Wed Apr 16, 2008 11:15AM EDT
See Comments (273)
The hip clothing retailer is set to roll out "item-level" RFID tags to track its inventory, although there are still lingering questions about what'll happen to the chip in that hoodie you just bought.
The RFID Journal reports that American Apparel launched a trial chipping program at a single New York City location late last year, and plans on rollout out RFID tracking to 16 more Gotham stores over the next three months, with a national rollout to follow.
Now, there's nothing new about retailers using RFID tags to track their inventory—but as the RFID Journal points out, the chips are usually embedded in single cases or pallets, not individual items. American Apparel will be one of the first retailers to chip each and every shirt, sweater, and sock.
So, how do we feel about this? Well, for its part, American Apparel says it’ll have better-stocked stores, with "one of everything on the floor"—meaning you'll always find your size and color on the shelf. And since it'll take less time to take inventory (just two clerks for two hours a week, versus four employees taking eight hours a week, according to RFID Journal), you'll get more help while you're shopping.
That said, what happens to those RFID chips when you walk out the door? For its pilot program, American Apparel clerks removed the chips from clothes once they were sold, the Journal reports, but after the rollout, the tags will remain in the garments you buy. [Update: The chips will be on the price tags, not woven into the garments themselves; see below.]
RFID Journal said that American Apparel has yet to detail exactly how—or if—it plans on deactivating the chips once your T-shirt is bought and paid for.
While I seriously doubt American Apparel has anything nefarious up its sleeves, the company would be well advised to detail its RFID privacy policies, pronto, and nip these nagging questions in the bud.
What do you think—are you all for "item-level" RFID tracking if it means always finding your size and getting better service? Or are you worried that Big Brother wants to track your new V-neck?
Update: A representative from American Apparel has responded with a clarification—the RFID chip will be on the price tag, not sewn into the garments themselves. His full reponse follows:
I am the Information Systems Director at American Apparel. I would like to request that you remove incorrect information from your article "American Apparel to track its clothing with RFID."
American Apparel will not be sewing RFID tags into the garment itself. The chips will be embedded in price tags, which are easily removable at any point by the customer.
While I think it's important to encourage people to discuss privacy issues and challenge new technologies, we do not believe that there is any privacy implication here. The tags contain no personal information, at any point, and can easily be removed by the customer (most stores do not remove price tags for you in case of returns).
I think you need to clarify this point, there are hundreds of comments taking your words very literally and I want to prevent further confusion.
Related:
American Apparel Makes a Bold Fashion Statement With RFID [RFID Journal]
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
absolutely insane. lets cut down more jobs while were at it. not only are they going to be tracking us with somthing else that we use everyday, the 4 people it takes to do this job will cut down to 2. end times are near and they are trying to make the rfid chip sound benificial to us. the govt. just announced how they are using our own spy satilites on the US and now they can track us by the close we wear connected to those satilites. JESUS HELP US IN THESE TIMES WE NEED YOU NOW MORE THAN EVER!
This certainly sounds like a sign of the times of the last days before Christ's return. I've been hearing about those chips being put in cell phones, in animals in pet shops, in credit cards etc. however, the one that will make the difference will probably be the one where they ask you to take one in the hand or forehead. When that time comes we are in big trouble. Right now, I may break out my trusty old sewing machine and brush up on making my own clothes. Maybe I'll take a few sewing lessons. Do I like this idea? No, definitely not as it is invasion of privacy for big business making more money. There are definitely limitations and this should be where one should draw the line.
I agree with isisshai. Any store that's going to put a tracking devise in my clothing and not take it out will not get my money. It's too creepy. How do I know that they're going to deactivate it? Personally, I don't want the whole world to know where I'm spending my time. That's my business.
Cgerath is right on the money; the danger is not in someone being able to track your shirt, but to associate your purchase with you, your activities, and your spending patterns later. Industry already spends billions every year trying to gather consumer information so you can receive junk mail. Do you really want to give government and industry more information about your personal life, considering the mess the two have already made of things by working together?
DONOT BUY THERE JUNK THIS IS A MESSAGE TO ALL and no more chinese junk buy AMerican and demand they do it right
The best way for the Goverment to gain even more control of the people is to say that they "Doubt" that anything nefarious is going on. Making us ashamed of doubting them but Shame on us for not doubting them enough.
