Early Daylight Saving Time a Failure

Wed Apr 4, 2007 12:45PM EDT

See Comments (26)

Hey, remember that trouble we went through all those weeks ago in updating our computer, PDA, and cell phone clocks so we could get with the U.S. government's decision to move Daylight Saving Time ahead by three weeks? Well, we did it all for nothing. The results are in: We didn't conserve any energy at all.

Turns out the conventional wisdom and some common sense really had it right: Setting clocks forward an hour in early March forced people to get up when it was still dark and cold outside, causing increased use of light and heat in the morning hours. Though we may have saved a little power in the evenings, any savings were offset by additional morning use. Reuters notes that most large utility companies are noting they have seen no change in power consumption over the last three weeks.

What's this mean for technology? Well, governments don't like to admit their mistakes, so I highly doubt we'll be returning to the slightly-saner standard DST schedule any time soon. And really, that would wreak even more havoc on your computers, as you'd have to unpatch or re-patch all the hard work you already did getting your systems ready for the change in the first place.

There's also that little issue that DST now ends in November. (Word has it the candy companies pushed for the change so trick-or-treaters could stay out later, thus increasing candy sales.) My bet is after a few years, after the current administration has ended, the DST rules will change again: We'll move back to an April "spring forward" but will continue to "fall back" at the November date.

Now give me a Twix. 

LINK: Early U.S. Daylight Savings a bust in power savings

Comments on Early Daylight Saving Time a Failure

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by theyowman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:06PM EDT Report Abuse

    Chris, I think the Governments' efforts are not strictly aimed at conserving energy directly, but to shed light on the over-consumption of energy that we, Americans, take for granted. As the article you linked pointed out: "That may come as no surprise to the Energy Department, which last year predicted only modest energy savings because the benefits of the later daylight hour would be offset." With that being said, the Government would have no reason to admit a mistake, because they knew that moving DST forward would not have a significant effect on energy consumption. Now give me a cookie. -ADM

  • 2 Posted by simoncohen69 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:23PM EDT Report Abuse

    Chris I don't understand your reasoning on the whole Halloween thing, unless you were being sarcastic :) Surely it's better for Halloween (and thus candy companies) if it gets darker *earlier* not later since both as a parent and a former trick-or-treater, I don't want to go out while it's still daytime... that wouldn't be any fun at all :-)

  • 3 Posted by mpfatdaddy42 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Am I the only one that thinks the electric companies are full of crap?! I don't really understand how the government can really believe they got a true reading about eletrical usage, because I don't think the power companies even know how much is being used. When is the last time you saw an employee of the power company actually read your meter? I have never seen one, and when you ask the company why someone doesn't read the meter and how can they know how much you have used, they tell you some bogus story about the go by anstandard average. (In lamens terms, they guess by your past usage. But if they have been guessing this whole time, then they are full of crap! I can not use any lights in the house for a month, and my bill will be the same as if I had every light on for a month.) Until the power companies are made liable for their theft, we will never know.

  • 4 Posted by cnull on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    simoncohen69 - Apparently there are many people out there that only let their kids trick or treat during the daylight. Not kidding. Check this page: http://www.chatterblogging.com/2007/03/12/daylight-spending-time/ "In 1985, during the senate hearings on DST, the candy lobbyists even put a candy pumpkin on the seat of every senator."

  • 5 Posted by stressbusters1941 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    the early changeto DST has helped me personally, allowing me to catch up on things that i couldn't do before the change. i like what i have been able to do. it isn't a case of saving money, it is a case of starting my transition to warm-weather activities early enough to make a difference. winter is not easy in northern ohio, but this change takes some of the bite out of my wallet. i don't want to go back to the old way. jim grant

  • 6 Posted by rorbincalendar on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    A failure? How? As far as myself, my family, and friends we were all glad for the extra daylight at the end of the day. We got to eat dinner and still take the baby out for a walk before dark. Who cares about conserving the energy or a little darkness in the morning, it added to the enjoyment of my LIFE! Thank you to the current administration!

  • 7 Posted by aceledon on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:44PM EDT Report Abuse

    If we really wanted to save energy, we should have left the time as is, but be allowed to leave work an hour early. That would have saved lots of energy.- Mine!

  • 8 Posted by commorancy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    As if the candy companies aren't already making a mint off of obese people today. Let's give a few more daylight hours to rot more kid's teeth, get them hooked to candy and make them even more obese. What a great idea!

  • 9 Posted by rorbincalendar on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    It's a shame that people like "commorancy" above no longer factor parents responsibility into what their children eat. To them it's always evil capitalist greed while adults are just powerless pawns in their master plan who can wash their hands of the parental duties and responsibilities. Are you people serious with this stuff?

  • 10 Posted by cwthe3rd on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:33PM EDT Report Abuse

    The is NO DST in Arizona or Hawaii!

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 Next Last

Post a Comment