Tue Nov 11, 2008 12:22PM EST
See Comments (66)
Nine years ago, the DVD of "The Matrix" shattered records and catapulted the budding DVD format into the mainstream. Can "The Dark Knight" do the same thing for Blu-ray?
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
I really don't see Blu-ray being that much better to run out and make a $200 purchase to buy a BD Player. I have an HD-TV, and I agree it more then worth having you TV in HD. Honestly though, once you have a HD-TV the picture isn't going to get much better. I have watched both HD and Standard PPV movies and they look about the same on an HD-TV, Well at least to me they do. If im going to watch a DVD I would just watch it on my xbox 360, and yes much like the BD the PS3 is dying in the US as well.
Blu-Ray, HD DVD, whatever technology comes further down the pike cannot salvage bad movies. Like so many things in our culture, looks are more important than content. Would "Casablanca" be improved by Blu-Ray? "White Chicks" can't be saved by this technology.
Nope.. dont plan on it. I love the way my dvd's look and am not willing to spend an extra $300 to see smoother elbows.
Blu-Ray requires an HDTV to truly be effective, & those are still too expensive too. Get HDTVs down to the price of REGULAR TV's, & Blu-Ray players to the price of standard DVD's, & then MAYBE I'll consider upgrading. Till then, it's just too darn expensive. I'll stick with my standard DVDs.
Blu-ray doesn't need saving. It is being adopted a rate greater than even DVD at the same point in its lifecycle. And compressed downloadable psuedo-HD will never be a substitute for Blu-ray. Downloads won't have lossless audio or any extra features. And all download models currently in discussion on relate to rentals. Don't forget ISPs are instituting download caps which will also put a crimp in all those downloads people seem to think will take over.
oh my god, bluray doesnt need saving, it is here to stay and in fact, it is doing 10 times better than dvd did during the same amount of time
In 1979 I bought a $1000.00 VHS player and 4 hour tapes were $12.each the next year or so saw BetaMax gone and VHS machines selling for under $400. . So I'll wait awhile. Right now Im very happy with HD DVD's
With a first rate BD player under $200 bucks at Amazon and netflix or blockbuster for BD rentals, where's the cost problem? The only problem I'm worried about is that BD gets too popular and it get harder to rent the particular movie I want.
Every time there is a leap in technology there are naysayers, either those who can't afford it yet, or those who are afraid of change. Blu-ray is light years ahead of standard definition, and up-scaled does not compare either. Just say you will wait until all your friends have it, then you will make the plunge as well. But please, stop kidding yourself that dvds look as good, or that there is no difference. Blu-ray is here for the next decade as the premiere technology, not downloads. Most people would rather own a disc than download a very large file and find somewhere to store it anyway. I own an HD-DVD player as well as a Blu-ray, HD just makes that much of a difference!
BluRay is here to STAY!!!
"Hard to say. On the one hand, as an eager tech geek myself, I can't think of a better combo than, say, a PlayStation 3 (or another Blu-ray player) and a Blu-ray copy of "Dark Knight" under the tree. (OK, a brand-new MacBook Pro and an iPhone 3G would be pretty sweet, too, but you get my drift.)" A person who wants a Mac Book Pro is so far away from being a tech geek you shouldn't even have been able to write this article. Go kill your self.
I will always buy the newest technology. My wife knows that and teases me about it. Funny thing is that she wants me to show off the bluray movies when ever people come over. No one ever says that their dvd looks just as good. Also downloads will not kill bluray. I enjoy my ipod as much as the next person while listen through tiny ear buds. But when I am filling my house up with music it is the cd that impresses people. Not the downgraded music stored on ipod. Don't forget that as we download more and more the internet companies are putting tighter limits on the amountwe can download. Until we live in a world where we can download bit for bit no download will sounds or look as good as the physical meda. Downloaded=Downgraded! My 2 cents worth.
The very company that you apparently so love, Sony, well you can blame them for Bluray's demise. Sorry Ben, you chose wrong.
Some of the blu-ray disc prices are scary at BB and CC but online you can get much better deals. I pre-ordered Dark Knight for $22, no shipping or tax. While I will not replace all of my standard dvd's with blu-rays, going foward, I would buy Blu-ray only. I have paid $10 for some blu-rays including memento and monster house, great deals can be had.....
You Gotta Spend Money To Make Money =]
When I buy a DVD movie I really only want to see the movie, I don't care about any special effect extra disk which to me is only a way of getting more money from me. DVD plays fine, get the price of a BluRay player down to 50 bucks and a movie disk only at 15 bucks and it will make no difference to me if it is DVD or Bluray, both the same price then ok, try to get more money from me and I don't want to have anything to do with BluRay.
I am not a techie, videophile or gamer. I am a single mom of a 4yr old. and no.. The darkknight will not convince me to spen nearly $200 on a machine to play movies when i already have 3 DVD players that work just fine. In fact, i won't upgrade to BluRay (or whatever the next fad is) until after the economy gets better and i can afford the 52inch HDTV that I want. Then and only then will I consider upgrading.
the less Blue Ray you buy the cheaper they will get. I will never pay 30 dollars for a movie. Sorry Sony your Blu Ray format is dying slowly! I have a PS3 but I don't buy any Blu Ray movies. got no reason to spend that much money just to watch movies that are on HD on TV already.
I can get the Dark Knoght right now at Walmart for $12.99 , why pay the $29.99. Plus sd dvds do look amazing on my Toshiba upconvert dvd recorder. I had a blu ray player and the difference is very little.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
46 Posted by halleen2 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:15PM EDT Report Abuse
Physical media is 20th centure technology. The future is all digital, no disc, no tape, no case, no shrinkwrap... just download. BD is a bridge technology at best. I'm waiting.