Anatomy") for more than THREE YEARS! What took Hulu so long to come up with an inferior product? The video quality on the ABC site is excellent and there are fewer commercial interruptions than Hulu. ABC also has a more elegant, intuitive interface. Unlike Hulu, ABC offers FULL SEASONS of their shows online (and past seasons of some titles). Some of the series also offer an HD option. I have not encountered any of the problems with the HD stream that the writer mentions here. I have a DSL line which is fast but certainly not the fastest home connection available. Still, for my money, you can't beat iTunes. You can watch on an iPod, computer or widescreen TV if you have the AppleTV box (which I love). I like the versatility and, with TV series episodes priced at a very fair $1.99, the quality is top notch and there are no commercials. It's also cool that ABC and the other major networks have not followed the NBC model. I get what NBC is trying to do...aggregate all of their content in one or two places that work best for THEM. Sadly, consumers have made it clear that they want to watch programming where and when they want. That's why ABC, CBS and FOX make programming available in many locations online, thereby giving consumers options. A couple of errors and overstatments that The Gadget Hound made in his article: you cannot "edit clips" from the shows on Hulu. The site offers a standard embed option that allows you to drop an entire episode or clips THEY have chosen onto your website or MySpace page. This is nothing new. I'm not sure what he means by the Hulu video player being "slick" as it's pretty standard fare with a full screen mode that leaves A LOT to be desired. I have two new, top of the line computers and the Hulu full screen image looked muddy on both my PC and Mac. Finally, the HD gallery is nothing more than a collection of movie trailers. Apple has offered a much wider selection of movie trailers on their site (apple.com/trailers) for several years and most are also available in HD. Played side by side, the stream from Hulu was no faster than the stream from Apple. The quality of the HD image was much better on the Apple trailer site, even when blown up to fill the screen on my 23" monitor. Hulu just seems like its a day late and a dollar short on all fronts.

  • 64 Posted by moveleft on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Sorry for the previous double post!! BTW, to all those complaining about not being able to watch content on Hulu because they live in Canada or abroad: I'm pretty sure you are blocked from the site because of all the complex issues involved in content distribution and syndication outside the US. Shows cleared for broadcast in the US are not necessarily made available at the same time for viewing outsidethe US. Also, there are many times when foreign distribution rights to a series or movie actually belong to a different entity than the rights holder in the US. I suspect that is why you can't watch shows on Hulu outside the US (just like the content available on iTunes varies from country to country).

  • 65 Posted by bdtang on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:04PM EDT Report Abuse

    I actually am a big fan of hulu.com... weird name but cool service that is currently free. I seldom watch "live" TV anymore b/c of time issues as well as the number of commercials that live TV has... come on - 20 minutes of commercials for an hour show? With hulu, as stated in the article, 4~5 commercial breaks that last ~30 seconds - for a total of 2~3 minutes? And also, just saw that they enabled a new method - agree to watch a longer ad at the beginning and watch the show commercial free - (the ad I watched was a trailer for Hellboy 2 - which was quite entertaining anyways)... Their interface is pretty cool and easy to use and better than ABC.com in my book which requires you to click to continue after a commercial which often breaks and starts the clip all over again. It would be nice if all of the networks/studios play nice and have 1 portal that has access to all content regardless if they are from ABC/NBC/CBS/Fox. Hulu is definitely heading in the right direction.... I'll definitely sacrifice watching a few commercials given the time savings compared to live TV or trying to search and download the content through torrents.... would be nice if they allow me to select the type of commericials I like versus making me sit through non-relevant ones (for example - drug ad to help you stop smoking - I don't smoke and don't intend too - but would be cool for me to see tech ads or movie trailers.

More Posts: First Prev 2 3 4 5 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.