Europe plan will require removable batteries in gadgets

Wed Oct 8, 2008 12:12PM EDT

See Comments (8)

The European Union is preparing to clamp down once again on gadget technology, this time with a rule that will require all electronic devices to have "readily removable" batteries in order to aid with the region's aggressive recycling goals and keep gadgets from being tossed in the garbage wholesale for want of a charge. By 2012 the EU wants 25 percent of all portable batteries recycled and 45 percent by 2016.

Square in the crosshairs of the rule is the bulk of Apple's mobile product line: The MacBook Air, iPhone, and every iPod ever made has a sealed case containing the battery which the customer can't access. Many other very small MP3 players (on par with the Shuffle) are similarly encumbered and will take significant re-engineering in order to design for battery removability.

But this has to be the biggest affront to Apple, which has endured years of complaints and even class action lawsuits over its steadfast determination not to let you replace the battery in your iPod. Will a major world power finally force Apple's hand where millions of consumers have failed?

The rule isn't finalized, but there don't appear to be any real obstacles in the way of its adoption in environmentally-obsessed Europe. But even the threat of this legislation should be enough to put any sensible company (ahem) on notice that it's time to get with the times: Users want replaceable batteries. Activists want replaceable batteries. Resellers want replaceable batteries. What's the hold-up?

Photo (of an unsanctioned third-party iPhone battery kit) courtesy Gizmodo

Comments on Europe plan will require removable batteries in gadgets

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by muscogeekid on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    This is a good question. Why doesn't Apple build their devices so that the batter can be removed?

  • 2 Posted by hailofaguy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:15PM EDT Report Abuse

    It has to be a cost thing with apple to not make some batteries replaceable. Probably a 10 cent design change but that would cut into profits. I wont buy a product if I cannot service items like the battery myself.

  • 3 Posted by penguin_152 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:06PM EDT Report Abuse

    The funny thing is that by apple requiring you to bring the phone to them probably insures that 100% of all iphone/ipod batteries are recycled since the company controls what happens to them. Most people (myself included) wouldn't think twice about throwing a battery in the trash if given the option. Unless they force dealers to take the old battery or charge a fee if you don't give it to them (similar to car batteries here in the US), this isn't going to improve recycling of anything.

  • 4 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    GOOD! It is about time something forced Apple's hands on this!

  • 5 Posted by uffpet on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Every IKEA store in the U.S. has battery collection stations, for example. It's just a question of being willing to change and make the effort (grocery stores should follow suit). BTW, off topic: In Germany one can even take old expired medications back to any pharmacy. In light of the recent reports on what substances can be found in U.S. drinking water, this might be a good idea, too...

  • 6 Posted by macearlybird on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    Apple wants you to throw away the device and buy a new one. It's just more of Apple greed. And it is not just Apple, but also Black and Decker with battery screwdriver and Oral with electric toothbrushes. It is time to change the concept of throw away to make more money. But Apple is one of the worst of the lot.

  • 7 Posted by klacour on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:52PM EDT Report Abuse

    Pffft ... big deal. I've been replacing batteries in my iPods for years. 1G anf 2G Minis, nanos, Photo. Now, don't get me wrong, I would like it to be an easier process. As for Apple in general, I've probably purchased my last Apple product. I need to replace my 80GB iPod, and went with the underwhelming 120GB Classic. I'm done digitizing my old vinyl LPs, and have over 1,000 albums and 10,000 songs stored on less than 1/2 my iPod. And now Apple has announced another Apple "event." October 14th. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz ...

  • 8 Posted by sabre61 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:59PM EDT Report Abuse

    Actually, having a replaceable battery pack makes the overall product thicker, since you now have the extra thickness of the enclosure of the battery pack added. Apple aims for thinness, because customers really like it. It's not some nefarious plot, just a simple engineering decision.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment