Tue Apr 1, 2008 12:27PM EDT
See Comments (716)

LAS VEGAS - With its sleek design, flashy menus, haptic feedback, and full-on 3G access, this touchscreen delight for Sprint users looks to be one of the strongest iPhone competitors to date. Read on for my hands-on impressions.
Announced Tuesday here at CTIA, the Instinct (set for release in mid-June)
looks like a virtual clone of the iPhone, but it delivers many of the features
missing from Apple's red-hot handset, including 3G access for speedy browsing
and downloads, a replaceable battery, expandable memory, and haptic feedback
for the touchscreen - that is, a slight vibration each time you tap the screen.
This key feature is sorely missing on the iPhone.
I got an early, hands-on look at the Instinct a couple of weeks ago in New
York, and I have to say, it's the most impressive iPhone contender I've seen
yet-or at least until I try out LG's
touchscreen Vu, which is also set to debut here at CTIA.
The Instinct certainly scores in the looks department, with its smooth,
jet-black face (Ã la the iPhone) and 3-inch display, along with three
keys-Back, Home, and Call-just beneath.
Measuring 4.6" by 2.2" by 0.49", the Instinct is a tad narrower
but a bit thicker than the iPhone, and it's also a bit lighter, weighing in at
4.4 ounces.
The Instinct's sleek, animated touch interface looks promising, if still a bit
rough-and-ready. The unit I tried was still in the testing stage, so I'll hold
off on direct iPhone comparisons until I've seen a final device.
 Still, a lot of the UI innovations that I love on the iPhone are right here. Navigating
on the touchscreen was a pleasure, and I liked the roulette wheel-like
scrolling through long lists of items.
 Another ace up the Instinct's sleeve is its access to Sprint's 3G "EV-DO
Rev. A" data network, which means speedy Web surfing, full-track downloads
from the Sprint Music Store (which got a badly needed makeover for the
Instinct), video clips from Sprint TV, and the ability to tether the phone to
your laptop for on-the-road Net access.
More good stuff: GPS navigation combined with voice commands, allowing you to
bark "Go pizza" to the Instinct and get turn-by-turn directions to
the nearest slice.
And here's a feature that travelers will love: the Instinct's removable
battery, good for swapping out during, say, coast-to-coast flights. The
iPhone's battery is-as many have groused about before-sealed in its shell,
meaning that if it runs out of juice and you're nowhere near an AC outlet,
you're out of luck.
Rounding out the Instinct's features are microSD memory expansion (up to 8GB),
a 2MP camera, stereo Bluetooth, and a media manager for sideloading music and
videos.
Good stuff, although I should point out that the Instinct's Web browser (or at
least the version I saw) looked pretty clunky compared to the iPhone's, and the
Instinct's POP/IMAP/Outlook Web access messaging won't be able to match the
iPhone's upcoming support for Microsoft Exchange servers. There's also the
iPhone's potential as a software platform to consider, now that the iPhone SDK
is out in the wild.
And of course, by the time the Instinct arrives in Sprint stores (sometime
in mid-June), we may well have a new 3G iPhone on our hands.
No definitive word on pricing for the Instinct quite yet, although I'm told it
could be in the $200-250 range.
So, what do you think? Do we have an iPhone killer in our midst?Â
Â
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
When Sprint inproves the basic call experience so calls stop being dropped and the "Nextel" ability to direct connect works - Then I would be impressed by the phone. The phone is only as good the network and Sprint needs to work on that.
Will this phone auto update like the Iphone? As in correct bugs, expand it's capability? Nothing will match the innovation of the Iphone, just people trying to get into a market they crushed first in, the touch phones!! Ans I haven't heard good things about Sprint.
no!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What does this have that my Voyager does not have ?
iPhone killer? Look, Apple sold 4 million iPhones thru January. Sounds wonderful until you consider that almost 1.2 billion cell phones were sold in 2007. While the iPhone has appeal to some, its price tag will keep it out of the hands of the masses. If you look at Apple's track record of price competition, they don't fare so well. Also, another yoke around Apple's neck is the lawsuit by Cisco who claims that Apple stole their trademarked iPhone name. Then there are the lawsuits by serveral states AG's over the soldered in battery approach. It is so evident that the popular press adores Apple. Why else would editors/writers muse as to whether every new cell phone with a large display is the iPhone killer? Nokia sells more cell phones than anyone. Why not state every challenge as a Nokia killer? Oh, I remember, the press loves Apple.
Nothing compares to the iphone nor ever will
Y no one mentioned LG's Voyager here ? Compare this to the LG Voyager and see how much better Voyager is...This phone is an exact copy of Voyager...Also, why compare both these phones with IPhone ? All these phones are cool..its the carrier/network that matters the most... well whoever wants to enjoy this phone good luck !! and whoever has iphone..good choice...but I love my Voyager...so no complaints !
History repeats itself. First there was the imac then the ipod, now the iphone. By the time the imac copies were produced Apple went and changed the style and the copies looked old. Same with the ipod and now the iphone copies, nobody wants a copy when they can have the original. I suspect the next generation iphone will look slightly different and the new Samsung will look old and stale....but they could sell a couple of hundred.......lkmd
looks pretty interesting. Not sure I get the big deal about removable battery. There are plenty of after market batter packs for Ipods that run off AA batteries, that are much more useful then just a removable battery.
in no way is this the iphone killer...i agree the closest one yet
Ha! Samsung! Can they ever come up with something on their own? Why would they, when all they have to do is take something great and slightly alter it? I liked the comment on Sprint finally developing something worth talking about though...
Who would want to go to Sprint when people already hesitate to go to AT&T? I think the IPhone cannot be beat! There are updates so often that include games, different types of calculators, things for health, etc. There are so many new features that the IPhone is including. This Samsung phone looks cool too, but the only reason why I say NO is because it is for Sprint
I had the Iphone and hated it then got the HTC Touch and thought it was much better...
Try Harder
wow. so innovative. it's a freakin' iPhone clone as far as industrial design goes. yawn. 3G iPhone is already in the works too.
What a cheap rip off!
What about the LG VX10000? It has all these fetures and more and is already on the market.....
May not be a iPhone slayer but looks like a definite Blackberry killer for me...because of the Sprint/Nextel compatability
Any Smartphone is better than a dumb POP3 IPhone.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
46 Posted by ldwgumby on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:58PM EDT Report Abuse
If I'm correct, wasn't the LG Voyager supposed to rival the iPhone? The fact is, it didn't, nor will any other phone rial it for quite some time. Apple provides quality products that are top of the line, and no other companies have come close to challenging the iPhone's superiority.