Six Must-Know HDTV Facts

Mon Apr 16, 2007 11:27AM EDT

See Comments (118)

Disappointed by how fuzzy CNN looks on your new HDTV? Wondering why Jack Bauer looks so soft and plump on your new flat-screen? Maybe it's because you're not really watching HD on your high-def TV.

According to Audioholics, almost half of the 24 million homes with HDTVs lack an HD cable or satellite feed, and about a quarter of those surveyed didn't even know they were still watching non-HD signals. Why such big numbers? Actually, it's not hard to understand; I can't tell you how many times I've watched salespeople at TV stores push HDTVs on hapless shoppers, going on and on about the razor-sharp picture and surround sound, but not bothering to tell them how to get HD signals into their living rooms.

The Audioholics story ticks off six things you need to know before you buy an HDTV, and it's a must-read if you're in the market for your first high-def set. Here's a brief summary of some of the pointers, along with some thoughts of my own:

 

  1. Your new HDTV needs an HD feed: Just plugging your regular cable or satellite box into your new HD set won't get you a high-def picture. You'll need to contact your cable or satellite provider and ask for an HD set-top box (satellite subscribers may also have to upgrade their dishes), and you may want to sign up for an HD subscription plan, as well (which typically offer channels like Discovery HD Theater and HDNet). Still watching TV using an over-the-air antenna? A good, properly aligned rooftop antenna may still do a good job of pulling down HD signals, but unless your HDTV has a built-in HD tuner (many don't), you'll have to buy a separate high-def tuner box to go with your set.
  2. Your HDTV/set-top box/cables must be configured properly: First, make sure you're using the right inputs when connecting your HD set-top box to your HDTV. You must use either the component-video inputs (a trio of RCA-type plugs, marked "Y," "Pb," and "Pr") the DVI input or the HDMI input. The composite and S-Video connectors on your TV can't receive HD signals, so if the cable guy starts hooking those inputs up, time to raise the red flag. Also, your cable or satellite HD box must be set to send an HD signal to your display; go to the set-top box menu and look for the display settings, and select either 720p or 1080i (depending on the native resolution of your HDTV). Finally, once you're ready to watch HD, make sure you're watching the right channel. If you're used to watching ABC on, say, cable channel 7, that's only the standard-def version of ABC; the HD version is probably much further down the dial, usually in the 700s. Check your programming guide.
  3. Most TV programming is still in standard definition: I'm still amazed by how many people think that an HDTV will display all their shows in high definition. Now, if you're only watching scripted (i.e., non-reality) prime-time shows on the major broadcast networks, then yes, there's a good chance that most of those shows are in HD (save a few holdouts, like "Scrubs" on NBC). But the vast majority of programming that's out there, ranging from "Queer Eye" and "Regis and Kelly" to "Pardon the Interruption" and "Sesame Street", is produced in standard definition, and your HDTV won't magically convert SD shows to HD. Check out TitanTV to see what's in HD in your area.
  4. SD typically looks terrible on an HDTV: Standard-def shows can look remarkably bad on a 50-inch display. Imagine taking a grainy Polaroid picture and blowing it up to monster size. If you miss how CNN used to look on your old 27-inch direct-view set, keep in mind that you were watching it on a much smaller screen.
  5. HDTV screens are wider than SD pictures: Because HDTV screens have a wide 16:9 aspect ratio, your new set will stretch the boxy 4:3 shape of a standard-definition show to fill the screen, which will make everything look short and squat. You have two choices: either live with the short-and-squat look on your SD channels, or dig into your HD set-top box settings and add sidebars to the SD channels. Yes, you'll have to deal with black bars on the left and right sides of the screen, but at least the picture won't look like a circus fun-house mirror.
  6. An upconverting DVD player doesn't turn standard DVDs into HD: I'm a big fan of DVD players that upconvert standard-def DVDs to 1080i or even 1080p, but make no mistake; because the source DVD disc is standard definition, you're still watching an SD picture (albeit, one that's been extrapolated to HD proportions). If you want true HD images from your DVD player, you'll have to pony up $400 or more for a Blu-ray or HD DVD drive.

Still confused? Then check out the Audioholics story, which goes into much greater detail.

Related:
Are You Sure You're Watching HDTV? [Audioholics]
Deciphering the Basic Roadmap for HDTV Connections

Comments on Six Must-Know HDTV Facts

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 46 Posted by ityler9 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    Not even a mention of cablecards? July 1 is the deadline for cable companies to be required to provide set-top-boxes that use cablcecards. Hopefully this will open the market up and others will start offering more tv, DVR/PVR and digital receivers with that capability.

  • 47 Posted by tgradie on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    I can't believe anyone will pay so much and work so hard to install something that essentially rots your brain.

  • 49 Posted by smf_hi on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    One quick thing that should be mentioned is that if you are watching a Standard Definition (SD) signal on a HDTV, the picture quality can be dramatically improved by watching it over a non-HD input, preferably S-Video, instead of the HDMI or component input.

