Dummies.com

<< See all Home Video Articles

Buying the Right TiVo Box

Many different manufacturers sell TiVo, and each model features its own bells and whistles. You see older, first-generation TiVos known as Series 1, the newer Series 2 TiVos, TiVos designed specifically for satellite reception through DirecTV, and a new mix of consumer gadgets that incorporate TiVo.

Here's a rundown on what you'll find when shopping for TiVo.

Standalone TiVo

A standalone TiVo refers to any TiVo that isn't designed specifically for satellite reception with DirecTV. Instead, standalone TiVos work mostly with cable hookups and TV antennas. Actually, these versatile little beasts can still work with satellite systems; they just won't take advantage of satellite-specific features.

Series 1 TiVo

No longer sold new, Series 1 TiVos still pop up at garage sales, on eBay, and through other used-goods outlets. These older standalone TiVos are a little bulky and slower than the newer models. In addition, Series 1 TiVos lack some popular software enhancements found in Series 2 models. (You can't group shows into convenient onscreen folders, for example.)

Lastly, only Series 2 TiVos offer the Home Media Option (HMO), which allows TiVo to communicate with your home computer, displaying your digital photos and playing your MP3 files. Once connected, TiVo grabs show schedules through the Internet instead of by telephone.

Without a subscription, a Series 1 TiVo can still pause live TV, fast-forward, and rewind, but it won't record shows automatically. To record a show, you must manually enter the correct channel and recording time.

Some tech-savvy people actually prefer Series 1 TiVos because they're easier to take apart and fiddle with. These tinkerers write their own "add-on" software to make their TiVos do oddball things like display a stock ticker along the bottom of a televised football game.

Series 2 TiVo

All TiVos sold today are considered Series 2 models. Faster, more versatile, and with more features than their predecessors, Series 2 TiVos also contain two USB ports for hooking up to a computer. Only Series 2 TiVos work with TiVo's Home Media Option, which lets users schedule upcoming recordings over the Internet, among other perks.

Series 2 TiVos can't record HDTV broadcasts, and they water down Dolby Digital 5.1 sound to stereo, but they offer more features and recording capacity than their predecessors. You'll probably be much happier with a Series 2 TiVo than a Series 1 TiVo.

DirecTV TiVos

If you receive your TV programs from the DirecTV satellite service, you'll probably want a DirecTV TiVo, officially known as a DirecTV Receiver with TiVo Service. These models record shows in slightly different ways than other TiVos.

For example, a DirecTV TiVo contains two tuners. So? That means you can simultaneously record two live shows on different channels. Or, you can record one channel while watching a different live channel.

All DirecTV TiVos can also record shows broadcast with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound; some models record HDTV, as well.

On the down side, DirecTV TiVos work only with DirecTV's satellite source. Standalone TiVos, by contrast, work with any signal source. If you stop subscribing to DirecTV's satellite service and switch to cable, your DirecTV TiVo won't work.

Because of their different circuitry and distribution, DirecTV TiVos come with reduced subscription plans.

DVD Player/Recorder TiVos

As the TiVo corporation grows, it stuffs its TiVo Service into a range of gadgets. Toshiba, for example, wraps a DVD/CD player around a TiVo. The Toshiba's SDH400 plays DVDs, CDs, and MP3 files. Its "embedded TiVo" records up to 80 hours of television on a hard drive. The unit includes TiVo Basic service, upgradeable to standard "TiVo Plus" service. It can be upgraded with the Home Media Option, as well.

Pioneer went further and created a pair of dream TiVos that not only play DVDs, but record them as well. Owners can create DVD libraries of their favorite shows. The Pioneer Elite DVR-57H stores 120 hours of shows; another Pioneer model stores 80 hours. Both models record shows that will play back on any DVD player.

In addition to burning your favorite shows to DVD, both units can schedule and record programs in the background while you watch a DVD. You can even hook up a camcorder, and copy your vacation videos to DVD. They both come with TiVo Basic service; you need a subscription for the "Plus" TiVo Service that includes the Season Pass, WishList, Suggestions, and other really fun stuff. (Of course, with technology advancing at the pace it does today, both these innovations will probably be outdated in no time!)

Several other companies offer similar TiVo/DVD recorder hybrids, with more models to come.

Choosing the right TiVo for you

Because TiVo now comes in many different installations, it's may seem more difficult than ever to choose the right one. But actually, it's easier - TiVo fulfills a wider variety of specific needs than ever before.

If you simply want the TiVo Service, just buy a standalone model of TiVo. It hooks up to any TV signal, be it cable, satellite, or an antenna, and lets you automatically record your favorite shows.

If you're using DirecTV satellite service, you'll want a DirecTV TiVo. It's designed specifically for DirecTV's satellite service and preserves your Dolby Digital 5.1 sound.

If you watch HDTV channels with your DirecTV, pick up the DirecTV TiVo with HDTV support. (These TiVos don't support Home Media Option for connecting to a computer, however. If that's a must, stick with the standalone TiVos.)

If you don't yet own a DVD player, pick up one of the DVD players with TiVo built-in. Combining the two items means one less box to wedge into your entertainment center.

Finally, if you're the type who enjoys saving TV shows and movies on videotape, pick up a DVD recorder with a built-in TiVo. Storing your shows on DVD is much less awkward than storing them on videotape.

1 of 1 Yahoo! users found this helpful

Was this helpful to you? Yes | No

Product Categories

Computers Home Office Wi-Fi & Networking Phones & PDAs Cameras & Camcorders TV & Home Theater Portable Audio

Today On...

Consumer Reports thumbnail
Consumer Reports

Don't buy without them

For unbiased ratings and reviews on thousands of products, get expert advice from Consumer Reports. Read More

Yahoo! Health thumbnail
Yahoo! Health

Mind and mood

A Resource for depression, anxiety, and mental health Read More


Question and Answer content at Yahoo! Tech is written by Yahoo! users at Yahoo! Answers. Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. For more information, read the Full Disclaimer.

Opinions expressed by the Advisors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Yahoo! Inc. Yahoo! receives no compensation from any manufacturer or distributor nor does it compensate any Advisor for the coverage of any product or service in any Advisor's content.