The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Wed Aug 9, 2006 1:58PM EDT

See Comments (261)

You want them to write a killer paper and email home; they'd like to take in an in-dorm movie, work on their Facebook pages, and listen to music. Here's a checklist for this year's back-to-dorm features that will bring inter-generational peace and harmony.

  1. They really do need their own PC at school. Despite the fact that schools tend have lots of computers in public spaces like labs, libraries, student study centers, and dorm common rooms, most college students (90 percent according to Fairfield University) bring their own computers. Burden as it may be, one dean from Purchase College put it this way: Students study, write, create, chat, research, shop—you name it—at all hours of the day, not just when computer labs are staffed and opened.
  2. Don't give them your old hand-me-down or an old PC you have around the house. This machine will be their lifeline, studyline, and entertainment line for the next four years.
  3. You probably want a notebook PC rather than a desktop. Notebooks are more versatile and they travel home with ease. There used to be a huge price difference between notebooks and desktops, so notebooks were really a strain on the pocketbook, but not today.
  4. Mac or PC? Definitely visit the college web site and get a sense for what they recommend and support. While no campus will say "no" to bringing one brand versus another, they do show favoritism. They might offer some services (anti-virus and other utilities, tech support, and so on) more universally for their favored platform. It's a good idea to go with the flow on the school's bias, because you're bound to get better service.
  5. Buying from the bookstore? Sometimes the college campuses have great educational discounts on certain PCs. Typically, if they carry them in the store they're likely to have some sort of tech support or coverage. You can often do as well, or nearly as well, buying online, but the convenience of having a store to deal with may be worth it.
  6. You want a good wireless connection. That means built-in 802.11g Wi-Fi (which comes standard on virtually all current laptops). The majority of campuses now have large portions that are wireless "hot spots." Bluetooth and infrared are both nice extras, but not as essential.
  7. A roomy keyboard. This is one place you shouldn't skimp, and you probably don't want an ultra-portable notebook, even though it's really lightweight. For the next four years your student is going to be typing quite a bit and a full sized roomy keyboard makes a difference.
  8. Battery. Not as essential on campus as other places because there are plenty of outlets, but if they're taking the computer to campus all day and have lots of those two or three-hour labs, long battery life might be a consideration.
  9. Mouse vs. touch pad. Since college students are often working on small desks I like to see them using built in touch pads. External mice are one more thing to cart around and potentially lose.
  10. USB ports. They'll want at least two or three of these for plugging in peripherals like digital cameras, flash disks, and so on.
  11. DVD/CD-RW. The ability to read DVDs and burn CDs is the baseline you'll want.
  12. Screen size. These kids can carry a bit of weight (they're young) so a notebook with a large screen—say 15 inches—is probably a good idea. The more they can see of the "larger picture" as they work, the better off they'll be.
  13. Decent sound and fast graphics. For many students the computer doubles as their entertainment system to watch a DVD or stream music.
  14. Backup and storage. Not as essential as you might think for students who are given generous amounts of space on campus. If they're not watching digital movies streamed from their hard drive, 60GB should do the trick. But of course, bigger is better.
  15. Processor. Again, unless they are crunching numbers, doing lots of graphics-intensive things like art or architecture, or playing Halo tournaments by night, you can skimp a bit here.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 26 Posted by winterman_43 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:47PM EDT Report Abuse

    I disagree somewhat with you on the PC vs Laptop deal. I have recently sent two through college and am going back myself at the moment. In my opinion, you get way more for the money for a PC as compared to a laptop...and PCs are easier and cheaper to maintain, repair, and use. You don't have to fool with the smaller keypad, monitor, and those darn batteries. The ONLY advantage a laptop has is its mobility; if you have to be mobile, then you have no choice. And know that about 90% (or more) of all schools and all businesses go with the PC platform, NOT Macs....just some friendly advice. smiles :-)

  • 27 Posted by rwhite1917 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I just finished my first year of college, and first year of being a mac user/owner. I was hesitant at first to 'switch' to a mac, but my older brother and friends advised me to get a mac for college. I've had my Mac PowerBook since june '05 and I can honestly say that I made the right decision! In regards to some colleges not having good 'support' for macs, well the answer is simple: THEY DONT NEED SUPPORT! While my roomate, who brought a laptop pc, was fighting off viruses/adware/spyware the whole year I didn't have one problem! I was able to plug right into the campus network, I was able to pickup wireless, connect to printers in the labs, do everything a 'pc' would do and without any problem whatsoever.