  • 50 Posted by jimlogue@verizon.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    One correction mentioned by another poster--it's not HD that the FCC will require, it's digital cable that is required by the FCC by February 2009 (so far--that date changes). HD TV is a version of Digital, but HD is not mandatory. Another correction, everyone does NOT have to run out and buy a new TV for this. Your cable companies have converter boxes that will allow you to view digital programming on your current TV. That is not going to change, so you do not have to worry about your TV becoming obsolete. If you're wondering, I work for a cable company, and we get these questions all the time.

  • 51 Posted by kalkeener4576 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    While the author is technically correct with his bolded statement in #6, the rest is not quite accurate. 720i or p is not quite standard definition either.

  • 52 Posted by shadoman_ on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:15PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have one more thing to add about antennae. The "rabbit ears" portion of your antenna are for the VHF bands, and most digital programming isn't on those bands. The little circle loop is the UHF part. You can build a UHF antenna out of coathangers and odds and ends! Here's a good set of instructions: http://uhfhdtvantenna.blogspot.com/ I can pick up stations 50 miles away with my homebrew antenna. Really!

  • 53 Posted by foolsufferedgladly on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    a timely reminder that this nu-fangled technology is confusing, clunky and very spendy, not to mention the competing formats. when simplicity of use and elegance of design are the norm, then i'll consider making a purchase, and not before. so there.

  • 54 Posted by benfar1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:05PM EDT Report Abuse

    What the public needs to know is that if you want high a definition picture and save money at the same time. All you need is a HDTV ready TV (this has a an ntsc tuner in it ).You will need a digital receiver...capable of receiving digital signals ATSC.( Best buy etc.), buy a pair of rabbit ears....and you are ready to go. You will be able to receive all your local channels and the public channels free without having to pay for cable. These stations are broadcasting analog and digital signals.The digital signal would give you High Definition reception, without paying a dime. Most of these Stations are broadcasting HD signals. The same thing holds true for a TV with a High Definition tuner( ATSC )built in. Benny in Baltimore

  • 55 Posted by visiworks on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:36PM EDT Report Abuse

    With All Respect to number 34 (wdlp), the DVD-Video Spec is 720x480 (NTSC) or 720x576(PAL) with a maximum bitrate of 9.8 Mb/s. Since the HD standard is almost twice that of DVD (peak at 19.4 Mb/s), DVD contains nowhere near the resolution needed to be "upres'd" to HD quality. Sending the signal over VGA (if you are using a true UXGA VGA cable) results in a quality that is no different than sending the signal over component video. The only difference is that the signal is being sent to the TV / Monitor in it's native format rather than in a format that the TV / Monitor has to convert. Relative bandwidth is very similar. The bottom line is this: You can only display as much resolution as the original recording was stored in...so an SD DVD only has 480 (NTSC) lines of resolution. PERIOD. When the signal is converted to the HDTV's native format, the extra lines of resolution are just filler or nearest neighbor interpolations and not a true improvement of resolution. The only way to get HD quality from ANYTHING (dvd, over-the-air, cable, satellite, etc) is for the source to have been encoded in true HD format.

  • 56 Posted by visiworks on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:36PM EDT Report Abuse

    With All Respect to number 34 (wdlp), the DVD-Video Spec is 720x480 (NTSC) or 720x576(PAL) with a maximum bitrate of 9.8 Mb/s. Since the HD standard is almost twice that of DVD (peak at 19.4 Mb/s), DVD contains nowhere near the resolution needed to be "upres'd" to HD quality. Sending the signal over VGA (if you are using a true UXGA VGA cable) results in a quality that is no different than sending the signal over component video. The only difference is that the signal is being sent to the TV / Monitor in it's native format rather than in a format that the TV / Monitor has to convert. Relative bandwidth is very similar. The bottom line is this: You can only display as much resolution as the original recording was stored in...so an SD DVD only has 480 (NTSC) lines of resolution. PERIOD. When the signal is converted to the HDTV's native format, the extra lines of resolution are just filler or nearest neighbor interpolations and not a true improvement of resolution. The only way to get HD quality from ANYTHING (dvd, over-the-air, cable, satellite, etc) is for the source to have been encoded in true HD format.

  • 57 Posted by jc_nom on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:31PM EDT Report Abuse

    Wow!!!! I can see why so many consumers don't know how to "use" their tv's. It is amazing that most of the responses in here are from guys from the "BIG BOX" stores or the usual "my friend has an hdtv" guy. Scryer_360, the reason you guys at BB get so many returns is because you need to train those associates on how to sell HDTV's. Oh, but that's right? That would cost so much money to teach years and years of knowledge to kids straight out of highschool collecting an hourly paycheck. And colinnwn...do you realize that NOTHING is broadcasting in 1080p and probably won't be for many years down the road!!!!!!! You were correct in stating that 1080p takes up more bandwidth, but this is one reason why no tv stations broadcast in 1080p. The other reason is that the tv stations that are broadcasting in HD, most of the major stations,ABC,CBS,NBC..etc.,these guys just spent millions on the HD cameras and equipment to get us the beautiful 720p content we see now. Oh, and try to get a BB or CC to change the channel for you and it's like a bunch of keystone cops trying to figure out what to do. Oh, and don't worry about what the government is doing about pushing back the dates for "cut off" of analog signals. The word obsolete doesn't exist if you have Direct TV, Dish or any other "digital" signal coming into the house. Most of you out there reading this probably have DTV or Dish right? And it's displaying on an analog tv? Well, there ya go. It doesn't have to be HD tv to get a digital image. Wow, how far a little education goes!!! So, to the "Gadget Hound"Ben Patterson who so cleary writes and I quote, "I can't tell you how many times I've watched salespeople at TV stores push HDTVs on hapless shoppers, going on and on about the razor-sharp picture and surround sound, but not bothering to tell them how to get HD signals into their living rooms." You obviously are not truly referring to true "salespeople" but are infact referring to the warm bodies that occupy the CC's and the BB's of this great nation, oh and how can I forget the disgruntled Wal-Mart employee just trying to make it through another day of endless amounts of people wanting the "best price" possible, but necessarily the best product possible. This employee has even less knowledge of the ever changing and evolving trend that is HD TV. Yes, I am a salesperson, a systems integrater, a design specialist. I work for one of the premier custom installation companies in the country and it upsets me to see articles like this. I work hard for my sales and most importantly, for the overall satisfaction of my clients because in the end if they are not happy then we are not happy as a company, and if they are misinformed then we lose all credibility as an industry. Teach that to your folks "BIG BOX" retailers. I've been in this industry for 12years and it's not something you can teach or something that can be learned over night. CC is finding that out the hard way. So, good luck America. You'll need it.

  • 58 Posted by juudycootie on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    Help! I'm 65 yrs old and on limited income--does that mean if I can't buy a new HDTV that I won't be able to watch TV anymore? I'm so confused by all this, and I'm very non-tech but I keep hearing rumors...sounds like they might be true ?!?

  • 59 Posted by forgedirons on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    thanks for a great heads up! this is a great example of the value the internet can provide consumers.

  • 60 Posted by jimmyreeves@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    I bought a AKAI 61" from shopnbc.com in Febuary and it worked for about 2 weeks and a panel went out. A repairman came out and stated it could not be fixed because parts were unable to be obtained. I tried to buy a warranty and no one would sell it. If the set had gone out after one year it would just have to be junked. It is now June and the broken T.V. is still setting in my living room. I would never buy another T.V. from shopnbc.com.

  • 61 Posted by free420future on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:03PM EDT Report Abuse

    when it comes to HD it seems everyone is some kind of Expert. HD this and SD that, you need this special box to watch this program in HD or how about a special DVD player to watch you favorate DVDs. my two cents on this is it's all about the money the Electronics drain from your bank account!! no matter what new technology is on the market you will pay for it. if you have the money then no problem. maybe i should just turn it off and get a life for a change, I mean come on GO OUTSIDE it's summer time.... put the video game down man. hey what about video games? maybe i need something special to kill aliens on Halo, nope not me all you aliens are done for!!!

  • 62 Posted by williamlecorchick on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    Great article. I'm a satellite installer and it is so difficult to have to explain all this to a customer who has incredibly high expectations when there are still all these things to take into consideration. It's true that not HD televisions have the same picture quality and a lot of them do make an SD picture look horrible. One thing I do want to clarify is that the FCC anolog out but NOT FOR HD!! So many people think you have to have an HD tv to get a tv signal. The switch is from anolog to digital. The reason, as far as I can see, is that you can fit more digital information into a smaller bandwidth than an anolog signal. With the growing demand for bandwidth do to the communications explosion it is necessary to make the digital conversion to free up some of the frequencies used by analog signals.

  • 63 Posted by amylion777 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:53PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have an 26" LCD HDTV DVD combo and rabbit ears. I get a great picture thanks to the network channels who broadcast in HD; not to mention the extra channels they broadcast. I love it! And my HDTV automatically switches the screen size according to what is being broadcast. I am a graphic designer; I promise its not like a polaroid blown out. And it was only $200 more than the standard 27" TV with no DVD player. Way worth it. After reading this article its good to know I bought a great TV. Way to go Westinghouse!

  • 64 Posted by ocm2002snr on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:43PM EDT Report Abuse

    Lets not bash the upconvert at a quarter or more of the price of HD players, its a good alternative. But its not true 1080P its simulated through scaling and line doubling.

  • 65 Posted by theazianguy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    Ok so Ive been selling Home Theater equipment for almost 5 1/2 years and let me tell you something this is a very helpful article. I now help run a Magnolia Home Theater and we always encourage our customers to purchase the right product for THEM & THEIR LIFESTYLE. So pay attention (post 14:stoogesracing)we dont rip off people by selling them a 720p set if they dont want to purchase a 1080p set, we fully educate them and let them make up their decision. Thats why we offer some Pioneer Elites which are 720p sets but have the ability to accept a 1080p signal but down scale the resolution. Therefore there are no issues when it does receive a 1080p signal. Oh yeah by the way please tell me whos broadcasting in 1080p anyway and dont say bluray or hd dvd because thats a no brainer stoogesracing. If you want to get fully educated stop by any Magnolia Home Theater store and talk to a pro.

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.