Mon Aug 6, 2007 10:59AM EDT
See Comments (26)
Where a teen goes, often goes a phone and a digital camera. Even to the movies, it seems. But teens who are at ease recording the many moments of their lives need to be well versed in copyright law.
A 19-year-old Virginia teen on a movie date to celebrate her birthday was arrested after unthinkingly recording about 20 seconds of the movie "Transformers" to show her 13-year-old brother, according to the Washington Post. She was charged with illegally recording a motion picture, and the Regal Cinemas is pressing ahead with the suit. She faces up to a year in jail and a $2,500 fine for recording the 20-second segment.
It was wrong, clearly, to record any of the movie, and it was not a smart move. But for the theater company to move ahead with this particular lawsuit to prove the industry's zero-tolerance policy is equally ridiculous. As Cindy Cohn, general counsel of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, tells the Post, the motion picture industry needs to stop treating fans like criminals. Sejas, a Marymount University student, was actually promoting the movie, not stealing it.
The Post reports that pirating movies costs the motion picture industry $18.2 billion a year, and 90 percent of illegally distributed films are recorded by camcorders, according to the Motion Picture Industry of America. But Sejas recorded seconds of the movie with a Canon PowerShot, her boyfriend's sister's digital camera. Even if that short clip made it onto the Internet, it is difficult to see how it could enrich Sejas.
Either way, warn your teens to keep the cameras off and away when at the movies. Or they may find a police officer beckoning them from their seats and into a legal mess.
LINK: Out of the Theater, Into the Courtroom [Washington Post]
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Netflix has a preview of the movie that lasts about a minute. 20 seconds appears to be much ado about nothing.
Let's hope the loss in ticket sales in protest to Regal Cinema let's them understand the difference between Spirit and Intent. One less reason to go to a movie in a theater....
I agree with all of the above, especially the comment that this girl is actually PROMOTING the movie - not selling it! Also, if you've ever seen video taken by a digital camera - even a good one like a PowerShot, you know a 20-second clip is no danger to the studio. Regal Cinemas, you need to apologize - right after you get a clue.
I am all for the motion picture industry going after the criminals who capitalize from their theft of movies. I also feel that Americans should be as aggressive as possible when our young people are abused in this manner. This young lady had nothing but kind thoughts when she captured a mere 20 seconds of video for her 13 year old brother. In a country where every day from one coast to another there is story after story of young people taking lives, selling drugs and destroying their lives, for a young person to be punished with such vigilance for showing a little love turns my stomach! We better find a way to stand up, protect and do all we can for our young people or this country is in for far worse problems. My prayers go out for this young lady and as for Regal Cinemas I pray that all Americans would not attend their cinemas for one week to allow Regal Cinemas to contemplate their actions. I stopped taking my four grandson to the movies more than 6 years ago because what they charge should be a crime!
Actually, the "fair use" component of copyright law says that excerpts (usually limited to 10% of the total) can be used for critical reviews. She should post a review online and use the clip to illustrate; voila! no violation, no foul.
Would Regal Theaters punish someone for keeping a copy of a movie trailer that's commonly available on the internet? I think not. They should apologize and creep back under their rock. Until this issue is settled I will NOT attend another film at ANY Regal Theater.
Go to Regal Entertainment Group and file a complaint with them. Even if it doesn't work they will find out how we feel about it and how I plan to not use their facilities as long as they act this stupid. The girl was helping them sell this movie to her brother and probably his friends. They should get 'flippin' real..
I live far away from America butI would want Regal Cinema to realise that the teen was just showing love to her brother and also enticing him to go and watch for himself. If this is not promoting their cinenma what is it? Do not always think about money. For once see the love and caring side of this issue and allow the girl to go free. There are very few young people who think aout their siblings when they are enjoying themselves.
I ARGEE WITH YOU I WANT BE GOING AND I GO EVERY WEEK WITH MY FRIENDS AND FAMILY I WILL NOT ATTENED THIS WEEK AT ALL AND NITHER WILL MY FAMILY AND FRIENDS OR MY CHURCH MEMBERS / YOU KNOW WHAT SOME COURT DONT HAVE ANY THING TO DO ,,,,,GET THE BAD OK
1 Posted by y3nn0b on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:54PM EDT Report Abuse
A long time ago people used to talk about the spirit and the intent of the law. I agree, it was wrong to record any of the movie. But it sure seems like Regal Cinemas is going way overboard on the zero-tolerance policy. This is where management should have used another long ago concept of logic and common sense. The theater could have explained the problem, asked her to delete the clip, and then hold on to the PowerShot until the end of the movie to prevent any other recordings. No harm, no foul, message delivered.