Thu Aug 21, 2008 11:47AM EDT
See Comments (9)
When you bought that nice, new flat panel TV, you dutifully recycled your old, giant CRT to keep all that lead out of the landfill. But what happened to it? Buried in the eighth paragraph of this Popular Mechanics story, you'll find out. Most CRTs aren't disassembled and carefully broken down into parts for reuse, they meet another fate: A cargo container for shipping overseas.
Old CRTs get shipped to (primarily) Malaysia, where the tubes are stripped out and put into new chassis, then sold as new TVs in developing countries. Tubes that don't work are melted down and rebuilt into new CRTs or shipped off to lead smelters, where it is conceivably reused in industrial applications like making car batteries. (The story goes on to note that even though there is some re-use at work, the people that work in these smelting factories deal with a crushing amount of exposure to lead.)
It's probably all told a better end result than the alternative: Over half a million tons of CRTs will make their way into landfills this year, with an estimated 46,643 tons of that representing lead. The lead isn't hazardous as long as it remains locked up in the glass, but how likely is that in the long run? One study performed almost 10 years ago found that enough lead leached out of landfills "to qualify as toxic waste."
If there's a glimmer of a bright spot here it's that CRTs are rapidly on the decline here, so there are fewer around to have to deal with. But that also puts you in a strange position should you be hanging on to one. The problem is this: Eventually we'll reach a point where even overseas markets no longer want CRT televisions, and they'll stop accepting the old sets for rebuilding into new ones. When this happens, any sense of "recycling" them will probably vanish altogether, and it'll be landfill all the way.
Of course, even recycling a CRT is only prolonging the inevitable. That lead is going to wind up somewhere in the end, right? Exactly where it ends up is likely to become a sticking point in the next few years.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
We spent several years in the S, Pacific and can definitely assure the skeptics thta old TV's, CRT monitors and just about anything else that is salvageable does indeed get re-used. In Vanuatu (1000 NMi NE of Australia) we befriended the owner of a 'TV refurbishing" shop - they would buy old TVs from t e US, Australia etc. and rework them for local use. We introduced them to the Internet and Google - with great results from what I have heard. They now buy old computers and resell them locally. Many of our old/junked cars end up in Central America and almost all of their buses has XXX School District on the side! If labor is cheap enough you can fix almost anything. Sadly when THEY wear out the stuff it usually ends up in the sea ...
geez, post number 3 is so completely disturbing. Didn't know in 2008 people could exist and get thru a day while still being so ignorant and close-minded about this big wide world. This article is about doing something intelligent and trying to prevent all of us from being exposed to lead toxins. Save your hatin' for some other part of the web (where we all don't have to be poisoned by IT.)
uh_stdnt, people like you really need to stay in school longer and keep an open mind. What a utterly stupid and shallow statement.
We all need to do our part to make this planet more healthy. The world is going in the right direction dispite people like uh_stdnt. He/she made a dumb statement and should recant asap just to save face. It's ok to make misstakes as long as you learn by them. There is far more good than bad and good always wins. Live and let live! Peace baby!
darn straight, I made a very ignorant comment, but a very common one. I just wanted to see the outrage. Its not just CRT TVs that die overseas, alot of our electronics do. Traveling in India and Pakistan, especially in the port city of Karachi, you can see freighters just dropping huge boxes of computer screens and sending it off to tribal areas where people live. And the kids, obviously with little education considering the political and economic climate of the frontier areas, forge through the metal and silicon. Basically a toxic dump. Thats not an image we want for ourselves. Again, I made an ignorant comment, I'm glad people called me out for it. But you won't believe how common such opinions are.
geez post number is unfortunately a statement heard made many americans. there are so many ignorant people out there, who know nothing, haven't been anywhere, don't speak any foreign language, but still think they should display there pathetic little opinions. All of them contribute to our bad reputation abroad.
WHO CARES!
post number 3 is totally unacceptable!
1 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse
Heh, my tube TVs just ended up in the trash pile with smashed tubes. Didnt take long for that to happen. Some kids came by at some point and broke them while they were sitting out there. I doubt too many thrown out sets actually make it overseas. I am sure it is more factory rejects and returns that go overseas.