The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Wed Aug 9, 2006 1:58PM EDT

See Comments (261)

You want them to write a killer paper and email home; they'd like to take in an in-dorm movie, work on their Facebook pages, and listen to music. Here's a checklist for this year's back-to-dorm features that will bring inter-generational peace and harmony.

  1. They really do need their own PC at school. Despite the fact that schools tend have lots of computers in public spaces like labs, libraries, student study centers, and dorm common rooms, most college students (90 percent according to Fairfield University) bring their own computers. Burden as it may be, one dean from Purchase College put it this way: Students study, write, create, chat, research, shop—you name it—at all hours of the day, not just when computer labs are staffed and opened.
  2. Don't give them your old hand-me-down or an old PC you have around the house. This machine will be their lifeline, studyline, and entertainment line for the next four years.
  3. You probably want a notebook PC rather than a desktop. Notebooks are more versatile and they travel home with ease. There used to be a huge price difference between notebooks and desktops, so notebooks were really a strain on the pocketbook, but not today.
  4. Mac or PC? Definitely visit the college web site and get a sense for what they recommend and support. While no campus will say "no" to bringing one brand versus another, they do show favoritism. They might offer some services (anti-virus and other utilities, tech support, and so on) more universally for their favored platform. It's a good idea to go with the flow on the school's bias, because you're bound to get better service.
  5. Buying from the bookstore? Sometimes the college campuses have great educational discounts on certain PCs. Typically, if they carry them in the store they're likely to have some sort of tech support or coverage. You can often do as well, or nearly as well, buying online, but the convenience of having a store to deal with may be worth it.
  6. You want a good wireless connection. That means built-in 802.11g Wi-Fi (which comes standard on virtually all current laptops). The majority of campuses now have large portions that are wireless "hot spots." Bluetooth and infrared are both nice extras, but not as essential.
  7. A roomy keyboard. This is one place you shouldn't skimp, and you probably don't want an ultra-portable notebook, even though it's really lightweight. For the next four years your student is going to be typing quite a bit and a full sized roomy keyboard makes a difference.
  8. Battery. Not as essential on campus as other places because there are plenty of outlets, but if they're taking the computer to campus all day and have lots of those two or three-hour labs, long battery life might be a consideration.
  9. Mouse vs. touch pad. Since college students are often working on small desks I like to see them using built in touch pads. External mice are one more thing to cart around and potentially lose.
  10. USB ports. They'll want at least two or three of these for plugging in peripherals like digital cameras, flash disks, and so on.
  11. DVD/CD-RW. The ability to read DVDs and burn CDs is the baseline you'll want.
  12. Screen size. These kids can carry a bit of weight (they're young) so a notebook with a large screen—say 15 inches—is probably a good idea. The more they can see of the "larger picture" as they work, the better off they'll be.
  13. Decent sound and fast graphics. For many students the computer doubles as their entertainment system to watch a DVD or stream music.
  14. Backup and storage. Not as essential as you might think for students who are given generous amounts of space on campus. If they're not watching digital movies streamed from their hard drive, 60GB should do the trick. But of course, bigger is better.
  15. Processor. Again, unless they are crunching numbers, doing lots of graphics-intensive things like art or architecture, or playing Halo tournaments by night, you can skimp a bit here.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on The Perfect Dorm PC: Some Rules of Thumb

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 7 Posted by farjamed on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:58PM EDT Report Abuse

    a laptop is much better. while its true you will hardly ever take it out of your dorm, when you need to you can. and during vacation you can easily take it home.

  • 8 Posted by aristotle47 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I really must advise against a Macintosh. I know I will be flamed by adament Mac users, but unless the campus is a Mac-based network, or even a Mac-only network, Windows machines really will be more supported on campus. Like the one tip said, go with whatever brand is subtly biased towards by the school, as you will almost assuredly encounter more support for it there... and my experience has been that most campuses support Windows machines.

  • 10 Posted by jrimmortal on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:42PM EDT Report Abuse

    You really do need a mouse. Preferrably a wireless one that has the USB adapter plug into the base when it's not in use. You will have serious problems with cramped hands and a lack of versatility if you stick only to the touch pad. Also, this complete eliminates the ability to play 98% of the games out there, as well as do work in the Adobe Suites, CAD, web design, or really anything other than internet surfing and word processing. Lastly, you need a flash drive (at least 512 MB). Very easy to swap files with friends or keep your data on hand... just in case.

  • 11 Posted by leftwinghockeyplayer13 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:48PM EDT Report Abuse

    I am a college kid with the perfect setup. It cost me a good chunk of money (around $3K) but any kid working for a summer can make it. I got a good, stable, but cheap laptop that I only use for class and when I am out of the dorm then I have a very nice, DIY desktop that I use for gaming and when I am in my dorm. The point I have here is that it isn't essential to get a nice, expensive laptop. Go ing with two computers is the best way to go. My roommate and I both have nearly identical setups and it works perfectly. Besides setting up your laptop everytime you get back to your dorm or apartment is just annoying and time consuming when you could be playing some Counter-Strike. Oh and by the way no one plays Halo on computers...no one really plays halo anyway....we are all on our Xbox 360's playing Halo 2 like we should be.

