Thu Jan 25, 2007 3:14AM EST
See Comments (48)
I was about to sit down to write a post about all the things that bug me about Windows Vista... but Steve Wiseman beat me to it. His "Five Sins of Vista" is essential reading... but I'm going to add my commentary to his penance.
My biggest complaint with Vista is Steve's #3: Windows Networking is a mess. Mess is putting it lightly, and while Wiseman points out that the Windows "Network and Sharing Center" is one of the OS's most confusing features, he didn't mention the nightmare that is attempting to network a Vista computer to a network containing XP or Windows 2000 PCs. Frankly, I've been trying to figure this out for a week and still can't get what ought to be a simple printer share working.
Wiseman's #4 involves Windows Search, which is a complete joke. Remember how Vista was supposed to take those cool desktop search apps like Yahoo! Desktop and Google Desktop and integrate them seamlessly into the OS. Well, guess what, searching is faster with Vista... but you can't search inside a file using Vista's so-called "advanced" search system (which comes up when you hit F3). Oddly, the search system integrated into the Start Menu appears to be completely different and works much better, at least for data files. You can't easily search for system files and non-document files with it.
My other big agreement with Wiseman is his #1 complaint about the file browsing system. Windows is trying to move away from the C:\folder\folder\folder... heirarchy, I suppose because less savvy users were confused by it. I find the Vista method much more confusing, mainly because you have to end up delving into that directory structure frequently in order to get anything but very basic file operations done. Wiseman has other complaints about the way it works (and fails to work), too.
I've found other nagging problems in Vista—like help files that were obviously imported from Windows XP and never updated with Vista's changes—and I'm sure I'll be complaining about them on this blog in the weeks that come. Hopefully those complaints will be followed by thoughtful explanations on how to fix those problems... but for the issues listed above, there's not much you can do aside from learning to live with it.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Thanks for the great advice about Vista, I was also thinking of switching over but after what I just read I'm diffidently going to stay with XP until things are ironed out. This article sure will help alot of other people.
"...but for the issues listed above, there's not much you can do aside from learning to live with it." Actually, there is no need to learn to live with it. You could simply not buy it. Windows dominance is slipping, and even if you must have Windows it seems to be more and more clear that XP is your best bet between the two. The more that I read on Vista the more it seems like ME part two.
What a nightmare!! Sure am glad I have a MAC!
"but for the issues listed above, there's not much you can do aside from learning to live with it." All of us can do something about it... Do not buy it; send a message to MS that it's not an appropriate replacement for XP. MS has long dictated to us... seems turn about would be fair play. I have been using MS software / OS's since Dec of 1983, I have seen it all.
I have been a pc owner since the late 1980s'. I started off with msdos 5.0 and progressed through Windows 95, 98, and XP. I will no longer pay Microsofts' prices to be a beta tester for their new bug ridden products. It would have been nice to be the guy who installed the roof on Mr. Gates' house so that when he called to say that the new product that he bought from me was leaking I could tell him to wait 6 months or so and then stick his phone onto the roof so I can then issue him a patch. Then suggest that he should have bought roof 2.0!!!
lucky for me i have a mac so i don't have to worry about vista which looks like a copy of Tiger OS apple's operating system
I see where the first service pack is already being put together...I am going to wait on the second service pack. I can't justify moving to Vista when even people that like it say..."I like it but..." "This is cool...but" and on and on...
I wish they would realize that to a lot of people out here it doesn't matter that much if the software is cool - it matters if it works. I have to work for a living (yes, on a computer). When I come home, I don't like to have to fight with the software on my home computer in order to get it to do simple things like cleaning out the cache or printing something I see on the screen without cutting the edges off. And I wish they'd come up with something that wasn't such a memory hog. No, I'm not looking forward to Vista.
Wow. All of this, and it's somehow worth $400. Will someone explain this to me?
1 Posted by shutrbug@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:21PM EDT Report Abuse
I think I'll stay with XP. It ain't perfect, but it works. If only Linux were easier to use...