Can "The Dark Knight" save Blu-ray?

Tue Nov 11, 2008 12:22PM EST

See Comments (66)

Nine years ago, the DVD of "The Matrix" shattered records and catapulted the budding DVD format into the mainstream. Can "The Dark Knight" do the same thing for Blu-ray?

The Blu-ray release of "The Dark Knight" is slated to Dec. 9, and as Video Business [via High-Def Digest] reports, Warner Brothers has more than a million Blu-ray copies of the Batman blockbuster teed up for retailers—reportedly, the most ever for a Blu-ray movie to date.

Indeed, "The Dark Knight" is perhaps the biggest gotta-have Blu-ray title yet, bigger even than "Iron Man" (which has sold about 500,000 Blu-ray copies so far, according to Video Business) and "Transformers."

But here's the big question: Will the popularity of "TDK" translate into a tipping point for Blu-ray, as "The Matrix" (which was the first DVD to ship more than 1.5 million units back in 1999) did for DVD?

Hard to say. On the one hand, as an eager tech geek myself, I can't think of a better combo than, say, a PlayStation 3 (or another Blu-ray player) and a Blu-ray copy of "Dark Knight" under the tree. (OK, a brand-new MacBook Pro and an iPhone 3G would be pretty sweet, too, but you get my drift.)

And besides being the biggest blockbuster of the year—of several years, for that matter—the "Dark Knight" Blu-ray is set to come with some unique, HD-friendly special features, including full-frame (16:9) sequences that mirror the eye-popping action segments in the IMAX release.

Then again, just because Warners plans to ship a million "Dark Knight" Blu-rays doesn't mean it'll sell a million of them, or that consumers will line up to buy their first Blu-ray decks.

Consider: Even though Blu-ray player prices are finally starting to fall south of $200, the bleak economic picture of 2008 is a far cry from the booming economy of 1999, when conspicuous consumption ($300 for a 1999-model DVD player ... sure!) was the name of the game. I'm putting off several big-ticket (read: $200+) tech purchases myself, and I'm betting you are, too.

And then there's the fact that for most people, the difference between Blu-ray and DVD isn't nearly as stark as it was between DVD and lowly old VHS.

Personally, I love the way my Blu-rays look on my 1080p, 46-inch Sony Bravia—but I still run into plenty of relatively discriminating viewers who say that their upscaling DVD decks look just fine, thanks very much. (And had I not bought my PS3 before the crash of '08, I might be saying the same thing.)

So, I'm curious: Will the release of "Dark Knight" convince any of you to go Blu? Or are you content to stick with DVD?

Related:
Dark Knight to break Blu-ray shipping record [Video Business, via High-Def Digest]

Comments on Can "The Dark Knight" save Blu-ray?

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 26 Posted by deadxxangels on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:39PM EDT Report Abuse

    I'd spend my money on it. I have 8 Blu-ray movies and I'm really big on technology I love being able to watch movies with out all the noise.

  • 27 Posted by rccrenwelgeiv on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:31PM EDT Report Abuse

    All i know is that i dont have a blu-ray player nor do i know anyone who does. blu-ray really isn't that popular yet as far as i know. Nobody ever says, "oh im about to watch a blu-ray" but you do hear,"im gonna watch a dvd." im gonna wait for dark knight to come on DVD

  • 28 Posted by prest_dinong30 on Sun Nov 23, 2008 3:44PM EST Report Abuse

    I would like the dark knight on widescreen dvd because I asked my sister t o get it for me for my birthday as a gift! Prest Dinong Oceanside, CA

  • 29 Posted by oshean20 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    Blu-Ray is going to be around for a while and there is nothing that is right on the edge right now and will not be for several years to come. Not until holographic discs come out which will likely be the next big step. As a videophile I have a 73" HDTV and all the needed equipment and speakers to make watching even the news an experience. If you have good quality products and care about the experience then BR is vital but usually only with special effects movies. Normal movies usually look good enough with just a normal DVD. The other component is the sound and BR takes this to much greater heights. The pricing is still too high for the disks but the quality is well worth it and I have about 40 BR now and still buy some DVD's depending on the movie. If you don't have the right equipment it would be pointless for sure but if you do care and have the stuff you need there is nothing else better.

  • 30 Posted by stephen_tennant2002 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:41PM EDT Report Abuse

    Bluray disks hold much more data than DVD so they will be around for a long time as data storage requirements increase (as they always have). However, for home entertainment, I think Blu Ray has a tougher fight than DVD. Firstly you have to purchase a high def TV - with DVD it was just a new player....the TV was the same. Secondly, movie downloads are in their infancy and starting to improve. This combined with the crazy zoning system of Blu Ray which means that when you are overseas and make a legal purchase of a legal movie, it is not playable when you get home, makes movie downloading a better option, once they get rid of a lot of this digital rights crap. So its early days and wait and see.

  • 31 Posted by environmentcayman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:55PM EDT Report Abuse

    No single movie is going to inspire me to go out and buy (1) a new TV and (2) a new palyer for (3) a more expensive disk. I saw Dark Night in IMAX and it wasn't so much better than movies in a regular cinema to inspire me to pay for a similar level of upgrade in my home. - Its not the cost of a single component, its the cost of the package vs the cost of what I have now.

