In-Flight Wireless: Cell Phones Out, Wi-Fi In

Thu Apr 5, 2007 12:36PM EDT

See Comments (7)

This week we were greeted with not one but two announcements about how we'll be communicating while aboard airplanes int he near future. While it was no surprise that the FCC officially banned cell phones from use while in flight (previously rumored here), the big news is that Wi-Fi will soon be allowed in U.S. airspace. The service has long been available on international flights but paranoia over interference with airplane electronics have kept it off domestic ones.

On the cell phone front, the FCC noted it had "insufficient technical information" to determine whether airborne cell phones would be a problem for cell phone networks on the ground. Are such fears founded? Perhaps, but the decision almost certainly has more to do with social arguments against airborne chit-chat. In recent months, the FCC has been flooded with messages from people who can't stand the asinine conversations they are exposed to on trains, buses, and on planes while they're taxiing to the gate. On the other hand, interestingly, the Wall Street Journal also reports  (linked above) that European and Middle Eastern airlines will begin offering in-flight cell phone service this year.

On the other hand, things are looking rosy for in-flight Wi-Fi. Though the FAA currently bans the technology along with cell phones as a potential source of interference, things have always been a bit looser for Wi-Fi, probably because it is quiet. Boeing's Connexion service was originally looking good over U.S. skies, but it was killed off late last year. However, a company called AirCell (which is also a proponent of in-flight cell phones) is looking to revive the idea.  It's even mentioned pricing: $10 a day. Other companies are dabbling in the space as well.

So you may be able to use your computer in flight, but not your phone, right? Well, what of VOIP systems like Skype? AirCell says it'll block those at the source. Sorry, chatmeisters.

LINK: WiFi in the Sky: Airlines Prepare Cabin Hotspots 

Comments on In-Flight Wireless: Cell Phones Out, Wi-Fi In

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by jim.pease on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    Wifi is quiet? Have you ever sat in a Wifi hotspot and watched someone talk via a video conference or instant messaging program? It's just as annoying as a cell phone.

  • 2 Posted by kendall_chong on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    Glad that you put in that they will block VoIp services Chris. I was wondering if they would get around that restriction and feed their chatty fix. But I would go one further is that wifi devices can only be used with headphones. Otherwise we could have people downloading videos and playing them too loud over their tiny speakers.

  • 3 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    LOL, you can only block so much! Quite frankly I think they would do better to have a free WiFi net that you can hook up your Nintendo DS to and play networked DS games with. That should keep the noisier section of the plane totally quiet.

  • 4 Posted by cnull on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    kendall_chong: Tons of people play music, games, and DVDs on planes, of course, and I've yet to see someone try to do so without headphones... Common courtesy may not be so common, but things aren't THAT bad.

  • 5 Posted by ginnij_mt on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    Cnull: Things are getting that bad... I'm a flight attendant, and I have to tell at least one person a day to use headphones or turn the volume all the way down. People seem not to care that they are in public, and technology, while wonderful, seems to have regressed society's manners and ability to act appropriately in public!

  • 6 Posted by ithakinm on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    Hear Hear to ginnij_mt I do not want to sit in a plane for 4 hours and listen to everyones conversations. I am polite to the person next to me but really enjoy NOT talking for a change.

  • 7 Posted by mypoptartispurple on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:31PM EDT Report Abuse

    you people are stuck up.Mythbusters have proved cell phones dont do crap and that proves the FCC is just paraniod.Your even more stuck up and paranoid if you think headphones can generate enough sound to disrupt whatever someones doing.ANd get off technologys back ginnjj its the special ed poeple who use them.other thing are worse people.Main idea:Cell phones and wifi dont affect planes and unless you brought a portable mini generator that fits in the tiny specifications, you CANT make sufficent noise!

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment