GPS Tops Consumer Shopping Lists

Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:11PM EST

See Comments (95)

Maybe they're tired of fighting about which way to turn, or maybe they're feeling a bit fragile and lost, but this holiday, GPS is topping many shoppers' lists. Amazon Electronics, the bellwether of who's buying what, just sent me a list of its top 25 most-purchased items last week. The Garmin Nuvi, in various models, appeared four times on the list. (Other repeated top sellers included Canon and Apple.)

Why the run on GPS now? The technology is finally mature enough that it really can get you where you need to be and keep you safe while driving at the same time. The price is reasonable enough. In addition, it's become a one-stop dashboard topper that can tell you where you are or where you want to be (as in the nearest gas station), let you talk wirelessly to others, or entertain you with photos, music, and more. And the new bells and whistles just keep getting better.

One of the reasons Garmin is so popular is that there's a perfect unit for everyone. (Or, looking at it another way, you may find the 35 different models of Garmins available just for automobiles a bit mind-boggling.) According to numerous shopping reports, Garmin's entry-level Street Pilot 550c was a huge seller on Black Friday.

If it's small you need, the Garmin Nuvi 350 (shown above) is one of the most compact global positioning systems ever. It weighs just over five ounces and is not much bigger than a pack of index cards, but its screen is bright and easy to navigate. It has a built-in music player and displays photos as an added extra. Many of the bells and whistles—like the free traffic alerts, travel guides, and downloadable audiobooks—require additional purchases.

The heftier big brother is the new Garmin Nuvi 700 series. Some of these models offer special tools for world travelers, such as maps of Europe. They include Bluetooth so that you can talk on your wireless phone through the GPS. The screen is bright and the maps beautifully rendered. Extras such as an FM antenna let you play music, hear turn-by-turn voice directions, and even download and play new audiobooks through your car stereo. One of the best reviews is at GPSReview.net.

David Pogue reviewed the Magellan Maestro 4040 and others in a recent New York Times roundup. He enjoyed both the low price and new features, such as being able to say, "Magellan, nearest ATM," and have the results appear. Magellan also carries the AAA database of restaurants, lodging, and travel blurbs. He gives the thumbs-up to the new traffic and accident alerts, but says the maps are not as pretty as some of the others.

One of the newbies on the market is part of our Last Gadget Standing competition at CES this year: the Dash Navigation System. Think of it as a GPS meets social network. Your GPS and others can share traffic information in real time as you're driving. Recently Dash announced its Express Model. It's opened up its application to developers, which means you could be doing anything from shopping for real estate to finding the best bar in town on your GPS.

Trying to figure out how much memory your device should have for maps or whether you need an antenna to pick up a stronger signal from the satellite beaming location information to you? There's a nice list of features on GPSInfo.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on GPS Tops Consumer Shopping Lists

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 66 Posted by dprofiteer on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:47PM EDT Report Abuse

    TOM TOM's are crap. They make one good low cost model. No high end or innovation.

  • 67 Posted by tyrone_1066 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:26PM EDT Report Abuse

    The TOMTOM is garbage! Some people like sidekicks and choc phones and some like iphones and crackberry curves. Some have childish immature tastes. Garmin has been making aviation GPS units for a long time now and they know what they are doing. I have a nuvi 250W and it is great is you are not interested in mp3, bluetooth, etc.

  • 68 Posted by cwboyfn on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:33PM EDT Report Abuse

    To the person asking about the Garmin c330. I have had a Garmin c330 now for the past year. Last year when I first purchased it I did it for I was about to take a long trip. I left Williamsburg, traveled down the East Coast, across Fl, across the Gulf Coast, to San Deago, up to Las Angeles and Las Vegas. I then went up the West Coast to Portland Or, then across to Mt. Rushmore in South Dakota,then down through several mountainous states back up accross the top of the states. When I arrived home in Williamsburg, it had been quiet a trip. I was on and off the road puling a camper all the way. The Garmin came in handy quiet a bit on my long journey. It guided me all the way and kept me abrest of traffic situations, fuel, food and campgrounds. By the way I never explained I did not travel the Interstates. I used all back roads as much as possabe. The only time I got on Interstates was when it was necessary to get by an obsticle. At the earliest moment I would get back on the side roads, for I wanted to see the country and places no one can see from interstates. In summary: The Garmen c330 was the best monitary investment I have ever made and I plan to head out again on more travels using it. I don't know anything about the Nuvi200, but from experience I can speak for the c330. I was gone for about 60+ days and depended on the it rather than using Map Quest or any other maps and that was great for a change. Now that I am home I still use it for locating addresses in my home town. In the past if I had to be somewhere In the local area I would always recon before I attemped venture out. Now I just enter the address and Garmin c330 takes me with 10 feet of my destination. In the past if we went on trips my wife navigated with maps as I drove. It was nice to have someone navigate for me rather than my wife :), and not have to fumble with maps or ask directions from other's. There is noting more that I can say except you would not be disapointed with a Garmin c330 GPS. I hope this not only answers your question, but assist other's that my be concerned also.

  • 69 Posted by nic324nic on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:37PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have a Garmin Nuvi 350 it is a great unit for the price, and I love the fact that it speaks street names instead of just saying "turn right in 200 ft". I like the whole Nuvi line from Garmin, but they get pricey.

  • 70 Posted by c.hall45 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:16PM EDT Report Abuse

    tom tom is the best never had ant promblems

  • 71 Posted by lbzmax06 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    This quickly has turned into a PRO Tom Tom forum! Looks like the Tom Tom advertisement people have done their homework and turned the majority into loyal consumers. It's ok, Garmin is still a good product but no match for the Tom Tom loyalist. Tom Tom! Where's din din?