  • 28 Posted by rwhite1917 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I just finished my first year of college, and first year of being a mac user/owner. I was hesitant at first to 'switch' to a mac, but my older brother and friends advised me to get a mac for college. I've had my Mac PowerBook since june '05 and I can honestly say that I made the right decision! In regards to some colleges not having good 'support' for macs, well the answer is simple: THEY DONT NEED SUPPORT! While my roomate, who brought a laptop pc, was fighting off viruses/adware/spyware the whole year I didn't have one problem! I was able to plug right into the campus network, I was able to pickup wireless, connect to printers in the labs, do everything a 'pc' would do and without any problem whatsoever.

  • 29 Posted by mattsjopson on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:11PM EDT Report Abuse

    I am a 4th year college student and I have to say that laptops are just not worth it. They are inferior in every single way to desktops except for portability. I highly recommend a solid desktop with a nice 19in (or larger) LCD. I have known so many people who have gotten laptops stolen (easier to steal), had them break (they are way less reliable), you can't fix them yourself (no simply swapping out bad parts), and had them go obsolete (they aren't really upgradeable). Furthermore, even the largest laptop screens pale in comparison to desktops, especially when comparing price. Larger desktop LCD screens are so much nicer for so many reasons, including workspace and entertainment, and viewing angle. Touchpad mice are extremely annoying to use compared to mice, and they reduce productivity, and also hinder your ability to play any games. I forced my girlfriend to try a mouse with her laptop, and after using a mouse she couldn't imagine how she ever used a touchpad. Laptops can be very noisy and hot. Some will come with fans that spin up at full speed, and when this happens you will begin to hate being around it. Finally, fast graphics will cost you a serious premium on a laptop, much more so than with a desktop. Bottom line: With a desktop, you will suffer a tiny bit more during move-in, but you will thank yourself for the extra hauling effort the rest of the year when actually using the computer. Buy a cheap laptop only if you have a solid desktop already.

  • 30 Posted by robmysterj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    The comment about macs not getting viruses... that's true if your running mac OS but you said the macbook pro will run windows too in teh same sentence. If you put MS Windows on your new mac then you are subject to all the same viruses, pop-ups, worms, trojuns, etc you get on a PC. Kind of defeats the purpose of paying premium price for a mac to put windows on it, don't you think?

  • 31 Posted by devinmarble on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:42PM EDT Report Abuse

    Get an external HD! You never know when your computer is going to crash or get a virus. Even if it's only 10GB, they are not that expensive and students can back up all their documents and music on it simply by dragging and dropping files. It will save time and money when the computer bogs out. If external HD's are too $$, at least get a keychain flash drive for their documents.

  • 32 Posted by terryavton on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    Whatever your system, please tell me how I can print articles such as Raskin's without the right side of the article NOT PRINTING! while the left side remains a large expanse of white!

  • 33 Posted by tabevolution on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    This is stupid, processor speed is important no matter what your doing and you will definitely want to add more programs and games to your computer sooner or later so why skimp. Where I go to school labs are open all day and night. You really don't need a computer for school, just for entertainment.

  • 34 Posted by ijswan on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:23PM EDT Report Abuse

    Why not a dell? Please educate me...as I am looking for one for my nephew. Thank you.

  • 35 Posted by kupriaa1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    Stop with the MAC stuff. It is the same reason why no one recommends using Gentoo, Fedora, Suse, or AIX. Great OSes- even cheaper than MACs. But why not- great tech support? Linux has better- and plus they too are typically immune to most window based viruses. The person who mentions they are a network admin- thanx for your worthless experience. I have experience with many oses. If you want cheap useful and secure OS go with Fedora 5. If you want a compatible OS goes with Windows. No room for a worthless OS such as MAC. I would recommend AIX but no one has money for it.

  • 36 Posted by mhasskam on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:17PM EDT Report Abuse

    My oldest daughter took a PC laptop to school freshman year. There were frequent problems with installations gone wrong, blue screen of death, maybe I have a virsu, how do I configure this, etc. That summer, I got her a Mac. Mind you, I don't have a Mac, and I don't use one at work. So don't blast off that I'm a MacHead ;-] But I was impressed with what happened. The support calls ended. I have two on college now, and they both use Macs. They're not computer geeks, and now they don't need to be. But they do enjoy their Macs, and they have no desire to go back.

