Getting a Computer for Editing

Thu May 25, 2006 11:03AM EDT

See Comments (5)

Seun, our New York Film student has just received an HD camcorder from Hook Me Up's tech expert, Jon. Now Jon has to make a decision about a computer and all the accessories Seun will need to shoot and edit video for school.

The Editing Machine (aka a computer)
Seun has an old computer, but the hard drive is sketchy, it doesn't have a lot of memory, and the processor is slow. A key component to editing video on a computer is having a fast processor and lots of memory.

To get video from a camera to the computer, Seun should have a FireWire port on her computer. Her current computer doesn't have FireWire in. Finally, her present computer is running Windows. If she wants to get serious about editing, she should probably be working on a Mac.

Many independent filmmakers prefer the suite of editing products available on the Mac. There are a bunch of Windows-based programs, but for the college film-school scene, Seun should have a Mac, as much for function as for credibility in the community.

MacBook Pro
This is Apple's brand new Intel-based laptop. The new processor allows this system to run much faster than previous Macs. It has a 15.4-inch display and includes all the video inputs a budding filmmaker could ever want. It is portable: at 5.5 pounds Seun can throw this in her backpack and use it anywhere. The Macbook Pro comes with Apple's iLife suite of software: image, music and video editing programs. Seun will start out using  iMovie to edit her videos. It's a very good program and a great way to learn the basics of video editing: cuts, transitions, and audio layering.

If Seun wants to upgrade her video editing software, she will have to step up to a program like Final-Cut Express ($200) or she could get the full version of Final Cut Studio. This professional grade editing software retails for $1,299, but if Seun buys the software using Apple's student discount program, she would only pay $699. Most School bookstores have educational prices for students who can prove they are enrolled (student ID card), or you can buy online from Apple's education store if you have a valid student ID number from a recognized educational institution.

The Accessories
Jon got Seun a tripod for the camera. He chose a low-cost model with a liquid head for smooth pans and steady tight shots. Any video editor can tell you the downfall of rookie videographers is unintentional 'shaky cam.' After a few minutes of watching the images rock back and forth, the viewer has motion sickness and can't watch anymore.

Headphones
When Seun listens to the audio on her camera, she will need to isolate and assess quality issues: can dialog be clearly heard over ambient noise?  Headphones are key for this task. One problem Jon discovered on the shoot is that the Sony Camera he got for Seun didn’t have a headphone jack, so she couldn’t check audio in the field. This is one of the downsides of buying a product online, you don’t get to look at a floor model to see if it has all the things you thought it would. I’m still glad Jon got Seun headphones: they are also crucial in the editing process. In a shared environment like a classroom, the library or a dorm room, headphones are far superior to external speakers.

External Drive
Video takes up a ton of space on the hard drive, so Jon got Seun a 250GB Western Digital external combo drive. Seun can store and back up her video projects on an external drive as she creates her video portfolio.

The Assessment
Seun wants to use her work as a portfolio, creating a body of work she can use for school. This portfolio will someday be used to get Seun a job where she has access to professional grade video equipment. I'm not sure Jon needed to get her a High Definition camera—she won't be watching it in High Def or sending it to a TV network that will be broadcasting in High Def, so I think we could have gotten a 2-3 CCD camera and saved a couple hundred bucks.

With that extra money, I would have bought Seun a wireless microphone or a better directional microphone. After 13 years in the television business, I know one thing for sure: viewers will tolerate a crappy image, but crappy audio is unbearable. Shooting in a city, Seun will have a ton of audio issues. A $300 wireless microphone could help her to add a more professional approach to the video she shoots, and that could make the difference on the final video reel she sends out when pursuing a job.

Jon's external hard drive, headphones, and a tripod are great choices to maximize the quality of Seun's video projects.

Overall, I think this set-up will be a great jump-start for Seun's video career. Look for her name on the big-screen sometime in 2012.

Top 5 Posts

Comments on Getting a Computer for Editing

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by eddien120 on Wed Jun 7, 2006 5:42AM EDT Report Abuse

    Jon did a good thing in getting Seun a hi-def camera: he's trying to future-proof her technology. I do agree with your assessment of the audio features that she will need. She should cut back on the food and get herself a nice wireless microphone. Other than that (and the fact that the Sony cam didn't have some of the input port that she might have needed) Seun is practically set for (student) life. Let's hope she is able to use her powers for good rather than evil :) I look forward to seeing "A Seun Babalola Joint" with the "Made in NYC" logo proudly on the credits one day soon.

  • 2 Posted by abionaalli on Fri Oct 20, 2006 9:13AM EDT Report Abuse

    i can see that seun is Nigerian. not only is she Nigerian, she's also yoruba and i am proud of her. i look forward to seeing her name on the big screen in the not too distant future. go girl!

  • 3 Posted by tonyquille on Sun Oct 22, 2006 1:13PM EDT Report Abuse

    So glad to see Seun's dream come true. I've also cherish to be a movie producer/music director. I believe my dream will one day come true. Could anyone get me Seun contact please? She can can reach me via email tonyquille@yahoo.com. I need to ask her about Making Movies and other thing. I want her to be my online classmate.

  • 5 Posted by jtellis23 on Mon Dec 4, 2006 2:27PM EST Report Abuse

    I'm sorry to add a comment now as the article was written months ago, but it just really upsets me when people pretend to know more than they know. First off, why would you, as the host of a technology show, act to encourage the misconception that any serious video editing has to be done of a Mac? I have been editing video since I first got my hands on an Avid machine back in 1996. I have had the opportunity to use and master editing programs ranging from iMovie and Windows Moviemaker, to Adobe Premiere, Final Cut Pro, and Avid DV Xpress, to name a few. I am just as comfortable on a PC as a Mac, and EACH program has pros and cons. Yes, Final Cut Studio is a very nice editing suite of programs, but one must not assume that they must first spend thousands for a computer then an extra $700 (as a student) when there are simpler solutions for the PC that can work for the editor on a budget. Secondly, please know what you are talking about when referring to CCD. A single CCD is cheaper because is relies on one device to process red, green, and blue, while a 3CCD has a separate sensor for each color. I do not think I have ever heard of a 2CCD camera (maybe you are confusing CCD with MegaPixel)? Anyway, I am not trying to be rude as I have enjoyed reading about her experience and I would love to be in her shoes, but I just get a little irked by the whole Mac/PC war.

More Posts: First Prev 1 Next Last

Post a Comment

 

Sign In to see your profile information, saved products and more...

Register Sign In

My Favorite Gadgets

 

Recent Activity

 

Recently Viewed

on | off on | off
 

Recent Searches

on | off on | off
 
 
 

Also on Yahoo! Tech

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio
 

Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.