  • 72 Posted by jcelmoreno on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    Niverent, I don't think the article is biased just because they don't mention tomtom. You only know of tomtom because they advertise alot. I work in a retail store and they have the highest return rate. I sell a garmin and more than likely my customers don't have any problems. Most people buy gps because they are tired of mapquest so why buy a tomtom which has the say mapping system? Navteq and garmin have way more history and better accuracy

  • 73 Posted by maniaxe2000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:05PM EDT Report Abuse

    Yeah where the heck are the tom toms!!!! I've had one since the original tom tom came out in the USA. The user interface is the BEST and the maps are so much more accurate now!!!

  • 74 Posted by pass_the_dice on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    Whatever happened to learning how to read a map? How braindead are we becoming? If this get responses this will only prove my point.

  • 75 Posted by snakebite1968 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    Did any of you people even read this article? It’s not a review of anything it’s an analysis of a list sent to the author by a third party. The list is a “list of its [Amazon Electronics] top 25 most-purchased items last week”. Obviously if Tom Toms are having delivery and stock problems (which they are) and are all sold out then they couldn’t of sold that many last week since they didn’t have any to sell (duh). Therefore there not going to be on the list. Quit your dang whining! Make sure you read and understand the information being presented to you before you open up your mouth and complain.

  • 76 Posted by faerielovesong803 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    jcelmoreno has a point about the garmin being more reliable.but the tom tom's are still very popular,especially the tom tom one series.but even so,the article is still ridiculous.even though garmins sell more,tom toms sell way more at my retail store than magellans do,and most customers complain about the magellan and return them. second of all,there was barely even a mention of features. the most important feature is text to speech,and she didn't even mention it or that the garmin streetpilot c340 is the cheapest garmin with the feature. obviously she doesn't know much about gps's. if you really want to know about which gps is best,go to your local electronic retailer and ask their sales person.they know more than she does.

  • 77 Posted by lisaclem06 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:53PM EDT Report Abuse

    In Defense of Garmin... Garmin is a good product. I've owned one (a 60CS, a handheld with car window suction mount purchased separately) for a couple years now. I would recommend it to anyone. It was pricey (I forgot the price, irrelevant as it's discontinued) but I love it. And unlike a digital camera that only gets old, this has map files you can update annually. I DEFINITELY recommend a GPS you don't HAVE to use in the car - one you can carry around outside if you choose. // Can't figure out the prices of GPS's available? You need some internet lessons. It's not this article's job to do your shopping for you.

  • 78 Posted by dybusrj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    Have a TOMTOM 910 and a Nextar W3 and would be lost with out them, I get lost going around the block........lol

  • 79 Posted by ice4christ on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:22PM EDT Report Abuse

    ***ATTENTION ALL READERS*** This is pure advertisment from Garmin! This is exactly what is called "GUERILLA MARKETING" for garmin, all the article is about garmin. Now dont get me wrong, Garmin is good, but not necesarlly the best...it actually has the most market share out of all Gps's wich is diffrent from being the best, and has been in the market longer. HERE ARE THE TOP 4 GPS'S IN THE MARKET TODAY: 1)GARMIN, 2)TOM TOM, 3)MEGALLAN and last, but not least 4)NAVIGON. what has ranked navigon as #3 is the reason that they swept a good portion of the market share in no time,with a good price and good quality wich megallan and tom tom took forever to do, and navigon. Navigon has also allied with "SIEMENS" and "FUJITSU" to come with a gps with mp3, games, digital pciture holder, changeable face off, and much more. My prediction....navigon is new to the market, but do not underestimate them! i gurantee you will be hearing about them more frequently.....! they are just new, also to watch out is "Hewlett Packard", they just started to do thier GPS'S but still is pending of them to prove thier queality! for those who have OMNITECH GPS'S= GOOOOD LUCK on that one...it is a Staples brand, they are a retailer..which manufactures a lot of things with china(cheap, but not good) sincerley, MANUFACTURES REP, AND STOCK HOLDER! :)

  • 80 Posted by apple_grower on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    Leaving out Tom Tom shows who is paying their bills.

  • 81 Posted by ruuca_2000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I think one of the most impressive features that the Garmin has over the tom tom is the SD card reader for extra memory. I like the car icons you can download as well.

  • 82 Posted by ikabod8 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:23PM EDT Report Abuse

    OOooooooo-kayyyyyyyyy...... then what? The title summarized the whole article. Let me rewrite this..... go to http://www.GPSreview.net

  • 83 Posted by briantmclaughlin on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:13PM EDT Report Abuse

    Golly-gee, I worked at Etak, the people who invented car nav, using cassette tapes and tie-rod telemetry! Then, I used a Tom-Tom this summer in my Teleatlas (nee Etak, nee GDT) mobile mapping van while cruising a country road in West Virginny and almost drove off the side of a mountain using their data that was just a little out of date and didn't reflect a little country road being closed because of it degenerating into a near-vertical cow-path that dead-ended into a "highway to nowhere". Gosh, I hope the data has been updated since then!

  • 84 Posted by dybusrj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    tyrone 1066........................... That's a real high end modle !!!!!!!!!!!

  • 85 Posted by dybusrj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    accipter2001................ went to the article and what is the FIRST unit they talk about T H E T O M T O M 9 2 0 T !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ONCE AGAIN someone with (mine is better than yours) grow up

More Posts: First Prev 3 4 5 6 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.