The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Wed Aug 9, 2006 1:58PM EDT

See Comments (261)

You want them to write a killer paper and email home; they'd like to take in an in-dorm movie, work on their Facebook pages, and listen to music. Here's a checklist for this year's back-to-dorm features that will bring inter-generational peace and harmony.

  1. They really do need their own PC at school. Despite the fact that schools tend have lots of computers in public spaces like labs, libraries, student study centers, and dorm common rooms, most college students (90 percent according to Fairfield University) bring their own computers. Burden as it may be, one dean from Purchase College put it this way: Students study, write, create, chat, research, shop—you name it—at all hours of the day, not just when computer labs are staffed and opened.
  2. Don't give them your old hand-me-down or an old PC you have around the house. This machine will be their lifeline, studyline, and entertainment line for the next four years.
  3. You probably want a notebook PC rather than a desktop. Notebooks are more versatile and they travel home with ease. There used to be a huge price difference between notebooks and desktops, so notebooks were really a strain on the pocketbook, but not today.
  4. Mac or PC? Definitely visit the college web site and get a sense for what they recommend and support. While no campus will say "no" to bringing one brand versus another, they do show favoritism. They might offer some services (anti-virus and other utilities, tech support, and so on) more universally for their favored platform. It's a good idea to go with the flow on the school's bias, because you're bound to get better service.
  5. Buying from the bookstore? Sometimes the college campuses have great educational discounts on certain PCs. Typically, if they carry them in the store they're likely to have some sort of tech support or coverage. You can often do as well, or nearly as well, buying online, but the convenience of having a store to deal with may be worth it.
  6. You want a good wireless connection. That means built-in 802.11g Wi-Fi (which comes standard on virtually all current laptops). The majority of campuses now have large portions that are wireless "hot spots." Bluetooth and infrared are both nice extras, but not as essential.
  7. A roomy keyboard. This is one place you shouldn't skimp, and you probably don't want an ultra-portable notebook, even though it's really lightweight. For the next four years your student is going to be typing quite a bit and a full sized roomy keyboard makes a difference.
  8. Battery. Not as essential on campus as other places because there are plenty of outlets, but if they're taking the computer to campus all day and have lots of those two or three-hour labs, long battery life might be a consideration.
  9. Mouse vs. touch pad. Since college students are often working on small desks I like to see them using built in touch pads. External mice are one more thing to cart around and potentially lose.
  10. USB ports. They'll want at least two or three of these for plugging in peripherals like digital cameras, flash disks, and so on.
  11. DVD/CD-RW. The ability to read DVDs and burn CDs is the baseline you'll want.
  12. Screen size. These kids can carry a bit of weight (they're young) so a notebook with a large screen—say 15 inches—is probably a good idea. The more they can see of the "larger picture" as they work, the better off they'll be.
  13. Decent sound and fast graphics. For many students the computer doubles as their entertainment system to watch a DVD or stream music.
  14. Backup and storage. Not as essential as you might think for students who are given generous amounts of space on campus. If they're not watching digital movies streamed from their hard drive, 60GB should do the trick. But of course, bigger is better.
  15. Processor. Again, unless they are crunching numbers, doing lots of graphics-intensive things like art or architecture, or playing Halo tournaments by night, you can skimp a bit here.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 46 Posted by wolf1999wolf on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    23 Posted by vetgirlosu on Sun Aug 13, 2006 3:25PM EDT Report Abuse $1099 for a MacBook. No viruses, no crashes, great customer support. You're wasting your money if you go with anything else. No viruses correct but you say no crashes im might agree because HARDLEY ANY PROGRAM ARE COMPATIBLE TO INSTALL TO EVEN CRASH IN THE FIRST PLACE

  • 47 Posted by meleabates on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:15PM EDT Report Abuse

    I disagree with this article. As a parent of 3 College Students I consider myself somewhat of an expert. My first 2 daughters received laptops. My third daughter received a desktop for the following reasons: 1. There is a substantial price difference 2. More bang for the buck - Bigger monitor, more mem., etc. 3. Chances of thievery on a laptop are orders of magnitude higher than a desktop. 4. Chances of damage to a laptop are orders of magnitude higher than a desktop. 5. With cheap flash drives, and desktops available at home and just about anywhere else, why would a student need a portable computer?

  • 48 Posted by robmysterj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have to agree there is a lot of flawed logic in the writer's article. She really needs to go do some price checking before writing suggestions based on price shopping. You can get decent PC's now for $400 to $600 everywhere, new in the box and the cheapest notebooks I have yet to see are $700 to $1k. If you spend $1k on a desktop these days I guarantee you will get twice the memory, hard drive space and a lot faster CPU unless you just go buy some overpriced named brand.

