Wed Oct 8, 2008 1:32PM EDT
See Comments (8)
Bowing to pressure from flight attendants and, reportedly, customers, American Airlines has said it will soon be blocking access to pornographic websites on its new Aircell in-flight Internet access service. Delta announced a similar plan earlier this month.
American says it will work with the provider to set up the filter. No timeline for implimenting the filtering technology has been announced. One has to imagine it won't take long.
Naturally, privacy and civil rights advocates are already criticizing the move. Filters always tend to cast a very wide net, taking with them plenty of non-pornographic content while missing sites that many will find offensive. It's the gray areas -- YouTube, personal blogs, medical information sites -- where things get really tricky. And of course, there's invariably the question of whether filtering will extend to violence, "hate speech," and other frequently-censored content.
Well, if nothing else, American has probably inadvertantly launched a new diversion for bored fliers traveling across the country: "Beat the Filter," where buddies try to see who can slip some adult content past the censor first. Loser buys the next round of drinks!
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
If the airlines aren't making you pay for the internet service they should be able to filter it however they please. But if I am paying for it then I should be able to view, surf whatever websites I please. Now if I have some young kids sitting around me that shouldn't be viewing this kind of stuff then its should fall back on whats right and whats wrong to do. In this day and age accountability for your actions is pretty high and I would not like to be on the receiving end of the consequences if I was to get arrested for someones kid seeing porn on my computer while in flight. Pervs in jail aren't treated very nice so I think these kind of filters might be the best thing out there if you just can't seem to keep from looking at this kind of thing for a few hours.
1. There is not right of privacy in a public place 2. You don't have many rights in someones place of business. They can set rules for your behavior. I don't understand why people have such a problem with this. I bet these privacy nuts would be fired for looking at porn in their own offices (unless they personally own the business and then its their choice).
who would dare do such a thing on a plane anyways? God, I can actually imagine some...
It's kind of interesting that this only comes up when they begin offering browsing service in the air. You never (or at least I never have) heard a similar controversy that people were watching porn DVDs on their portable DVD players on flights, or watching saved movies on their laptops, etc.
Too bad they can't enforce this on cars with DVD screens on the highway. Funny story, I was caught in a traffic jam at night, when someone's very brightly-lit LCD screen caught my attention. Being stuck on a bridge with nothing but red lights to look at meant that the most interesting thing was this screen. I couldn't make out what it was at first, but (predictably for this story) it was some good old-fashioned fellatio. I wasn't offended. Flabbergasted, maybe, amused after the initial shock.. But really, what are these people thinking?
Well, at least I can still play WoW while on a long flight...
Lets not forget that as soon as you start to regulate content you take responsibility for that content! Lets wait and see the first mega-lawsuit because someone was downloading pirated software on a flight - only the most obvious of a whole bunch of possibilities I am sure. They can't catch the user, but they sure can catch the airline!
1 Posted by david_lmt on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:38PM EDT Report Abuse
First, I wouldn't even dare to look at porn in public in the first place. Second, are there that many people out there watching porn on flights that they have to enforce this? Why don't they just give people watching it in the first place warnings instead of blocking websites?