Thu Oct 2, 2008 12:31PM EDT
See Comments (152)
Armed with a roomy touch display, stereo speakers, and—eventually—a year's worth of free music, Nokia's long-awaited touchscreen phone (formerly known as "The Tube") will make its debut in London today. Can it compete with the iPhone and T-Mobile's Google-powered G1?
First, let's cover the specs: Measuring 4.4 by 2 by 0.6 inches, the 3G- and Wi-Fi-enabled 5800 (set for global release by the end of the year, but not in North America until the "early part" of 2009) is more or less the same size as the iPhone 3G and the G1, although at 3.8 ounces, it's significantly lighter than both of its touchscreen competitors (the iPhone is about 4.8 ounces, while the G1 weighs in at a hefty 5.6 ounces).
So, how's the 5800's 3.2-inch touchscreeen? I haven't had a chance to try it in person, but the Symbian-powered display looks (from the press images, at least) reasonably sleek—somewhere between the clunkier interface on the G1 and the iPhone's eye-popping UI. No multitouch (so no "pinch"-type gestures), mind you, but the 5800 has an accelerometer that lets you turn the phone sideways for a virtual, landscape-oriented QWERTY keypad. You'll also be able to enter text using a half-size, portrait QWERTY keypad (with a stylus, if you like), T9 text prediction, or handwriting recognition.
Nokia promises a couple of key one-touch interface features, including a "Contacts Bar" that gives you quick access to your "favorite" four contacts, along with a "Media Bar" that'll let you tap into your music, videos, and images. Not bad, although I'd also like to see a status/alerts toolbar like the G1's.
As its name implies, the 5800 XpressMusic is more about tunes than productivity, so don't expect out-of-the-box support for BlackBerry or Exchange servers (although this being a Symbian phone, there's nothing stopping third parties from filling the void). Instead, the 5800 comes with stereo speakers, support for stereo Bluetooth headsets, a 3.5mm headset jack (which doubles as a TV-out port), and up to 16GB of microSD memeory expansion for your tunes.
The 5800 will also support Nokia's much-touted "Comes with Music" service, which will let you download all the free tunes you can stand—but just for 12 months, with a helping of DRM on the side. (CNET has details on all the restrictions right here.) Also, keep in mind that the cost of all those "free" tunes will be passed along via an inflated price tag for upcoming "Comes with Music" handsets (the Nokia N95 and 5310 XpressMusic phones will also be getting "Comes with Music" support), although Nokia reps didn't have details on how big the surcharge will be. Still, the music catalog looks to be pretty solid, with all four of the major labels (as well as some indies) signed on.
Back to the 5800 itself: The phone also comes with a 3.2MP camera, complete with Carl Zeiss optics, a dual LED flash, and video recording (up to 30fps). GPS and Nokia Maps are included for navigation. Sorry, gamers—no N-Gage support on the 5800, at least for now.
Nokia hasn't released U.S. pricing details—or carriers, if any—for the 5800 yet. (Since the 5800 is a GSM handset, it'll only work with GSM-based carriers such as AT&T and T-Mobile.) In Europe, however, the phone (minus "Comes with Music," for now) will sell for 279 euros, or about US$385—not bad, considering the sky-high price tag of Nokia's N-series beauties.
How does the 5800 XpressMusic stack up with the iPhone and the G1? Well, hard to say until I see the phone itself in action—and especially whether the 5800's touch interface measures up to the two touch heavyweights.
My initial impression? I'm a bit underwhelmed, frankly; it's almost as if Nokia is wading cautiosly into the touchscreen pool with the 5800. What I'm really waiting for is a full-on, touchscreen Nseries handset, complete with a revamped interface designed specifically for touch. In any case, I'm reserving any final judgement until I get an actual unit in for review. (Update: Gizmodo just published a quick hands-on report, and so far, the touchscreen sounds pretty lackluster: "On the prototype we played with briefly, it's much harder to get touches to register, and far less accurate than the iPhone's capacitive screens. The 5800 packs a built-in stylus for this reason—you'll be using it a lot." Ouch.)
So, what's your take? Like what you see? Disappointed? Fire away!
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
wow! this phone look really intresting! It kinda looks like the Iphone alot! tho the G1 to me is ugly. And the service povider is T-Mobile whic i think is not good! Verizon should invent a BETTER NEWER phone!
Why does someone who has not even had a chance to pick up this phone decide to write a critique about it? As soon as I read " haven't had a chance to try it in person" I have to admit that I was not interested in reading anything more he had to say.
nice....I will get one - for sure!
Have you noticed how many phones have come out stated to be "better" than the iphone, but guess what. iPhone is staying on top
That's great that you haven't tried the product. How do we know if it will work? Why should we listen to you. Thanks.
Another pathetic attempt to match Apple. I don't think the rest of the cellular companies out there recognize the appeal of the iPhone. The sleek, thin design matched with endless applications, moving GPS map with possible turn-by-turn in the future, excellent media player and impeccable customer service just can't be matched. These clunky devices that Nokia, Motorola and LG keep producing just don't even compare to half of what the iPhone offers. I'll stick to the iPhone 3G... forget the rest, it's obvious no one can match it.
i'm sure it is cool phone but why do they have to always come out with a new phone every week
Just another iPhone knock-off - without a physical keyboard it won't win any buyers away from the iPhone (except in markets where the iPhone isn't sold of course!)
every time a phone comes out everyone say that its gonna beat the iphone......IT NEVER DOES!!!!! and i highly doubt that thats going to change unless this phone provides everything that an iphone has and much more. Cuz with the iphone the possibilities are endless and now the iphone has added the GPS and the 3G network, leaving ppl nothing to complain about....
Iphone killer is starting to get old and very Cliche. It will not happen because no company has the innovation, or platform to pull it off. The Iphone is cool but it is the platform that makes it spectacular. This nokia phone will just be a big, kinda cool, clunker of a mediocre nature.
iPhone is half the price and a better touch scree with just as much memory...why would people choose this over it?
I Love Nokia Phomes. Go Nokia! I can now develop my apps in Symbian SDK and not have to be locked in with IPhone SDK.
Does it accept external memory such as an SD card? How many Gig in it? Does it work with itunes or only mp3/4? Hard disk or chip memory only?
iphone killer? Why do the G1 and 5800 XpressMusic are described as killers when they are going to be in the market after the apple company already made their gross sales on the iphones way before these killers are being issued in to the market.I would call them traditional technology phones, at this time. Maybe phones that want to compete against the iphones should be advertised in the same time period when the apple establishes a new market technology concept and idea to be called killers.
I LOVE HOW EVERYBODY HAS TO ATTEMPT TO COPY APPLE. IT SOUNDS LIKE MICROSOFT WITH WINDOWS VISTA WHEN THEY COMPLETELY COPIED MAC OS X. NOW SO MANY PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO COPY THE iPHONE. APPLE IS AHEAD OF EVERYBODY ELSE. THIS NOKIA IS NO GOOD AND NOKIA HAVE ALWAYS BEEN BEHIND IN "NEW" FEATURES.
How can you review a device that you haven't even used? What a fraud.
the LG dare is better than this and the iphone. no comparison
Seriously, how do you review something off of press images? I could have written this reading the spec sheet. People if you read anything past the line "I haven't had a chance to try it in person, but..." you probably just wasted some valuable sleep.
Verizon will NOT carry the phone.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
26 Posted by macandkanga on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:02PM EDT Report Abuse
Why do they all insist on calling these phones iphone killers? An ipone's an iphone or it is'nt.