Tue Oct 28, 2008 12:57PM EDT
See Comments (193)
Yeah, what's the deal with all the netbooks?
If you're unfamiliar with the devices, here's the pitch: You get a small, cheap laptop with a basic set of features, limited performance, and often a small hard drive (or an even smaller amount of flash storage). Some netbooks run Windows (usually XP), some don't. And that's the sell. The emphasis: cheap.
Prices typically range from about $300 to $500, but there are exceptions on either side. As with standard laptops, the more you pay, the more you get... but at some point you get into the realm of those regular laptops, and the appeal of the netbook fades considerably.
There are numerous pros and cons to the netbook phenomenon that should impact your decision whether to buy one. First, some pros: They're cheap. Oh, I mentioned that. But they're also very portable and generally more rugged than you'd expect, which makes them great for people looking for a second laptop to use as a "getaway" computer. Just toss it in your bag and head out for that adventure weekend. If it gets lost, stolen, or broken, you're out a much smaller investment than if it had been your $2,000 Mac that you dropped into a ravine.
Now for the flipside. Netbooks are, again, cheap. To get prices down, sacrifices must be made. That means dog-slow processors, no graphics ability, (usually) no optical drive, and minimal RAM. Netbooks won't work as an emergency DVD player for the kids. Battery life is often poor (with a few exceptions). Many netbooks look more like toys than real laptops, so they aren't appropriate for business users. And the smaller the keyboard gets, the harder it is to type. On machines with an 8.9-inch screen (the smallest and typical standard among netbooks), touch-typing is pretty much impossible. Then there's the OS issue. While some netbooks run Windows, many run Linux. Whether that's a pro or con depends on your opinion of Microsoft, but many users dislike having to learn a new operating system and instead prefer the familiarity of Windows.
Should you buy one? Tough question, but I highly recommend that if you do, you consider a model with a 10-inch screen, which will give you a less cramped experience on both the eyes and the fingers (thanks to the bigger keyboard). My two favorite models: The Asus Eee PC 1000H and the new Lenovo IdeaPad S10, both with 10.2-inch screens and Windows XP. Both are available for under $500. The Eee has much longer battery life (but weighs half a pound more), while the IdeaPad has better performance and a larger hard drive. Take your pick.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Personally I prefer the teeny tiny handheld computers, like the new Imovio iKit
These shine in the field with support techs.
I agree that Netbooks have some value- its in the portability. However, the major drawback of these devices is that they are still not easy to use when you walk around or stand. Its hard to walk and type and its hard to use the touchpad. Thats why Slate Tablet PCs are a much better choice. I have a motion computing LE1700 for some of the same reasons you suggest Chris. However, I can manipulate the device standing up or sitting down. Battery life is 8 hours and the devices weighs 3 LBs. Without the extended battery- 2LBs 4hrs battery life.
Tiger Direct is having a big sale on netbooks - just got the email - check it out.
I see dual core laptops for sale for around $500-$600 in the Sunday Newspapers Sales Flyers at Best Buy, Circuit City, Office Max, Stapels Etc.... every week. Why pay $500 for a glorified netbook when for $100 more you can buy a real laptop. Other then the size/portability there is no real advantage unless you buy the low end netbook - then price becomes a factor. I guess the netbooks are worth it if you only want to use it as an internet device, hence the term Netbook.
I hav a Asus Eee PC 900 and its really great. I take it with me overseas being wireless fantastic. At home i rather than using desktop i use my Eee PC. Great for cheking emails. rreplying whilst listening to whatever on tv, I just love it. I hav wireless laptop, but I still prefer this little beast.
Netbooks will turn out to be a gadget that is used for a few months and then either collects dust or is resold. Complete and utter waste of money.
I bought the Acer Aspire ONE with Windows XP and was delighted to use the wi-fi to upload the Blackbery Deskto Manager so I could use my BB as a modem where I am most without wi-fi signal. I actually got it installed and was able to connect briefly but "Then it happened". The screen began to flicke off and on and eventually I got a message that said it was too large a file..strange huh? I tried to get it back to work but n luck. I needed this feature to work and it didt so I returned it. Other wise I was very hapPy and it was very cute in that Pearly Pink! Darn!
a gameboy does more and better things that these "computers". They are not worth it. You can't do nothing, open the browser and that is all.. Forget about writing a document on Word or even Notepad. Capacity? haha!! install one txt file and the free space is gone.
1 Posted by crapdirector on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:30PM EDT Report Abuse
I can't tell you how many Macs I've dropped into a ravine.