  • 12 Posted by spirit_ranch on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:36PM EDT Report Abuse

    Buying a USB cable keyboard and a wireless mouse are well worth it. I use mine all the time and typing on a small keyboard sucks. You can find USB "extenion cords" at RadiopShack that turn one USB port into four port USBs

  • 13 Posted by terryavton on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    Why is is that all articles such as this one, that clearly are intended for reader to be able to print same, are set so far to the right of the page that when printed, you lose approx. one inch off the right side of the printed page, making if difficult, and sometimes impossible, to read??

  • 14 Posted by jacbob7 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:26PM EDT Report Abuse

    this is a waste of time. why dont you tell which brand is best and forget all the bull.

  • 15 Posted by zavesov on Thu Sep 3, 2009 11:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    i am a college student living in a dorm and i bougth an inspiron 6000 from dell. This thing is 6.65 lbs and I can tell you from experience that you want a lightweight notebook (something around 4-5 lbs). Kids who don't take their laptops to class dont want to carry all that weight around. otherwise they would. I personally wish I had bought a lighter ones because trying to keep pace with professor is impossible on a paper. Also make sure your laptop has a lot of USB drives (4 is perfect)(like the article says) and buying a flash is a must even if they dont use it at first.

  • 16 Posted by kupriaa1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    Once again- before you ever post about computers learn about them- you mention that processors arent too important unless they are crunching numbers. But just a few comments later you say students use them for dvd entertainment. I guess MPEG playing doesnt require a processor. Great analysis. How about important things like TURON and Centrino technologies? where is this discussion? RAM?

  • 18 Posted by frenzee2000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:03PM EDT Report Abuse

    She has not discussed the usefulness of a docking station. She says a large keyboard is a must, but I really don't see why the student can't just use a ultralight laptop and keep a 19" LCD and docking station at the dorm room with a standard sized keyboard with all the extra buttons. Also, special laptop micro-mice 1/3 or 1/4 the size of regular mice are available, as well as folding standard-size keyboards. Once more thing, extra storage can be kept at the dorm room via an external hard drive, which CAN be 160GB or more. True, all this costs extra money, but lugging around a 13 pound laptop across a huge campus (along with books and other supplies) should be illegal.

  • 20 Posted by amacgeek on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    Based on my experience as a University Network Admin here in Los Angeles, I'd have to say that a student's best bet is a new MacBook or MacBook Pro. If your student is not required to edit video, then a MacBook is the way to go. If you need to get into video production, of any kind, then go with a MacBook Pro. The key advantage to these laptops has everything to with their ability to run both Mac OS and Windows, but with the Mac OS being UNIX, they can connect to, not virtually, but ANY campus computer network. There simply is no other computer in the world that can make this claim. Add to this is the Mac's exemplary build quality and you'll have a computer than will make it all the way to graduation. And to those who argue the Mac is more expensive, go ahead, do some pricing from Apple's retail website, and compare these prices to like configured products from Gateway or Dell and you will be surprised. Then, since you're son or daughter is a student, visit Apple's Education Store for an additional savings. There are simply no more arguments to not go with a Mac anymore.

  • 21 Posted by robmysterj on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have to suggest staying away from Mac unless the school only uses them simply because intial cost, software and service are much more expensive and harder to find. As far as hard drive size, it wasn't to long ago a 20gb was gigantic. Most notebooks these days come with a 40gb or 60gb or larger which is more than adaquate for school work if not overkill. If you fill up a 40gb+ with music, your probably pirating it because that many mp3's would cost a ton to download or buy the cd's (approx. 20,000 songs). I also think there is a huge cost difference between desktops and notebooks unlike the article says. Sure, notebooks are now the price desktops were a few years ago, but in comparision desktops are 1/2 to 2/3 the price for the same thing. Also upgrading a desktop or adding high end stuff is much easier and cost effective. I would only suggest a notebook if the school requires mobility. At least at my University there are computer labs everywhere and you can always email yourself what you were working or put it on a lowcost usbdrive.

  • 22 Posted by vetgirlosu on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:34PM EDT Report Abuse

    $1099 for a MacBook. No viruses, no crashes, great customer support. You're wasting your money if you go with anything else.

  • 23 Posted by littlemisschitown on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:54PM EDT Report Abuse

    you can get a mac for colleges, especially the new macbook and macbook pro. they actually do run windows, and since macs don't get viruses, the money you'd save on virus software you can use to get windows if you MUST have it. Also, macs can use ms office and hardly ever crash. FYI: students can get discounts on office, mac laptops and desktops at apple.com/students

  • 24 Posted by sirbega on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:24PM EDT Report Abuse

    I agree with germanjulian2002, I had a laptop 2 years ago and I never brought it with me to my campus, I sold it and bought a desktop PC, alot faster and much cheaper

  • 25 Posted by ectiodad on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    Great call on considering buying from the campus bookstore. If they sell computers then they will likely have an onsite repair facility. Saves the trouble of packing it up and sending it away and waiting ages for it to come back. I also agree with getting a laptop instead of a desktop. The desktop may have more juice and easier to repair, but the portability of a laptop can't be beat. While a student may not be using it in the classroom, there are so many hotspots at today's universities you can do your work where ever you happen to be. No need to only be stuck in your residence room to do your work. BUT DON'T FORGET TO BUY A LOCK. Stay away from the ones that plug into the video-out port as they are quite easy to break...and if they don't break off the thief will do A LOT of damage to the inner bits of your computer.

Post a Comment


My Tech

Please enable your browser's cookies to activate the My Tech column.

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.