Check out the book "The Spy Chip Threat" by Katherine Albrecht and you'll learn more on these chips and their use. You'll also learn JUST how much info they collect from you as you make your purchase and how it's linked to THAT item as well. Each item carries it's OWN ID number (two shirts alike and same size...different tracking number). NOTHING comes out of Wal-Mart without a RFID chip attached. The chip IS NOT KILLED at purchase but rather remains active. YES...someone with a scanner can read your trash content and you can be tracked. Oh...and by the way, you know that long thin strip imbedded inside dollar bill (five or larger)? You guessed it, an RFID chip that allows it to be tracked.
Some source tagging company is making boku bucks if every chip remeins in the garment and just walks out the door needing to be replaced each time. Plus worries about the gubment tracking people who buy those type of clothes? Big deal. If they wanna track where a bunch of frat boys toss their beers back then monitor away. It tells them nothing and would be more expensive to maintain rather than yield any fruitful results.
If a store wants to have a tracking chip in all their items then let them. I for one will never buy from that store... To stop this just hold off buying that shirt you want or buy it some where else, if sells fall so will the chips!!!
Did you people ever stop to think that the thing will likely be destroyed through the wash and dry cycle? I mean, come on. Aren't we a bit nuts here? You're supposed to wash the clothes you buy before you wear them. Let's be realistic.
dov charney can spin it anyway he likes but as anyone who has been in one of the stores knows american apparel employees are far too hip and cool to be bothered with customer service. i too will stick to the gap.
There are so many privacy issues to deal with, adding one more would at least cause me pause before personally shopping in the store or letting my children. There has to be more too it than simplicity for the store and we know they have inventory. There are cost factors involved. Do the cost of the clothes increase or decrease for consumers?
ARE THOSE PEOPLE CRAZY!!!! NEXT IT WILL BE CAMERAS`S IN OUR EYEWEAR.
If i waunted people to know where i am and what i am wearing i should have the choice to let them know, not the clothing store. I DO NOT AGREE with this at all
How smug to start chips with socks and other clothing!! Believe me this is just to get you used to the idea!!! Dogs ,cats already have chips and we will be on the same chain before long!!! Think it won't happen ? Better believe it will!!!!!
It's scary how paranoid some people are. What's scarier is that it is based on lack of information and misinformation that has been put out by all these conspiracy theorists. RFID is a simple technology that has been around for a long time. These tags that are used on merchandise have to be read by readers that are within a few feet. They can't be read by some satellite orbiting in outer space to track what you are doing with the items. No government spy is sitting in a dark room watching a monitor to see what some consumer is doing with their goods. Get real! RFID is simply a method for businesses to track their merchandise for inventory control and also for anti-shoplifting purposes. They do it to help save money. Wal-Mart uses it and they estimate it will save them $1 BILLION a year for those purposes. As stated by someone else, if you are paranoid about someone monitoring your shopping habits, then don't use credit cards or store's club cards. That is how they tie two and two together to match what was purchased with what person purchased them based off of your personal information stored in the credit card or store card. NOT with RFID tags! Even then, all they use that info for is to create marketing/advertising towards you and what you did or didn't purchase in the hopes you will come buy more stuff.
We need to wake up.. Yes, it's true about cell phones, credit cards etc but it's only a matter of time(once people are numbed to the idea) before "we the people" will have micro chips implanted in our hands so we can be tracked like merchandise.
I have seen disks used to prevent theft- and that's a good thing. But once I buy and pay for an item, I don't see a real need for the said item being tracked- except maybe by persons who don't have my best interests at heart (to be polite). Seriously, American Apparel- Rethink this idea of putting tracking chips in everything! Unless you want to lose a large fraction of your customer and future customer base.
I am an honest, hard working person and I have nothing to hide, but my I love my privacy. I would rather wear old clothing from Salvation Army than buy new clothes that have this "chip" in it. I agree with Isisshai that this does nothig for the customer, except infringe on our rights.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
26 Posted by kbonnetta@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:48PM EDT Report Abuse
"The idea is that if an item is stollen it will alarm if somebody comes back into any branch store either in a bag for return or wearing it on your back." That would be fine - it it was true but it isn't necessarily true... read the article again... "American Apparel has yet to detail exactly how %