Wed Apr 16, 2008 11:15AM EDT
See Comments (273)
The hip clothing retailer is set to roll out "item-level" RFID tags to track its inventory, although there are still lingering questions about what'll happen to the chip in that hoodie you just bought.
The RFID Journal reports that American Apparel launched a trial chipping program at a single New York City location late last year, and plans on rollout out RFID tracking to 16 more Gotham stores over the next three months, with a national rollout to follow.
Now, there's nothing new about retailers using RFID tags to track their inventory—but as the RFID Journal points out, the chips are usually embedded in single cases or pallets, not individual items. American Apparel will be one of the first retailers to chip each and every shirt, sweater, and sock.
So, how do we feel about this? Well, for its part, American Apparel says it’ll have better-stocked stores, with "one of everything on the floor"—meaning you'll always find your size and color on the shelf. And since it'll take less time to take inventory (just two clerks for two hours a week, versus four employees taking eight hours a week, according to RFID Journal), you'll get more help while you're shopping.
That said, what happens to those RFID chips when you walk out the door? For its pilot program, American Apparel clerks removed the chips from clothes once they were sold, the Journal reports, but after the rollout, the tags will remain in the garments you buy. [Update: The chips will be on the price tags, not woven into the garments themselves; see below.]
RFID Journal said that American Apparel has yet to detail exactly how—or if—it plans on deactivating the chips once your T-shirt is bought and paid for.
While I seriously doubt American Apparel has anything nefarious up its sleeves, the company would be well advised to detail its RFID privacy policies, pronto, and nip these nagging questions in the bud.
What do you think—are you all for "item-level" RFID tracking if it means always finding your size and getting better service? Or are you worried that Big Brother wants to track your new V-neck?
Update: A representative from American Apparel has responded with a clarification—the RFID chip will be on the price tag, not sewn into the garments themselves. His full reponse follows:
I am the Information Systems Director at American Apparel. I would like to request that you remove incorrect information from your article "American Apparel to track its clothing with RFID."
American Apparel will not be sewing RFID tags into the garment itself. The chips will be embedded in price tags, which are easily removable at any point by the customer.
While I think it's important to encourage people to discuss privacy issues and challenge new technologies, we do not believe that there is any privacy implication here. The tags contain no personal information, at any point, and can easily be removed by the customer (most stores do not remove price tags for you in case of returns).
I think you need to clarify this point, there are hundreds of comments taking your words very literally and I want to prevent further confusion.
Related:
American Apparel Makes a Bold Fashion Statement With RFID [RFID Journal]
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Everyone is wanting to watch each other...pretty scary to me...they should use that stupid chip to find out why the oil prices are so high...AND its gonna put more people out of work, not more people in the stores to help out the consumer...more unemployment on the rise...I wont be buying any American Apparel...lets hope the other industries wont turn to a chip....
Guess who won't be buying American Apparel !
WELL I AGREE WITH # 3 IF YOU DON'T THINK YOU ARE BEING TRACKED BY NOW YOU ARE JUST NAIVE. THE CHIP IS JUST A MARKETING PLOY TO SEE WHAT GOODS GO WHERE AND WHAT SELLS AND DOES'NT. ACTUALLY PRETTY SMART FOR A RETAILER. THEY CAN GATHER STYLE INFO / COLOR TRENDS AND A HOST OF OTHER THINGS. WHAT MAY BE HOT IN N.Y. MAY NOT BE IN MIAMI.
The store already knows what it has sold, that is all tracked thru the register. And that is how they keep inventorey. I've worked in stores, there is no way 2 people are going to stock an entire store in 2 hrs.. That's a load of crap. So now they just link the chipin your shirt to the name on the credit card. It's who we should be paranoid of, not wheather or not we should be paranoid.
The number one expense in retail is theft (external and internal). If they can cut this cost and somehow treat people as customers and not potential thieves, then they are on to something.
What a world we live in, I would not buy from that retailer, this is america, and we are not animals that have to be tracked. Give us a break already.