  • 32 Posted by betterthanebert on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:05PM EDT Report Abuse

    Blu-Ray is in TROUBLE, and the primary culprit is, predictably, Sony choosing to shoot themselves in the face. They're refusing to do a price drop on the PlayStation 3 (the most popular Blu-Ray player out there) for the '08 Holiday Season. BAD IDEA, Sony, and in this economy, you're sure gonna pay for it. Not only in poor console sales, but also in slowing or perhaps stopping Blu-Ray adoption all together. But Sony making a bad call is hardly anything new. The iPod isn't the Walkman of the 21st century for nothing. It isn't just that Apple, Nintendo, Microsoft and others are out-executing Sony. It's that Sony is largely giving it away with braindead decision after braindead decision. Their new leadership isn't signficantly better than the old in that regard.

  • 33 Posted by sprayinlead on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:37PM EDT Report Abuse

    One big problem I have with purchasing only BR DVD's is that I have a PS3 in one room and a regular DVD player in the living room and I take a laptop with me on trips that has a standard BR player in it. So, I really limit my viewing/watching ability if I purchase BR. Sony needs to push their BR players in all PC's and further drop the price of home players...otherwise BR will never be fully integrated everywhere. Best thing all around is to create BR discs where they can be played in regular DVD players, but not necessarily look as good as played in a BR player. HD DVD would've met more needs for everyone, but it couldn't afford the game.

  • 34 Posted by gkirk78 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    I will purchase "The Dark Knight" on Blu-ray at the $24 prices I have seen advertised. The $29 -$35 MSRP price of blu-rays is what keeps me from purchasing more of them, and once hi-def movie downloads become mainstream, I won't purchase another disc of any kind, ever.

  • 35 Posted by rayatkins101681 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    I love how people are writing off Blu Ray. Blu Ray is far from dead. It's the future of HD movies. Digital downloads are not practical for alot of people. Some people want hard copies of their movies not downloads.

  • 36 Posted by leec12 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:48PM EDT Report Abuse

    It seems to me a lot of you are misinformed about blu ray vs dvd. For you to say upscale looks as good as true HD 1080P is laughable. I work at a Best Buy and what most customers don"t understand, is in order to getthe best out of your tv, you have to invest a little bit more money. On top of purchasing the tv, you neeed a power cleaner, hdmi caBLe, tv calibration etc. to maximize the full potential of a 1080P, you have to have all the pieces;until you have all the pieces, you can not compare anything to 1080P.

  • 37 Posted by avionics85 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:59PM EDT Report Abuse

    Blu-ray isn't doing bad, in fact for the economic times we are facing it's doing well. I think they need to sell a ton of copies of Dark Knight, but it's more of a "make but not break" kinda thing

  • 38 Posted by bschiess on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:14PM EDT Report Abuse

    I used to think that my upscaling (1080i) DVD player was nearly as good as BD. Boy was I wrong. I purchased a PS3 about 2-3 months ago, and not only was I blown away, but I knew I had a winner when my wife commented "Oh my gosh, I can't believe how clear this movie is" when she didn't know we were watching a BD version of "Sex and the City - The movie." I agree with everyone's comments about the prices, and I haven't purchased a BD title yet but instead have been renting them from Block Buster. They have a nicely growing BD section, and that's how I'm getting my fix.

  • 39 Posted by ardithkay on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have no desire to go Blu-Ray now or ever. Truth is, the whole idea is stupid. I enjoy my 25 inch flat screen LCD TV and to be honest the DVD experience is fine by me. Blu-Ray will probably go out like the laser discs did in the 80s. There is more to movies than owning the "latest and greatest" of technology. Give me surround sound and a clear screen with a carefully kept DVD and the experience is perfect in my book. DVDs are in and I'm not about to sacrifice my new collection for something that probably won't be around long at all.

  • 40 Posted by wanlord69 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:40PM EDT Report Abuse

    Planning a full scale change out of all 4 DVD players in my home for Blu-ray and "TDK" will for sure be my first purchase. However, I am anxious for streaming HD from Blockbuster or Netflix as well!!

  • 41 Posted by munizm on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    I totally agree if you have a clue, Blu is the way to go. I own a PS360gb and will buy my kids thier 80gb PS3 and 1080P tv so they can have their own hd experience. Prices on BD movies are in the 15.00 range now, and will soon be competetive on pricing to DVD. Players are also under the 200 mark.

  • 42 Posted by oobgarm1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    I think it's here to stay. There are plenty of discs out there that are in the $20 range, which is acceptable for most films. Things have backed off somewhat from that $30+ pricetag, though there are some studios hanging onto it. Once players drop further, sales will pick up. Most folks, myself included, are only going to go for the top-tier movies, or personal favorites. The only problem now is the relative low-cost of DVD.

  • 43 Posted by samclark@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    I've had a blu-ray player for a year already and I couldn't live without it. I already invested a ton in my stunning Samsung 1080p 46' HDTV. It would be just plain silly not to have a movie player that matches its quality. Or to put it another way, nickle smart and dollar foolish.

  • 44 Posted by lvphilly1017 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    Well...Blu-ray is my life. I am the future tech-ist. No old fashion for me such as vhs or dvd. But DVD is still good. My opinion is blu-ray is still better bec of higher storage. of course still an expensive. that's life!

  • 45 Posted by timanny on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:10PM EDT Report Abuse

    When I get a large (40+) HD TV then I'll go Blue-Ray, but until then it's not worth the money for the switch for my small HD TV.

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.