Tue Aug 5, 2008 12:09PM EDT
See Comments (13)
Europeans have been rumbling rapidly toward legalizing cell phone conversations in flight, but in the U.S., the sentiment is exactly the opposite. Not only are consumers down on the idea, the U.S. Congress is getting in on the game, with a key House of Representatives committee voting to approve the so-called, horribly-named Halting Airplane Noise to Give Us Peace (HANG UP) Act and send it to the full House of Representatives for a full vote. The Act would make banning in-flight cellular calls a matter of federal law; right now they are banned only because of guidelines from the FCC and the FAA.
HANG UP has a long way to go before becoming a law, but I can't imagine it will encounter any serious resistance along the way. U.S. consumers have overwhelmingly stated they do not want people to be able to use cell phones while flying (in a typical poll, 3 out of 4 consumers support such a ban), and U.S. Congresspeople likely see passing the law as a simple (and free) way to prove they're "listening to their constituents."
If you're a communications junkie, the good news is that HANG UP still allows for the use of data services like web browsing and email, so even if/when it passes it won't impact systems like those from American and Virgin America which let you use your laptop to access the Internet while you're flying. And lest you're thinking of skirting the imminent ban through some high-tech sleight of hand, most of these types of services already have filters in place that prevent the use of VOIP services like Skype.
But really, I wonder if HANG UP is really going to, as the name implies, "halt airplane noise" for real. Last time I checked jet engines clock in at about 140 decibels, which, when I'm flying, is all I can ever hear. Maybe Congress can put an end to this loud menace through some well-written legislation. (Kidding, folks.)
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Especially on long hauls, the last thing you need is some puffed up self important wannabe mouthing off on his cellphone. From micro-management to social networking, it can all wait until the plane lands - or you shouldn't be on a plane to start with.
Maybe then we can ban loud talkers and crying babies. THEN we'd finally have some peace and quiet when flying. Seriously, why is all airplane noise blamed on cell phone users? Because people need a scapegoat and then they don't have to review their OWN behavior. And, no, I don't work for a cell phone company.
p.s. Don't forget that your local Public Servants (Congresspeople/Senators) mostly/only fly private jets, so they have absolutely NO knowledge about volume levels on commercial aircraft.
As annoying as cell phone talkers are on airplanes, do we really need the power of the State to come in an legislate common courtesy? I don't own a cell phone and am driven nuts by people who insist on talking loudly about the banalities of life to their friend and everyone in a 10 mile radius, but I am also driven nuts by the nanny state coming in and telling people when they can and cannot use their phones. The state does not have a legitimate interest here. It's just headline grabbing by passing laws that they don't have a right to pass. Is it annoying? Absolutely! No questions from me (and I would even enjoy the benefits of the ban!) Is it the right of the State to control? Definitely not.
To be perfectly honest, I don't really think of HANG UP is very useful. What penalties would be incurred if someone broke this federal law? I hope it's only just a series of fines as anything worse would be a bit much, considering this is a law for conveniences.
I agree with paul_e_t 100%. I also agree with crapdirector 100% as well. Thank you for the article, Mr. Null.
What ever happend to freedom of speech? Out the window with the right to bear arms? Huh? Democracy or communist state?
I agree with 'crapdirector': it is the state trying to exercise control over our lives again and playing on peoples frustration, and ignorrance of the fact that you can actually talk quietly on modern 3G phones while the person on the other end can still hear you. We are not in the 1G and the dying 2G era now.
I am very much in favor of banning cell phone use on all public transportation. I do not want to hear other people's conversations. Usually they are loud and annoying. I see people use phones in check out lines,coffee shop lines,etc. It is annoying and does contribute to noise pollution and irritation for others. I am especially annoyed at my health club where people talk loudly while exercising and others,like me,go to health club for relaxation and stress relief,not more noise.
1 Posted by reggie_six on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:35PM EDT Report Abuse
I fully support this ban. In fact I would like to see it extended so that people cannot use their cell phones until they are inside the terminal. There is no reason that someone should impose their conversation on the rest of the folks waiting patiently to exit a plane. If cell phone conversations were permitted on board in flight, the users would simply shout their words to be heard over the engine noise, and to heck with anyone else on the plane (like their seatmates). Even people who are normally polite seem to become rude and inconsiderate of others when their cell phone is on - I don't know why - but we shouldn't encourage that sort of behavior. This is one bill that I hope passes ASAP