  • 49 Posted by masotil on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:10PM EDT Report Abuse

    Most of these laptops will be Intel-based and no mention is made of the processor. The Intel M class processor is ideal for laptops. It has low power consumption (longer use before battery recharge) and they are as fast as equivalent Celeron in speed.

  • 50 Posted by lightstream2000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    Print it from a mac...macs have what-you-see-is-what-you-get printing from the internet. PC's don't, and no pc tech has ever been able to tell me why, or how to correct it..except by copying and pasting it to WORD, or using the "printer friendly" button sometimes provided at the top of the page. Oh,well.

  • 51 Posted by amacgeek on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    Those who state that student should stay away from the Mac have no grounds to argue from. All new Mac that run an Intel chip can run Windows, at full speed. You have the option to boot directly into Windows if you so choose, and never run the Mac OS (but you need it installed), or you can run the Mac OS with Windows running in, well, a window (recommended). So this horsepucky about some campuses not allowing/supporting Macs is a non-issue. A Mac is now, and in my humble opinion, has always been, the machine to choose. My older brother graduated USC with a degree in Business Computing using a Mac. That was over six years ago. He was able to complete all of his assignment, run all of the programs needed for his classes and connect to the campus resources using System 8, years before OS X. So I close saying to anyone claiming a Windows-based PC is the only way to go, you have a lot of homework to do. Because your argurment doesn't hold water.

  • 52 Posted by slkayton on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    Almost all colleges are PC (Windows), not Mac these days. And if you're majoring in math, science or engineering, then you need Windows, because most of the math analysis software won't run on a Mac. Make sure to get a thumb drive (keychain drive/flash memory drive) and back up everything often. Keep the thumb drive in your pocket so if the laptop gets stolen, you don't lose the backup also. Thousands of college laptops get stolen every month, so back it up or lose it!

  • 53 Posted by craigm1987 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    As far as the article goes, it is OK, but lacks some. The writer doesnt even mention RAM, quite possibly one of the most important factors regaurding speed. I really see the MacBook taking the market this year. Theyre already selling off the shelves. It seems like everyday I see more and more people possessing MacBooks. I myself use both platforms. I currently have a desktop homebuilt pc running xp pro, and a new MacBook Pro (15" 1.8ghz, 1.5 gigs ram). It's a stunning machine, but it has drawbacks. For those people that think Macs dont crash...What a complete lie. I get crashes when running programs under rosetta all the time. Now, all the programs that run under a universal binary run completely fine, but programs that run under rosetta crash quite frequently (MS office). For anybody going into graphic design, I dont really know what to tell you. Adobe CS2 is not out on a Universal Binary yet, so its painfully slow even on my computer. But when it comes out on UB (spring 2007 I think) its going to scream. People going into film/video--Definately go with a MacBook Pro. Final cut pro screams on it now that its out on universal. I edited a 20 minute documentary on this laptop a little more than 3 months ago and it didnt crash once. It rendered fast, worked fast, everything was great. Just my two cents.

  • 54 Posted by naigogaiju on Sun Aug 13, 2006 3:43PM EDT Report Abuse

    Yeah hi, I don't know about the PC stuff but I just wanted to say that I thought that the Asain princess who appeared in the advertisement looked very prety. Thanks - Marc

  • 55 Posted by leo998811 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    laptops are better than desktop for college because you can bring the laptop to the libary and enter you reference which saves alot of time.

  • 56 Posted by lostwise on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    It doesn't hurt to be spoiled and rich either. P.C.'s are not essential, you can make it without them.

  • 57 Posted by qxsnoexp on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    The only reason Mac doesn't get viruses is because not enough people own it to write viruses for it. With the right anti-virus and protection, your windows could be protected from harm. And it really depends which sites you visit. My cousin helped me get an anti-virus program and it works just fine. The subscription just expired but I haven't been experiencing any problems because I've watched which sites I've been going to. You just have to be caution of the kind of site you're visiting. And an external hard-drive is much more reliable than an internal. Even though it costs more, you can just easily unplugged it when something goes wrong with your pc or notebook.

  • 58 Posted by mikesmachines2003 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:20PM EDT Report Abuse

    If you want to really help please list the computer companies and the features each one has --the article you just posted was a bunch of crap

  • 59 Posted by xx3doorsdownfan on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:53PM EDT Report Abuse

    Good tips that I'll need to use in 2 more years when I graduate high school!

