Mon Apr 16, 2007 11:27AM EDT
See Comments (118)
Disappointed by how fuzzy CNN looks on your new HDTV? Wondering why Jack Bauer looks so soft and plump on your new flat-screen? Maybe it's because you're not really watching HD on your high-def TV.
According to Audioholics, almost half of the 24 million homes with HDTVs lack an HD cable or satellite feed, and about a quarter of those surveyed didn't even know they were still watching non-HD signals. Why such big numbers? Actually, it's not hard to understand; I can't tell you how many times I've watched salespeople at TV stores push HDTVs on hapless shoppers, going on and on about the razor-sharp picture and surround sound, but not bothering to tell them how to get HD signals into their living rooms.
The Audioholics story ticks off six things you need to know before you buy an HDTV, and it's a must-read if you're in the market for your first high-def set. Here's a brief summary of some of the pointers, along with some thoughts of my own:
Still confused? Then check out the Audioholics story, which goes into much greater detail.
Related:
Are You Sure You're Watching HDTV? [Audioholics]
Deciphering the Basic Roadmap for HDTV Connections
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
overall a great article but one thing you should try and avoid is the black bars on the sides of the screen. the longer you have those on there the more chance you have of burning that image into the tubes that display your picture onto the screen. i know this is the case with any tube projected pictures but im not sure with plasma and lcd. but i would think it still would not be a good idea. you end up with an image always showing up there while watching something else. then you have to replace the displa tubes which arent cheap.
I work at a BestBuy in Liberty Missouri, and I cannot thank you enough for making this post. You cannot imagine how many times I have had customers buy an HDTV without getting a proper signal or try and use the old RCA cabling, and they end up returning the TV. And speaking of cable guys, I wonder if anyone even trains these guys? The TimeWarner installers in Liberty do not even KNOW how to open the menu and set the audio signal to come out of an HDMI cable. We'll get people the good stuff, Monster HDMI, and yet the cable installers rip it out, badmouth us at BestBuy, and then use component video cables and ANALOG stereo audio units! Which sucks, because then you cannot get true surround sound (not through analog stereo cables anyway), and you have to do pro-logic or some such crap. I'm glad to see its not just me who wants to educate people on this, thanks a bunch for writing the article. PS: what stores have you shopped at that told people they did not need a hi-def signal to get HD? We freaking pump DirecHD and cable HD at BB, is Wal-Mart filling people with crap again?
Monster HDMI = waste of money. Digital is digital and unless you're trying to use a coat hangar and some solder, cheap is the best way to go. He should also mention you can zoom SD pictures to full screen effetively cropping the top and bottom but avoiding black bars and distortion.
This is good stuff. One thing I didn't see is that some of the HD set top boxes provided by satellite companies do not fully support HDMI (even though the machine will have an HDMI output) so using this with a high def screen can also cause degradation in picture or just plain problems with the signal. Thanks to my installers, I hooked up my new dish with the component cables and the picture quality is fine.
I bought mine a couple of years ago, just to find out the gov't keeps pushing the mandatory conversion date back. It sucks that there isn't much programming on cable that's HD.
In response to neonsohc84, on plasmas and rear projection TV's you have to worry about image burn from the side bars. LCD's you don't. This is a very good article. A lot of things have to be kept in mind when moving to the world of HD. Your picture quality is only as good as the source. Garbage in, garbage out. I have been installing, programming and designing Home Theaters for years and I own my own business doing so. I can't tell you how many times I have had to redo the work of a cable installer or sell the customer something else that was needed because the guy at BestBuy sold them an incomplete system. You are a rare one scryer as most employees at BestBuy only push what they are told with no understanding as to the nature of HD or the products that they push. So much so, that when my clients tell me that they want to buy their components at BestBuy, I tell them to have BestBuy deal with it and then call me after they still have problems. 25% of my business is because the client got the run around from the big box retailers. The other 75% is the niche group that want the best of the best that you won't find at BestBuy so it all works out anyways. Good luck to all of you out there. With manufacturers constantly upgrading/changing their products, we'll all need it.