You people need to re-read this original article because it is EXACTLY as krisldoane states. In the article it states that it's unknown as to how the chip will be removed from the clothing once it leaves the store. Now if this chip was actually on a "tag" one could just snip off the tag as we do now with new clothing purchases so there would be no question (in the article or otherwise) as to how the chip is to be removed. Right? This is just the very beginning of a slippery slope for more governmental control over it's citizens. It won't be long before they'll be imbedding a chip into our fontanelles ("soft spots") in our heads as newborns for tracking. Wake up people before it's too late!
Conspiracy theorists unite! They should change the name to UnAmerican Apparel! Come on - you are in greater danger of being watched and listened to by our president than a clothing chain.
I believe that the public are being 'desensitized' by 'casual' use of the RFID so that several years from now people will accept this as 'routine' and good for all. This is already being implemented in cattle and other livestock as a method of identifying herds and food sources. This will make it's way into the delivery room where at birth a child is chipped, all being done for the good of the people. The writing is on the wall people, the "iron fist in the velvet glove"
How much will the chips cost? Aren't they electronic? Won't they use more taxes? And, I would think this as stalking sort of. Observing our very own clothes sizes. And it can stay to "American Apparel" because I have an odd taste in clothes...Shoot,I might even be a clown.
I have no problem with it if I can snip it off when I get back home... I suppose more thouight is needed on this one
I guess I feel like this isn't really a big deal. Every store already monitors this information when you give them your phone number. There's nothing in the article that says a random person can get your information through this chip. If you're really scared of "Big Brother" I'd suggest you get off of the internet. Every website that you touch tells someone where you are, your IP address all the way down to the resolution of your monitor. And, if you give up buying clothes from one retailer you might as well go naked. Many retailers use similar inventory control methods.
#74 and others, Just because we're already being tracked (cell phones, etc.) you're going to roll over for this one?
More help, yeah right. Watch 4 employees turn into two employees in a hurry. Remember when getting rid of the attendants at gas stations was going to provide cheaper gas and better service? Ever try and get service at a service station recently? BTW I saw a sign yesterday that read $3.99 per gallon.
Wow, so glad everyone figured it out. Yes it's a huge government conspiracy to keep an eye on us. Yes MI5, the FBI, and the CIA all want to know who's wearing the latest fashions from American clothing stores. Because it's a well know fact that anyone who buys an overpriced brown v-neck from a store in the mall is a terrorist and we should be keeping an eye on them. And yes, this is how Hitler started, with RFID tags. GET REAL. RFID tags are very small and will probably be attached to a tag on the clothing or sewn into a small fabric pouch as many manufacturers are already doing with anti-shoplifting tags. You can easily remove those. Odds are once you run it through a washer/dryer the chip won't work anymore anyways. If you buy into the government conspiracy junk, then you already know they are bugging your phones and internet so exactly what are they going to learn by knowing what size shirt or pants you wear or that you shop at a certain clothing store? Really it will be many, many years for them to even find that out if they wanted as there are only a few businesses that are slowly starting to use the technology. I work for a company that sells/services RFID systems for retail businesses. There is no government involvement or conspiracy, just a new technology to save companies money by better inventory control.
NO!!!!!....also what happens when you go through security at the airport? Is this a chip or a bar code?
"Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely." It was true then and it is even more true now. Seeing what this present administration has done to take the government along the path of absolute power, is there any thinking person who can believe that eventually these chips will not be used to keep track of you every minute of every day? This will become the most neferious abuse of personal privicy to date. Not only will the governments be able to keep track of you, but so will every retailer, and anyone else that gets ahold of the signal receiver, which I doubt will be that hard to come by. The time of personal privacy is gone, and the American people have helped to kill it. Instead of rising up in indignation about this they will willingly accept it. As long as they have their baseball, football, beer, and TV they won't worry themselves about something as meaningless as the loss of personal privacy. And the government and retailers know this quite well.
I know a lot or most of the retail stores use this technique for tracking inventory; however if they are not going to remove the chip once the item is purchased then what are they using it for. I agree with #75 in regards to inventory and sales, but I do believe it's another way they are trying to get the public to accept the chip then watch out for "Big Brother". Because of my type of employment I an aware of what's in store for the public in the future.
AA should have already outlined and made public their privacy policies instead of waiting for people to have questions. I never shop there anyway because I don't like their clothes, but if I were a regular customer, I wouldn't be anymore!
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
66 Posted by w.stloukal@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:38PM EDT Report Abuse
Big Brother is watching. Beware!