  • 60 Posted by cs_gmlynarczyk on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:31PM EDT Report Abuse

    A few comments... First, a big screen doesn't necessarily mean you'll fit more on your screen. Most manufacturers like to throw on a low-resolution 15" XGA screen because it's cheap. A 14- or 15-inch screen needs to be at least SXGA+ (or the widescreen equivalent, WSXGA+) Unless your computer offers Multibay optical drives, get a DVD burner. It's almost necessary even today, and if you want your computer to be running strong for four years, don't shortchange it now. If your computer supports Multibay drives, you can get whatever you want now and if you decide in the future you want something different, you can always upgrade. Also, you can't really skimp on the processors, especially with the imminent release of Windows Vista. Even people who are doing simple tasks such as word processing will need more muscle than ever just to run the OS. A dual-core Turion 64 X2 or Core Duo (or Core 2 Duo) is the only way to go. Don't forget to mention memory. 512MB just isn't enough, especially for systems that use shared graphics memory. 1GB of memory will minimize pagefile usage, which will speed things up considerably. Lastly, 60GB should be a bare minimum for hard drives, but perhaps more important is the hard drive speed. Most retail stores like Best Buy and Circuit City, who frequently try to pass things over on customers who don't know better, throw in 4200RPM hard drives, which are anciently slow. 5400RPM should be considered standard, and if offered, look for 7200RPM. Warranty: Get an extended warranty with Accidental Damage Protection. Drops can get expensive. Broken screen = $750, easily. Other comments in response to others: A keyboard is most certainly necessary, and so is a mouse, even if you only use it at your desk. Better yet, get a wireless set which will free you from the cords and only take up one USB port (as opposed to 2 for a separately wired keyboard and mouse.) Unless your school prefers Macs, or you're planning to run BootCamp, buy a PC. 90% of the world runs on it, and there's no telling what kind of compatibility problems you'll run in to. If you bring a Mac into a PC environment, you had better know how to fix everything yourself, because your school's IT support will likely not offer help. Likewise, don't bring a PC to a Mac environment. Tablet PCs are fun, but they're still in their baby stages, and while they have seem some refinement in the past few years they still have a way to go. If you think you'll use it to write notes on the screen, think again. You'll find that typing is much easier and faster, not to mention searchable. And handwriting recognition software is rarely satisfactory. Also, Tablet PCs tend to have less muscle than notebooks in terms of CPUs, memory, and hard drives. Lastly, you don't need to spend anywhwere near $3k. $1,400-$1,800 for the average user, $1,800-$2,200 for those who require lots of muscle and dedicated graphics memory. You don't need an Alienware or a Dell XPS.

  • 61 Posted by lroux on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:58PM EDT Report Abuse

    Having a Mac with a dual boot to Windows makes it sound like you can run any windows program, but I tell you that is false. There are still some web sites and software that will not run properly on a Mac even if it is running Windows. I've never hit a site on a PC that I can't run properly. Believe me, I am no lover of Bill Gates, but it is time to admit he won the war.

  • 62 Posted by amacgeek on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    I've never said Mac get any more or less support than a Windows user. All I'm arguing is that a Mac can run Windows. To take your agrument to bear, then a Mac running with Windows should be able to receive the same amount of support. But for those of us who know, the real reason Mac running the Mac OS don't get the love Windows does by most campuses is simply those working in IT are not willing to provide the support. They could do themselve a favor to learn the OS that Windows is derived from, but they're just lazy and unwilling. This is the reason Mac's don't get love. To not use one for this reason is not a reason.

  • 63 Posted by robmysterj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    The mac arguments keep going on and on and on... and always pointing to the fact now they are intel based and can run windows... if you want to run windows, why pay 2 to 3 times as much for a mac hahaha, buy a PC... if you want to run Mac OS for what ever reason, not to be argued here... then buy a Mac; simple!

  • 64 Posted by wolf1999wolf on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    if your worried about virus subcriptions then get avg free you get full coverage all the time

  • 65 Posted by kupriaa1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    Print it from a mac...macs have what-you-see-is-what-you-get printing from the internet. PC's don't, and no pc tech has ever been able to tell me why - And i can tell you about IPSEC, TCP/IP, LT2P, Kerberos, WPA, AES, EFS and other important security concepts that are simple and more valuable than a WYSWYG sense. Vs Appleshare which isnt even around anymore moron. Most student dont care about your stupid little point. And by the way neither do i. There are many things a computer can do- Fedora can do more tricks than your worthless MAC OS.

More Posts: First Prev 2 3 4 5 6 Next Last

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.