Tue Nov 11, 2008 12:22PM EST
See Comments (66)
Nine years ago, the DVD of "The Matrix" shattered records and catapulted the budding DVD format into the mainstream. Can "The Dark Knight" do the same thing for Blu-ray?
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Blu-Ray doesn't need to be saved from anything. Yeah Blu-Ray sales aren't beating DVD or anything but Everyone knoew they wouldn't yet. They may not be beating DVD but they are making a big dent in them.
In my opinion Blue Ray is the ONLY way to watch movies. For those of you that bought HD players, you should have known that Sony wasn't going to lose another media/format war, remember Beta vs VHS? Unfortunately with times being tough, consumers cannot justify buying a $20-30 video. Well I can't!! Happy Holidays!!
I have not seen either upconverted DVD nor the Blu-Ray. It's all well and good if you a videophile and have to have a fix. But for the average consumer, DVD's are "good enough". By the time you factor in the exceptional amount of work and investment it takes for an HD TV to look good, it just doesn't seem worth it for the average person. That being said, a whole lot of average consumers will become videophiles after seeing true HD - the kind that is hooked up and is broadcasting correctly. I will not be purchasing a Blu-Ray player in the near future, nor do I have plans to upgrade to an HD television; it just isn't worth my investment.
I'm really suprised by some of these comments. I am 100% satisfied with Blu-Ray's quality, it's storage capacity, and not to mention my Blu-Ray player upscales the DVD's I currently own. I'm very happy I made the switch.
No more optical formats for me. I am one of the idiots that bought into HD DVD and here I sit with a dead format. On the upside, it plays my regular DVD's beautifully, and I am snapping up HD titles on the cheap. And of course the downside being no new releases, but I've finally learned my lesson thanks, no more early adoptions for me.
No the dark Knight will not save the blu-ray. blu-ray needs to come down on the prices to be saved. and it looks better on plain DVD.
I have a Samsung 1080p HD tv and a Samsung DVD player that upscales DVDs to 1080p. DVDs are 1/2 to 1/3 less than Blu-Ray. I see no need for a Blu-Ray. I did not like the way the war between Blu-Ray and HD-DVD was handled. We, the consumer, did not get to decide which format we would prefer. It was decided for us by the deals that were made between Sony and the movie studios.
I don't see the point in an "upgrade" to Blu-ray. I still have plain old CRT TVs in my house, why would I bother getting a BR player. I won't see any difference between a BR disc and a DVD on my TVs. My TVs generally last about 10-15 years so I've got about 4-9 years before I get a better TV, by then the movie biz/tech giants will be pushing some other new fangled product on the market to replace BR and everyone will be "upgrading" (ie emptying their wallet) for that.
blu-ray is pretty expensive, but I just couldn't wait for the price to lower so I bought my ps3 yesterday. I have to admit it's only when they show landscapes or trickles of water when I really get to appreciate my $399. But one of the reasons that I bought it now was for the release of the dark knight. It just tells the story more vividly to me, but I do hope that the blu-ray prices drop, so I'm only going to buy blockbuster hits right now.
I have at least a half dozen TV's in my house each with its own DVD player. If I go Blu-Ray, I would only buy one player ($300) and could only watch on one TV, where with a DVD (which is still pretty good and a heck of a lot cheaper than Blu-Ray) I can watch in any room in my house. I think Blu-Ray is going to be strictly a niche market like Laser Discs were.
Blu ray is the future. THeres a blu ray player in stores for 130 and the dark night is 23 dollars and not 35. There started to lowing the prices and wait till next year there all gonna drop more
With the players still more than double the cost of a good upscaling DVD and the disc's going for $30, I'll wait it out. Besides, I had to replace 2 Sony DVD players that went bad in a year or so. I'll never buy another Sony hardware product !!
We really got burned years ago with investing in a laser disk player which went by the way of the dinosaur. We were left with dozens of overpriced & oversized laser disks that were virtually useless. I've been afraid of technical advancement ever since. I don't know a lot about Blu-Ray but it sounds like a similar type of techno-gimmick: here today, gone tomorrow. Besides the ONLY way to see Dark Night, in my opinion, was on the big screen!
Blu Ray is already dead. There is no need for it and people who have an average of 2 or 5 dvd players already will not spend more money for a new gadget that does the same thing. Bury BluRay
Dark Knight isn't even worth watching on DVD. owning one of the best movies on Blue Ray would be a must. definitely worth it.
I love all the negative comments about BD, I remember when DVD's first came out, and all the negative comments: there to expensive blah blah blah, The Dark Knight may not be to BD what The Matrix was the DVD, but I believe that BD is here to stay. I also remember when DVD players where a $1000, and CD writer drivers where $1000 and everyone said that's expensive blah blah blah, BD is the new format. Yeah the economy sucks right now, and yes they are expensive but BD are here to stay.
Blu-Ray has been dead before the fight with HD-DVD. I mean, Blu-Ray has frickin' loading times. I want to watch the movie, not wait for all of the crappy bonus material to load.
I see "Blu-ray" going the way of "Laser Disc", great for the gotta have tech head but until we see some real price drops in both the discs and players I believe the rest of us will be satisfied with the standard DVD/download format. Don't get me wrong Blu-ray/HD movies look amazing but I don't feel the need to see "Coming to America" or "I Now Pronounce you Chuck an Larry" in High-Def especially for 30 bucks a pop. This whole HD business is still so very new to ALOT of people and to answer this original question here... No I don't think 1 Blu-ray movie will save or start the Blu-ray trend. IMO.
As demand increases, prices will drop. Go look at your local walmart or bestbuy, target store. every month the blu-ray section gets bigger and the dvd section gets smaller. No comparison to me watching same movie upscaled as in blu-ray. Movies with computer animation and lots of special effects is where the biggest differences are.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by duprea on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse
Lower the price on the deck. Then lower the price on the disc. Then we can talk. No more Gilette marketing plays where they give you the razor and then make out like bandits on the blades.