How to Buy a Laptop: Summer 2007 Edition

Mon May 21, 2007 2:58PM EDT

See Comments (52)

It's been about six months since my last laptop buying guide. Sounds like a short time, but you can't stop innovation in this market, and you'd be surprised how much has changed in the last few months alone. I've also been surprised how many emails I've received in recent weeks asking for laptop purchasing advice, so it seems time for another update on what to look for in a laptop.

Here's what I advise looking for in a new notebook purchase.

  • CPU - I wouldn't bother with any chip other than an Intel Core 2 Duo. Don't get suckered into getting a cheap Celeron machine, and don't go for an AMD system either. The speed of the chip isn't terribly important, but you do want to make sure you're getting a "Santa Rosa/Merom" system, which is more future-proof than older models. How do you know if you're getting a Merom CPU? Just check the chips listed in the Merom section on this Wikipedia page. Just match up the model number on your laptop of choice and see where it falls.
  • Memory - 1GB is a bare minimum today, but it should suffice for most laptops.
  • Operating System - It's hard to find a PC without Vista preinstalled on it right now, but it can be done. If it's available as an option, I'd choose XP over Vista, no question. Of course there's always the MacOS and Ubuntu, too.
  • Hard Drive - While you can get hard drives with no moving parts now (called SSDs, or solid state drives), they are so expensive it doesn't make sense to do so. Stick with an old-fashioned spinning-disc hard drive. Capacities haven't changed much lately. While you can get up to a 250GB notebook hard drive, most come with 80GB as a default, which most users will find big enough. Upgrade according to your needs.
  • Optical Drive - Both Blu-ray and HD-DVD are starting to make a splash on laptops now. Note that HD-DVD laptop drives are read-only; if you want to write to high-def optical media, you'll need the Blu-ray option that some vendors offer. I doubt many users need this much high-capacity optical storage, though. And there's no real advantage to watching high-definition DVDs instead of regular DVDs on a tiny laptop screen. I'd just stick with a dual-layer DVD-RW drive for the time being, at least for another six months.
  • Graphics Card - With Vista, it's more important than ever to invest in quality graphics. I wouldn't recommend any integrated graphics solution. You'll be very disappointed with the experience under Vista. That said, few notebooks offer much of a choice when it comes to graphics options, so juice it up as much as possible. Upgrading to discrete graphics from integrated can be as inexpensive as an extra $99, but it'll make a world of difference in your daily computing.
  • Screen - Nothing much changing here, except that LEDs are starting to appear as backlighting instead of fluorescent tubes. This means you get a brighter screen and lower power consumption, but the difference is not dramatic on either count. Don't hold out for LED backlighting and choose instead based on how big a screen (and how much weight) you're willing to carry. Laptop weight has not really changed at all lately: Expect to carry 8 pounds and up for a 17-inch system, 6 to 7 pounds with a 15.4-inch machine, and as little as 3 pounds with an ultralight.
  • Wireless - The Santa Rosa chipset I mentioned above puts four flavors of Wi-Fi, 802.11a, b, g, and n into your notebook. You definitely want this: Nearly all upcoming Wi-Fi hardware will use 802.11n in some form. Wireless WAN (WWAN) is another option that many vendors now offer. Want to get high-speed access away from a Wi-Fi connection? Now you can do so without a bulky add-in card. Add it if you want the feature and can afford the monthly service fees.

That's about the lay of the laptop land today. In case you're wondering, Macs have seen only modest refreshes in recent months. If I was getting a Mac, I'd make an exception to my above rule and wait for the new LED-backlit models to show up (since that will be in a matter of weeks) and, if possible, until 2008 when the new MacOS arrives. It would still be OK to purchase one today, but I think you'll get a better deal if you wait a bit.

As always, feel free to send me specs or a link to the laptop you're considering via email and I'll weigh in with an opinion. Happy shopping!

Comments on How to Buy a Laptop: Summer 2007 Edition

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by bowtah on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:12PM EDT Report Abuse

    Did you mean "I'd choose XP OVER Vista"? Are there really any other reasonable options for PC laptops?

  • 2 Posted by tsupersonic1986 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:23PM EDT Report Abuse

    Hi, Good article overall. I just have one quick comment. For CPU, you said, " I wouldn't bother with any chip other than an Intel Core 2 Duo. Don't get suckered into getting a cheap Celeron machine, and don't go for an AMD system either." What is wrong with AMD processors? They are just as good as Intel performance wise. The Turion X2 may have a shorter battery life than Intel's counterpart, but with Intel dominating the CPU in terms of processing power (both laptop & desktop), it's crucial that consumers buy AMD as well. What do you think keeps the compeition going? These companies are working very hard to create CPU's, and the only that drove Intel to create the Core (2) Duo processor line was AMD. AMD is losing profit because everyone is buying an Intel processor or a computer w/ an Intel chipset. Modern processors are very powerful for the typical user. Even a Celeron M processor is more than sufficient for a person who wants to surf the web, check email and Office granted you have enough RAM. So, why is it that you're telling people to get an Intel Core 2 Duo processor in their next notebook? I think it's very bad advice in my opinion.

  • 3 Posted by scottiecordes on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:08PM EDT Report Abuse

    For writing to hi-def, I believe you meant to say if you want to write, you will need a blu-ray. hddvd cannot be written to as of yet.

  • 4 Posted by erikliska on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:55PM EDT Report Abuse

    Vista doesn't suck. the only thing that sucks is the people complaining about vista. People hate changes. get over it and SHUT THE ----- UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 5 Posted by cnull on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    tsupersonic - AMD chips are fine on desktops, but the mobile versions consistently underperform. I don't recommend them. AMD's profit does not enter into my decision making process, btw. all others - sorry about the typos, they've been fixed!

  • 6 Posted by terminalman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    Given that the top laptop in the banner further down on this page is an Apple MacBook (also Intel Core 2 Duo) the fact you appear to have forgotten they exist seems kinda dumb. And since a MacBook can cost less than a comparable Dell system (including the "fancy" Vista comparable to MacOSX), this omission does a disservice to readers. Most folks prefer Windows, which is cool. But if you're going to write "How to Buy a Laptop", let's not omit one of the major choices.

  • 7 Posted by cnull on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    terminalman - There's an entire paragraph on Macs at the end of the story. Keep reading...

  • 8 Posted by theliquidone on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:04PM EDT Report Abuse

    Chris, do you ever do a guide for desktops similar to this one?

  • 9 Posted by hockeyhotshot_23 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:19PM EDT Report Abuse

    So many people, like yourself, state that Vista is not that great. I've been using it since December and love it. You need the right specs, and its a great OS, and doesn't crash nearly as often as XP did

  • 10 Posted by hockeyhotshot_23 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:19PM EDT Report Abuse

    Also Chris, I work at Best Buy and I see alot of problems with people buying the Core 2 when they only do internet surfing and office documents. You can buy an Duo Core chip or an X2 and still get the same results unless you are doing alot of heavy gaming and Photoshop. You should advise your readers that a laptop that comes with a hd-dvd rom is going to be pretty pricey (ie: HP DV 9260nr for $2249.99). Also, the new Gateway laptops that have the AMD X2 chip now come with Draft N in the wireless card.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 4 Next Last

Post a Comment