  • 37 Posted by aznpunk989 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    I find that processor can be very important at times. As college students will be exposed to potentially unsecured wireless networks at times while plugging into worldwide sites like Myspace and Facebook... the possibility of viruses can skyrocket. Processing speed can help aleviate any negative effects long enough to remove them. Factoring in processing behemoths like Photoshop (and other graphics softwares), smart browers like AOL Browser or Mozilla, and heavy media programs like RealPlayer and iTunes... I would definately suggest at least giving heavy consideration to processing speed. For a notetaker, keyboard, processor and harddrive space are everything. I suppose one could probably take away from attention from entertainment-based things like superior speakers or a large screen, but for an on-the-go student at a place where they SHOULD be studying, a computer needs to be able to WORK.

  • 38 Posted by kristen_flanagan on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:53PM EDT Report Abuse

    One advantage of a laptop is that you can get out of the dorm and work if it is too noisy. If you have a heavy writing load for your courses, this can be invaluable. At my university students seem to think that the computer lab is a place for socializing, not work. Being able to find a quiet corner in the library or anywhere else can be useful. At the same time, you get more for your money with a desktop.

  • 39 Posted by ccorbet1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:20PM EDT Report Abuse

    You left out 2 big issues - RAM (Memory) and Microsoft Office. Having at least 512MB of RAM is key to a smooth performing system no matter the processor you purchase. If you can afford 1GB of RAM, buy it. The system will use as much as you put in. Many PC offers will leave out office altogether. Students qualify for "Student Teacher Edition" for the low price of roughly $149. It's a great deal and typically cuts down the cost of having Office bundled with the system or spending close to $400 buying it seperate.

  • 40 Posted by lroux on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:58PM EDT Report Abuse

    Sorry, but a Mac is NOT a good idea. As a tech person at a University I can tell you Macs a) have less support, b) some software such as large registration systems purchased by Universities (PeopleSoft) do not work particularly well on Macs; not to mention some web sites, and c) Games, dude. Half Life 2 is not available for the Mac. Unless you are a graphics designer or a musician who needs a Mac, stay away from them for school. Yup. Macs are great...but you'll be wishing you had both if you have a Mac, and you will just have to be more careful about viruses if you have a PC.

  • 41 Posted by tenaciouse1080 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    This is the largest promotion for the greatest marketing scheme in history. Schools are BANNING laptops from classrooms because the kids don't "study" or "note take" as those stupid commercials describe. If your son/daughter is away from home, get him/her a desktop that STAYS AT THEIR HOME/DORM

  • 42 Posted by bnp_p1990 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:10PM EDT Report Abuse

    I'll say desktop because its faster and cheaper but it really depends. I dont really carry my laptop anywhere so I'll say desktop.

  • 43 Posted by bigmike485 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:07PM EDT Report Abuse

    #4 Mac or PC: not an issue anymore. two words: boot camp.

  • 44 Posted by davidz901 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:38PM EDT Report Abuse

    "since macs don't get viruses, the money you'd save on virus software you can use to get windows if you MUST have it" Macs get viruses, too, there just aren't as many of them...and if they're running Windows, then they're pretty much as likely to get viruses as anything else. Also, you can get pretty much any amount of virus protection that you want for free, legally, if you know where to look. Personally, I would only recommend a Mac if you were focusing and arts and such, such as CAD, or video editing.

  • 45 Posted by primechaosx on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:18PM EDT Report Abuse

    mac= no no. yes it can dual boot windows but when in windows u CANNOT do anything but what u can do on a mac. yes office suites work better on windows but thats not good enough reason to get a mac that supports windows. as of right now the drivers for bootcamp make mac look laughable. u cant play games on mac (no entertainment if ur looking for it) you are better off getting a pc notebook, and downloading a bios hack to install osX on it ;D (just kidding). even the cheap pc notebooks supports everything. ive played halflife 2 on some of the lowest dumpyest (newer) laptops available and still had fun. also pc = more of everything and more availability and price ranges than mac. not to mention just about everyone knows how to fix pc's even little kids becuase its so easy to use compared to a mac.

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.