Exploding Batteries: What's the Real Risk?

Fri Sep 29, 2006 1:47PM EDT

See Comments (24)

Lately I've been hearing from countless people with Dell laptops who are concerned that their notebooks could blow up at a moment's notice. People are trying to call the Dell recall phone number, and it's completely jammed. Panic is rampant. People seem to think they're sitting on a time bomb, and they want it off their desk immediately.

Well I'm here to tell you one thing: Relax.

Seriously. Calm down.

OK. Now listen: Should you return your recalled Dell battery for a new one? Yes. Do you need to do it right this second? No. Some of you have been using these computers for years and the battery hasn't exploded yet. What are the odds that it's going to happen this weekend? Or even in the next few weeks? Virtually nil.

But let's look at this more thoroughly. What are the odds of a Dell notebook going up in flames? I put pencil to paper to figure it out.

Dell has reported that 4.2 million laptops are at risk (about 7 million total have now been recalled), and, as near as I can tell, about 8 known cases of batteries melting or exploding over the last two years. Let's play pessimist and assume the problem is much worse than Dell knows about. Let's assume that over the next three years, a full 60 notebooks will explode if left with at-risk batteries. Doing the math: That's a 1 in 210,000 chance per year of a recalled battery exploding. Over the next two months, should you decide to wait a bit to replace your battery: The odds are 1 in 1,260,000.

Do those odds frighten you? I decided to cobble together some comparable statistics to put you at ease. Here's your risk of facing death or damage due to some more realistic concerns. (Note that all odds below are for the event happening over the course of one year.)

Odds of being struck by lightning (though not necessarily dying) in a given year: 1 in 400,000 (Source: National Weather Service)

Odds of dying in a car accident in a given year: 1 in 18,400 (Source: National Safety Council [NSC])

Odds of getting killed somehow while walking around outside: 1 in 49,000 (NSC)

Odds of drowning: 1 in 88,000 (NSC)

Odds of choking to death: 1 in 97,000 (NSC)

Odds of dying in an air (or space) accident: 1 in 392,000 (NSC)

Odds of freezing to death: 1 in 469,000 (NSC)

Odds of death from falling off the bed or a chair: 1 in 347,000 (NSC)

Odds of choking to death on your own vomit: 1 in 740,000 (NSC)

Odds of getting killed by fireworks: 1 in 26,440,000 (NSC)

Odds of death due to overly hot tap water: 1 in 11,100,000 (NSC)

Odds of death due to burning pajamas: 1 in 97,000,000 (NSC, and no that's not a joke)

Odds that you'll kill yourself: 1 in 9,200 (NSC)

Surprisingly, your odds of freezing to death or falling off the bed to your doom are better than that of your Dell exploding over the next year, but those are major long shots. You're less at risk with the Dell than you face with countless other hazards, like being stabbed to death (1 in 142,000), dying through surgical complications (1 in 102,000), or getting killed on a motorcycle (1 in 79,000). Let's also note that these melting Dells haven't killed anyone yet, either.

Now consider this: Time magazine says 591,000 laptops were stolen in 2001. I estimate there are about 100 million laptops in use in the U.S. right now (and that's probably aggressive). Your odds of your notebook being stolen this year are at best 1 in 169, about 1,000 times as likely as the thing melting in your lap.

Now I'm not saying that you shouldn't replace your hazardous battery, not at all. If you own a notebook from a company doing recalls, check the recall website and see if your battery model is listed. (I keep a handy list of all the recall websites on one page.) But don't kill yourself to do it immediately: What I am saying is that you might face a bigger risk of bashing in your own skull with your phone while you face endless busy signals and hold times if you try to get the replacement battery during the panic-stricken first few days of any recall. If you're that concerned, simply remove the battery from your laptop and work on A/C power only for the time being.

Take a breather, folks. It's gonna be all right.

Comments on Exploding Batteries: What's the Real Risk?

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 3 Posted by zac_hanley on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:58PM EDT Report Abuse

    Your own vomit, yes - but what about the odds of choking on somebody else's?

  • 4 Posted by cicero_hood on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    The only problem with the analogies here are the situaltional probabilities. Example: your odds of freezing to death may be 1 in 469,000 but this is a national average. Your odds to freeze to death are considerably lower if you're a resident of Flagstaff than if you live in Alberta. But the overall point is a good one: we tend to worry more about sensational dangers than real ones.

  • 5 Posted by kcdevine@verizon.net on Tue Aug 22, 2006 9:17PM EDT Report Abuse

    I love this article. Innumeracy is the culprit. None of us, save a very few with a lot more intelligence than I, even understand all these numbers, ratios, and probabilities. I guess it just goes to show, once again, that we are a funny species. Thanks for the laugh.

  • 6 Posted by tgposz on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    a little more than 10 years ago, Gregory Benford assigned some costs to similar sorts of events, i.e. if the odds are high enough, we ought to do something to protect people... The figures (1995 $$) are his: Saving a single Life costs: - $200, in third world countries (usually due to malnutrition) - $75,000, in advanced nations (cancer screening) - $120,000, in USA (highway safety agencies, better highway dividers, easier on-ramps, etc.) - $1,000,000, in USA (to avoid one case of deadly lung disease by having better air pollution controls) - $5,000,000, in USA (to eliminate natural radioactivity in drinking water, which is why we don't do it) - $2,500,000,000, in USA (for nuclear plant safety) - For about 600 times the cancer screening rate, or $50,000,000 per year, killer asteroids could be identified and eliminated from threatening the earth. Gregory Benford, F& SF, March, 1995 tgposz http://wunderphul.blogspot.com

  • 7 Posted by cnull on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    cicero - good point. Your odds of being killed by an exploding laptop are also much lower if you don't use one... but what fun would that be?

  • 8 Posted by jim798393 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    I heard that in five of those six cases the users dropped their batteries into salad dressing made of over 50% vinegar and then later put out a cigarette on it. The sixth case involved handcuffs, candle wax and a Dobermann. Since this is a family forum that's all I can say. But those odds need to be recalculated for these coincidences and occurrences, I think.

  • 9 Posted by jim798393 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse

    Really Chris if you want to alert people to a real danger that's not getting any press look into CR123A photo batteries, also lithium, used in the context of a high powered LED flashlight. These flashlights are becoming more common and the faliure rate, explosive nature, unquenchable fire and intense chemical toxicity makes these batteries and these flashlights serious dangers. Go to Candlepowerforums.com: http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=124776 In my post above the point is that we don't know whether there were causative circumstances like faulty chargers or habitually leaving the notebook in a car trunk of mistreating the notebook. Also if failure is going to happen wouldn't it happen early in the battery life cycle? How old were these batteries. Could people worry less since they've gotten thru a year or two without a fire? Just additional factors to consider.

  • 10 Posted by johnp_dell on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:39PM EDT Report Abuse

    Interesting read, for sure, but the bottom line for us at Dell is the safety of the people who use our products. The Sony batteries do present a very low risk, indeed, but not one we're ready to take.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment