Tue Jun 17, 2008 12:12PM EDT
See Comments (33)
I'm not that partial to lawmakers meddling with the media, but when it comes to muzzling TV ads that are double the volume of the shows they're sponsoring, I'll make an exception.
Broadcasting & Cable reports that Rep. Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.) has proposed a bill—the aptly named Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation Act, or CALM—that would hold the FCC responsible for ensuring that TV commercials "not be excessively noisy."
More precisely, the bill would mandate that the FCC "prescribe a standard to preclude commercials from being broadcast at louder volumes than the program material they accompany."
Indeed, loud TV ads are so pervasive that several technologies have cropped up to combat the problem, such as Dolby Volume (which Chris covered last year). The only problem, however, is that these features typically limit the overall dynamic range of the sound, making the whispers too loud and the explosions too soft.
Now, usually I'm suspicious when legislators start circling the media, hoping to score political points by censoring violent movies, video games, or raunchy music lyrics.
But a law regulating noisy TV commercials—the ones that are so loud that you jump for the remote to turn the volume down—well, that's a cause I could get behind.
Related:
Eshoo Calls for CALM in TV Commercials [Broadcast & Cable]
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
america another freedom being taken away are we really free watch out in china they call this communisum. one more freedom being taken
finally so happy there may be an end to this nerve ending practice
why does our congress and rep. spend there time on such trivial things as loudness on tv.why dont they do something that is important to the america people
Back in the 1980s, the Reagan Administration sided with the advertisers in the loudness issue and as well with children's advertising. One a mistake, the other, an incalculable mistake. Don't believe me? Look it up.
This is the first proposal that has came up in california since i've lived here [8yrs.] that has made any sence!!
I find the difference in volume is worse on pay tv (cable) than broadcast. Pay or broadcast, it's definitely worse on certain channels and/or for particular ads. The FCC does have a rule about volume, but that doesn't really do much for those who have cable or sat as the FCC is almost entirely restricted to public airwaves.
I feel they should lower the volume, But they should also get rid of the adds about all the diff. pills out there and their side affects. Don't the European stations do commericals during a certain time of day and than leave the rest of the day open for shows commerical free? I am older and I heard of this years ago. If not than maybe that is something they could do here in the USA. Say 2 hours of nothing but commericals, than the other 22 for shows.
Please, please, please, let this become a federal law!!! And while they're at it, try to reduce the number of TV commercials from 100,000 an episode to about 20. Commercials should also be required to be as entertaining as the shows we watch...I don't know how they'll figure that out, but loud isn't the answer, EVER, YA HEAR ME!!! Oh sorry, I had the keyboard type on loud.
THIS IS BILLY MAYS FOR OXY CLEAN AHHHHHHHHHH
It's about time loud commercial be classified as public disturbance. And make it 3 counts they're out in California. 25 years to perpetual ban on TV punishment.
in china they call this communism in americaits called the law
Thank heavens somebody is finally doing something about this and I am frankly very sick of scrambling for the remote to mute the tv everytime some outrageously loud commercial is aired. Do they honestly think that someone actually will want to buy their products after being infuriated over the volume level of their commercials? Also, it makes me totally mute them anyways after being blasted with the volume levels.
If only congress would have passed the bill before they went on break....
About time!!!!!
I would like to support the volume control bill. It is an abuse of the public air waves for broadcasters to up ad volumes---and an assault on our hearing. The unanticipated volume increase soulds like a good class action lawsuit. Bob
Whats sad is, I work for a major Cellular Telephone Provider - I won't say which one - and advertisements have made their way into MOVIES! In certain movies, you can clearly see Sprint or AT&T or Verizon or T-Mobile. I want to watch movies without thinking of work! (I work so much I don;t even have cable, but even with my antennae I see these commercials.) My job conbsumes my life enough as it is, but I couldn't watch a MOTION PICTURE without advertisements!
THANK GOODNESS I am so sick and tired of this! It has gone on way to long! I thought they passed a bill like this a long time ago! It's so terrible you can't hardly hear the movie or show then it goes to a comercial and you jump out of your seat. It is especially annoying when you are watching tv while others are trying to sleep. I don't know how many times I have been asked to turn the tv down it's to loud. Well it's not my fault that they are intruding on me and everyone else by blaring the stupid commercial that you have probably seen a thousand times already!
wooooo 100th post!!
I'm glad to hear I'm not the only who can't stand the loud commercials! You would think the advertising companies and their clients would realize that people find loud commercials so obnoxious that "mute" has become the quick solution. HELLO ADVERTISERS; your tactics are NOT working when the commercials are "TUNED OUT"! The money wasted in TV advertising could be put to much better use!
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by missannie42 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:21PM EDT Report Abuse
I agree with the previous comments. In the meantime, Turn DOWN the volume, get up and do something useful during commercial time.I haven't watched a commercial in years and don't feel deprived at all.