Mon Feb 26, 2007 6:13PM EST
See Comments (2374)
Daily Techno-Babble offers a breathless "three reasons why Windows Vista is sinking like a rock," and while the story has a point, I don't really think that "limits on how Vista can be used under virtualization" is really the thing about Vista that is scaring away that many would-be users, nor are Microsoft's DRM provisions on high-definition video much of a big deal yet, as few users care about high-def on their PC right now. Don't get me wrong: I think all of these are factors that make Vista a poor OS, but they aren't the primary reason that it's "sinking like a rock."
Given that Vista sales seem lackluster at best, what's the hang-up? I think it's something far more simple than the reasons that DTB offers up.
So what's turning people off of Vista? Here's my take, in order of importance:
1) Price. There's no way around this one. Upgrading to Vista doesn't just mean spending up to $400 on software, but also cash on RAM and video card upgrades, or buying a new PC altogether. If Vista was a $100 upgrade that anyone could use, it'd be a top seller, I'm sure.
2) Nothing new to see here. Love the visual style, but does photo tagging and 3-D window flipping really merit an upgrade?
3) It's annoying. I don't know any Vista user who hasn't turned off User Account Control, which nags you with an "Are you sure????" prompt every time you try to do anything beyond run the calculator. Yet UAC is the linchpin of Vista's vaunted new security system. Without it, it's really no different than XP.
4) Tons of stuff is incompatible with Vista. An acquaintance of mine got a new PC with Vista preinstalled. Neither her scanner nor her printer had Vista drivers ready. Both peripherals cost several hundred bucks, and now they're essentially paperweights (though the printer, at some unforseeable time in the future, may work again). Lots of software won't run on Vista, either, but it's the hardware incompatibilities that are daunting. (Update: Looks like the scanner driver's finally ready.)
5) It's confusing. Everything that XP could do, Vista can do... only it's buried under a different menu and it has a new name. While average users probably never use many of these settings, power users have found themselves starting from scratch to relearn Windows.
6) It's busted. Try connecting to a printer on your network that's hooked up to an XP machine. Or try downloading a file with a third-party application and then accessing it via another PC on the network. I won't go into a list of the endless bugs and flaws with the design of Vista, because I don't really have to: Vista needs a Service Pack already.
That's my take, but I'd love to hear your reasons for being hesitant: Why aren't you jumping whole hog into the Vistaverse?
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Vista does have its share of problems now. But it will soon be caught up with its problems, MS will have to put out upgrades due to IT changes daily. This operating system is no differance then 95,98,XP or 2000. Why complaine?? We all know as long as there are dum people who want to try to damage your P.C. there must be changes, all most daily. But all and all since we are now dependent on P.C. for news and comunacation we have to hope for the best. MS is the good guy not the bad guy. So I say good luck to MS we wish you the best, keep the windows down and let us feel the breezzz!!!!!!!!
what for? I'm happy with my XP, and I promise to stay with it till it craps out, perhaps. John
i noticed at sams club they had lots of computers on shelves pre loaded with win xp two days later, they had pulled all their old comps and replaced them with units pre loaded with vista. i havent been able to find a new computer with xp on any shelf since hmmm am i to be force fed this new operating sytem?
And the funny thing is about vista is that even b4 vista was put out there, MS said they would be sending out a SP. so all u brave ppl just wait hope will come.......when MS feels like it
Because of all the reasons you said and because my next replacement computers will be Macs!
Since the main advantage Vista has over XP is its interface, Microsoft really should just create a patch that gives XP users the option of changing XP's appearance to look more like Vista. Of course they will never do this because they want us to have to buy Vista in order to get any of the improvements it offers.
Waiting for stability in it. Remember when XP shipped everyone? 10,000+ Bugs? All the needs we are griping about now are things that XP brought to the table.....count on the same happening with VISTA as the kinks are ironed out....you have to figure that the way we are being FORCED to take the new OS, it will eventually become something we cannot do without...like XP is now! Thanks Chris
Because LINUX sounds so, so much better. No monopoly. No bullying big brother behind your back. No shoveling down your throat everything you need or not. Then lets protect the innovative companies out there from being sucked up by the mammoth. Almost everything MS has, is a result of others innovation, small little companies gobbled up then destroyed. MS is destroying our innovating technology, locking out everything but itself. That's why I no longer want anything coming from Microsoft.
You know the old--and true--saying: Microsoft gets things right on the third try. So I'll be waiting a while and in the meantime will continue to speak softly and kindly to my computer and bakc up regularly and hope it holds out for quite a bit longer.
1 Posted by aatw55 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:43PM EDT Report Abuse
how about big brother's built in spyware? i'm jumping ship to linspire/freespire!