Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:19AM EST
See Comments (150)
Faced with crushing deficits, depressed tax revenues, and a grim outlook for 2009, states across the country are taking another hard look at taxing interstate sales completed on the web. Once a strict "no tax" zone, those walls are now on the verge of crumbling.
Following the lead of tax-hungry New York, 22 states and hundreds of retailers have joined a group called the Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board. The goal of the group is to simplify the methods by which sales taxes are calculated, collected, and transmitted online by creating a set of tax rules that rolls the thousands of state, county, and city tax codes into a single, simplified code. And the SSTGB also wants to make those rules apply to all online purchasers, even those across state lines, not just buyers in the same state as the seller's offices.
The SSTGB already has some of the biggest retailers around in its pocket, including Wal-Mart, Borders, and J.C. Penney.
Of course, not everyone is thrilled about the prospect of the e-taxman. Amazon is famously suing New York for its requirement that the company collect sales taxes for all sales to New York, despite the fact that Amazon doesn't have a physical presence there. It is collecting those taxes, though, in the meantime, as the case works its way to court.
Overstock, however, is not collecting those taxes, having fired 3,400 of its New York-based affiliates in order to skirt the NY legislation. (The recently-enacted law claims that locally-based "affiliates," which collect a commission on referrals for sales of products sent on to a third-party retailer, constitute a physical nexus in the state and thus make the retailer responsible for tax collection.) Overstock is also suing New York over the law.
What happens now? More waiting and negotiating for the forseeable future. As Forrester analyst Sucharita Mulpuru notes, "It's a legal morass. In a best-case scenario, it's going to take a while to sort everything out."
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
All praise the Democrat party as they seek yet another way to confiscate my hard earned money and throw it out the window.
Note to dubyac99, Your statement about "GW" is a undeniable proof for a)- liberalism being a mental disorder b) Democrats being the dumbest of the dumb. First of all, New York is a DEMOCRATIC bastion, if you don't know. Thanks to your "progressiveness", you ARE broke, so is California (another state where "progressives" rule). So, stop whining, band over, and take it like a lady (that you are ...) - the "changed", you wanted and voted in, is coming.
So let me get this straight, these states are paying people to sit on this SSTGB. Why not fire these people and use the money, that would be their salaries, to get the states out of the hole? Oh that's right, tax everybody else, don't let your friends lose millions of dollars. Ahh, the American way.
WOW... the internet being a (mostly) tax-free consumer zone was not my #1 reason for making the majority of my purchases online, but it was near the top of the list. Even with tax added, the price difference between online and retail stores is still great enough that it will continue to be cheaper to purchase online (for those sites that offer free shipping). Still, here's hoping the top dogs of online sales can fight this issue and keep online prices at WYSIWYG status.
Why does everyone feel the need to whine about internet sales tax? Most states have a use tax clause in their sales tax law which requires the purchaser to pay the sales tax if it is not collected by the retailer. The only thing a sales tax being collected on the sales would change is that the purchaser does not need to file. I know no-one files this form but that is why the states are changing the enforcement to the retail not the purchaser.
Our greedy, irresponsible government will never stop finding ways to take our money until they've managed to take it all; then they'll use their Nazi hit squad (the IRS) to collect it all for them.
Welp, time to buy overseas-online junk....
lol@US tax chat rorbincalendar.... please read a book. its not just the Democrats that have take the mass majority of your money and waste it on BS. The repubs have taken you hard erned bucks as well. And to think....most of the taxes collected from American citizens, which are mainly poor - middle class, never gets put back in their pockets. Most of the taxes collected are used to make rich folks richer...pay off Debt that was created by the US government, giving to people that never pay money back----- see isreal...etc....not to poor American citizens that taxe payer usually ----- about. Can you say the mass majority of American citizens = slaves?
Here is a little information from the US Office Of Tax Analysis for sturner60653 who obviously has been opening books without any numbers in them. ___ In 2002 the latest year of available data, the top 5 percent of taxpayers paid more than one-half (53.8 percent) of all individual income taxes, but reported roughly one-third (30.6 percent) of income._____Taxpayers who rank in the top 50 percent of taxpayers by income pay virtually all individual income taxes. In all years since 1990, taxpayers in this group have paid over 94 percent of all individual income taxes. _____ As for Republicans or Democrats, the last President to raise our taxes was Bill Clinton the next one will be Obama.
1 Posted by dubyac99 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:49PM EDT Report Abuse
My key reason for buying online for the last five years from Amazon. And now, Bushism is taking it away! Thanks GW, another notch in your belt for messing with our economy!! (Yes, his methods ultimately play a role in all the economic blowups that are happening around us!)