Common sense is at an all time low...
nice article. but people also need to know the difference in the hd signals as well. 720p is not TRUE hd. 1080i & 1080p are the real deal. they need to understand that they are missing out on more of the true hd signal by going with only 720p. the more pixels your tv can handle, the much better the picture. I notice that most are being sold at 720p anymore (pay attention Best Buy guy in Libery), & people are getting truly ripped off.
Just because the government is forcing the stations to go digital doesn't mean you automatically get HD. Most stations will still broadcast in SD just using a digital signal.
"720p is not TRUE hd" Not true either. 720(p)rogressive is a valid HD resolution. In fact, for quick motion video (like sports) it is preferred over 1080(i)nterlaced as you will perceive less flicker. 1080i can be marginally better than 720p when there is no quick motion or camera movements. 1080p is always the best, but it takes a lot of bandwidth, so few broadcasters use it.
I've been watching SD content on a HD set for two years now, and the picture does not look "short and squat" nor does it look like a circus funhouse mirror. The picture may look a little stretched, but it beats taking a 50" TV and watching the action on a 32" picture.
There is a detailed list on what to look for at http://www.hometheaternetwork.com/HTN_HDTV1.htm
What I have yet to see explained anywhere is how an HDTV with tuner can yank HD signal out of the AIR with an antenna, but getting HD out of the CABLE from my cable company "requires" a set-top box/converter. Why is that??
I am thinking that you may be wrong about most programs defininion. I was prepared to see a lot of bad looking programs when I hooked up my HDTV, but I was pleasantly surprised that even old shows like friends are shown digitally and some even say 1080i even though they are standard size 1.33 to 1. Nevertheless most TV is now digital and about the only show that has a bad digital signal is an old byron Allen show which I really don't care about anyway.... So I disagree. Many people will be pleasantly surprised in the big cities (Detroit) how good the digital signal of a regular tv starion really is
Everyone as made good points about HDTV. I want to bring up a something that hasn't been said yet. HDTV and Digital TV do not go in hand in hand. When the transition is made in 2009, to digital TV not every thing will be in HDTV. Yes, it will be digital signal. It may still be in standard definition. All the hardware in the world, can sitting in your house. It won't change anything your watching to HDTV. It will still be digital standard definition. Some local stations in smaller markets at this time may find the cost is to high for them to broadcast in HDTV. The national broadcasters can send their signal as HDTV to affiliates (local) stations. Only to be send out by them as a digital standard signal. HDTV will come to all of us at some point in the future. But standard definition will still be with us for a few more years. Even after the big change over.
Almost all tv's now are set up for HD now and include the digital tuner. All TVs made after March 1, 2007, by law, must have a digital tuner. So it's going to be hard to find a new tv that is capable of doing HD right out of the box.
FORGET CABLE & SATELLITE! I have HDTV and recieve over 40 HD channels using a regular antennae. Break the TV junkie cycle and save money by getting rid of cable and satellite service.
If you're a penny pincher but want HDTV, remember, there is no such thing as "bad" over the air reception with HD. If all you have are rabbit ears and are within the slightly tighter broadcast "circle" of HDTV broadcasters, your TV will be every bit as crisp and interesting as that which you might have piped to your house through cable or satellite. I think most of us would opt for a TV signal carrier of some sort or other, but it's a quiet little secret that HDTV sets don't actually NEED them. It's supposed to be one of the pluses in high def taking over in the first place but since there's no money in everyone using rabbit ears, no-one talks about it!
There is some good info for those that don't know what HTDV truely is. I really dont see HD coming into full swing for another 2-3 years. I have a samsung 50" DLP HDTV and its great. The only thing i dont like is the fact that i only get about 30 HD channels total (local and Cable). AQnd i only watch about half that (Discovery HD being the most watched). I suggest that those that still want more info read the full article. This just barely skims the surface of what there is to learn about HD and HD signals.
Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.
| Computers | Home Office | Wi-Fi & Networking | Phones & PDAs | Cameras & Camcorders | TV & Home Theater | Portable Audio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 Posted by dprivett69 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:47PM EDT Report Abuse
this was really great help - thank you