ThinkPad W700 tops indie test of laptop color quality

Mon Feb 2, 2009 1:44PM EST

See Comments (7)

Unless you're a digital artist or professional photographer, you probably don't give color accuracy much consideration. But if you've ever wondered why little Johnny looks a bit green when you're flipping through digital photos on your laptop, maybe you should. While the color accuracy of your LCD remains a topic largely of interest to the pros, digital photo expert Rob Galbraith found that even inexpensive laptops can have great color... and some of the sacred cows of the business may not be as sophisticated as you'd think.

Galbraith took four laptops -- two ThinkPads, including the new ultra-pricey W700, which includes an integrated color calibration system, a recent 15-inch Apple MacBook Pro, and a cheap Dell Insipiron Mini 9 -- and used a range of professional-grade color sampling and correction tools to measure how accurately colors were being displayed on the laptop screen. Galbraith also measured how well colors held up when the viewer wasn't front and center before the laptop, looking head-on at the display.

The results: As expected, the ThinkPad W700, with the integrated color management system, was the winner on both counts. But a surprise was in store regarding the placement of the Apple MacBook in Galbraith's tests: Dead last, finishing up behind even the Dell netbook, which by all expectations shouldn't even come close in this kind of testing.

That's shocking, especially considering Apple's reputation in the digital art and design community, an industry where it enjoys a virtual monopoly.

The picture was a little different if looking at viewing angle as a prime consideration: The two ThinkPads swapped places, and the MacBook earned third in Galbraith's testing.

As a side note, Galbraith notes that even the best laptop screens won't hold a candle to a good external monitor, so anyone making serious design decisions should hook up an external display whenever color representation is important. All other laptop users -- unless you have a W700, the only machine Galbraith rated as "above acceptable" -- should expect color accuracy to be iffy at best and plan accordingly.

Comments on ThinkPad W700 tops indie test of laptop color quality

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by nerd160 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:36PM EDT Report Abuse

    I am not suprised about the Mini 9. I have one and it is one of the best screens, on a laptop, I have seen.

  • 2 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    That was interesting about where the Apple fell into place. I have to find a good calibration program to try out. I tried Apple's built in stuff, but the more I tried to work with it, the worse the display got.

  • 3 Posted by ranjnarani48 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:29PM EDT Report Abuse

    i may be a buyer of this kind of product what technicaly it is a powerful device. what i want to give a suggesion that technilly sofisticated things are so expensive please if you are intersted to become atechnically large company keep low prize of tecnologies,......

  • 4 Posted by sieg_schoenberger on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:21PM EDT Report Abuse

    That's all interesting. However, in order for this story to be complete, we need the technical specs of the screens that were tested here. Does the W700 feature a TN, an IPS or PVA panel. What type of backlighting is used. And all the rest ...

  • 5 Posted by d_bostanashvili on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    still, good old CRT is the best choice.. LCD technology is just defective, i hope it will be replaced by something superior.

  • 6 Posted by eisosdesign on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:52PM EDT Report Abuse

    If you need to do any serious color work on any computer, laptop or desktop, you definitely need some kind of color calibration hardware. The Huey by Pantone is a good inexpensive solution that plugs into a standard USB port. Doesn't surprise me about the MacBook, Apples are just prestige items anymore, they've long since become irrelevant as design tools. I've worked with both PCs and Macs extensively for decades, and the gap in graphics quality between the two now is nil.

  • 7 Posted by badronald61 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    badronald61 i think they need to go back to the crt, lcd is a joke.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment