Sat Oct 4, 2008 4:29PM EDT
See Comments (18)
"Get Linux" is almost as common a refrain in the comment threads on this blog as "get a Mac." But although various Linux OSes have made enormous strides in recent years, they may still be far from ready for prime time: In an interview with Laptop magazine, an executive with MSI, which makes perhaps the best low-priced netbook on the market, says that the Linux version of its popular Wind laptop is being returned (at least) four times as often as the Windows version.
According to MSI's U.S. sales director Andy Tung, "We have done a lot of studies on the return rates and haven't really talked about it much until now. Our internal research has shown that the return of netbooks is higher than regular notebooks, but the main cause of that is Linux. People would love to pay $299 or $399 but they don't know what they get until they open the box. They start playing around with Linux and start realizing that it's not what they are used to. They don't want to spend time to learn it so they bring it back to the store. The return rate is at least four times higher for Linux netbooks than Windows XP netbooks."
That's significant, and a little scary: A pocket of Mac enthusiasm notwithstanding, Windows now dominates the market so heavily that many people are afraid of change. It's hard to fault them. Though OpenOffice and Microsoft Office share 90 percent of their DNA, it can be a little daunting when commands aren't exactly where you expect them to be. And the various Linux OS flavors themselves can take considerable getting used to. Even locating files and figuring out where the programs you need are can take a lot of work.
Of course, the thought with the original Asus Eee PC, the first low-cost machine like this on the market, was that people wouldn't mind the differences of Linux since they were only paying $300 or so for the machine. But now that Windows versions are available, usually for just a $50 to $100 premium, consumers seem to saying that familiarity is more important than rock-bottom pricing.
Meanwhile, MSI says it's working to refine and update its Linux-based laptops (which are not available in the U.S. currently)... but that's going to take some time before a solution that's really palatable to consumers is reached.
(via Gizmodo)
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Maybe this will stop the Linux users greater than thou holier art attitude. But then again, they will just cry that the people didn't mess around long enough to even give it a chance.
I can see it now mac and linux user crying foul, but there nothing to cry about window is just better period.
Change is good but people should be willing to change also. It's the only surefire way to adapt. Cryptic, yes but it also applies to operating systems.
I have to wonder how that comparisom would fare if it was Vista vs Linux? We bought a new HP Vista machine and converted an old WIn 2K based desktop to SUSE Linux. After 2 months the hassles with Linux are far fewer! There are hassles wiht both, but the Linjux hasslesw are well documented and Novell ($60 SUSE Linux support) actually DOES provide solutions in real English! We are preparing to convert the new machine to Linux as well.
Well folks, there is a learning curve with Linux as there is in every thing. The problem here is with the sellers of Linux laptops, they do not illuminate anything in the way of support. Perhaps its because those that are selling them do not know them. Those of us in the Linux world recognize the bountiful availability of support in the oodles of Linux forums. This should be made clear and be pointed out to those who delve in to the Linux waters for the first time. This is not a problem with the technology, its a problem with marketing and business sense. To the sellers of these laptops please ask for our help, we will be glad to help you help you customers.
Nice link bait, Chris. Let's correct that headline to "MSI sales in foreign countries reveal Linux laptops returned 4x as often as Windows." Gee, not so ominous; definitely not "significant." This cannot even really be applied or paralelled to the US market at all. Bring us some numbers from HP (Suse) and Dell (Ubuntu) on US sales and returns, then maybe you have a news story, otherwise you are as irrelevant as Rob Enderle.
I have to agree. The title is just a tad too general. If you check other independent online reviews of the MSI with Linux you'll see that it's by far one of the lowest rated netbooks to date, precisely because MSI have done a really poor job with the out-of-the-box experience. Apparently, even getting wireless to work is a hassle. Funny how all of the other netbook providers got this right, Linux or otherwise. As it stands, this story and MSI coming out so openly about smells of M$.
Does Pricing deceive a customer? hard to digest...Well it is hard to believe that customers realize Linux is hard to operate when they get the comp... What did they think of lniux b4 buying the machine
I don't agree that my Linux netbook is difficult to understand for a newbie. I bought a ASUS 900 a month ago and had it up and running in less than 10 minutes, had the wireless figured out in about 15 minutes, and have used open office with little trouble ever since. I bought it because my HP Vista laptop was a total waste of money - too slow to open, too agrivating to operate, and too heavy to consider portable. For $400 dollars I have a fast, convenient and tiny netbook that I am learning to appreciate more all the time.
1 Posted by shadowman_26 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:15PM EDT Report Abuse
maybe this will stop the Linux is greater than thou holier art attitude these users have. But then again, they will cry and say that they didn't play around with it. Go figure.