New tech scam extorts money, accuses users of stealing porn

Mon Dec 1, 2008 1:12AM EST

See Comments (9)

Those Nigerian princes have nothin' on the lawyers of Davenport Lyons, a British outfit which is threatening to sue UK residents by sending "pre-settlement letters," much like the RIAA uses to get accused music file sharers to pay up. The twist? Davenport Lyons says it represents the interests of a group of German pornographers, or at least a company (called DigiProtect) which owns the right to a grand total of two such films (plus assorted other digital content).

According to the Guardian, some 25,000 people have received letters from Davenport Lyons, demanding payments of roughly 500 pounds (about $770) each. Hundreds of people have claimed innocence in these cases, with numerous letter recipients complaining that they wouldn't even know how to download movies, and if they did it certainly wouldn't be gay German pornographic fillms.

Kudos to Michael Coyle, a solicitor helping letter recipients fight the claims of Davenport Lyons: For 50 pounds he helps consumers respond legally against these strongarm tactics. To date, Davenport's only real successes have come in cases where no one showed up in court to defend themselves.... but five-figure judgments certainly get people scared and interested in settling, which is precisely the point.

Done right, legal threats are huge business: The Guardian piece notes that, if all 25,000 letter recipients paid the requested fees, the law firm would net more than 12.5 million pounds for its trouble... a far more lucrative line of work than making those movies in the first place.

Comments on New tech scam extorts money, accuses users of stealing porn

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by pwdrskir on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:22PM EDT Report Abuse

    How can they get away with this type of extortion? No proof, just bullying.

  • 2 Posted by dubyac99 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    Hey, wait a tic! I do believe I have perused Gay German midget porn between consenting legal age ponies. Am I in trouble or something?

  • 3 Posted by clinton.langford on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Well done to Michael Coyle,who demonstrates that not all lawyers are the snakes we'd wish always to avoid! The whole thing is unbelievable and quite disgustingly frightening. Down with Davenport Lyons!

  • 4 Posted by jwalker216 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    OMG. Why is it that these freaks have the RIGHTS to extort somebody. Why is it any judge wouldn't throw this sort of thing out of court? Are all judges so immoral that they can no longer tell that these are nothing more than outrageous scams/extortion efforts? Nasty. It says a lot about lawyers AND judges. Evil. And they don't even care it's evil.

  • 5 Posted by savagekittenzofdoom on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:06PM EDT Report Abuse

    It just makes you want to go and slap whoever did that; or accuse them in-turn. but, jeez thats horrible.

  • 6 Posted by wilson.tony86 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:47PM EDT Report Abuse

    It seems to me that the world we live in instead of being fair and just... just gets a little more worse... however, I find it almost unbareable to hear of these injustices in the modern world we're living in with technologies so advanced to travel in space... you'd think things could be a bit simpler in stopping needless, unethical behaviors as id theft... scams of every sort... without the victim even having to go to a court.

  • 7 Posted by louisheli on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    Don't be naive!!!!! Of course the judges know better, but it is part of the system. didn't you know that!!!!!! The government has to make money somehow and how better to do it since no one likes to pay more taxes.

  • 8 Posted by nemo_shadows on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    I once heard that you can't sue organized crime because they have the best lawyers that money can buy and know where to hide the bodies if it looks like their going to loose so all you can do is kill it before it kills you .... and yes Virginia, you are in a war ...

  • 9 Posted by j_industry on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    Many innocent people will pay up especially those who don't fancy being in the paper being accused of downloading gay porn, those who pay up make this scam pay. It's far better than having to send a billion Nigerian Lottery emails out for just one reply. Apparently some of the big name firms have stopped using them to demand compensation for file sharing, this probably won't affect DigiProtect/Davenport Lyons as they are now onto something far more lucrative.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment