Sat Sep 15, 2007 4:02PM EDT
See Comments (13)
Legislatures have been heating up over the dangers of using cell phones while driving, with one recent action taking aim text messaging while driving. Whether such laws have any effect is another story, but that hasn't stopped states from continuing to push for more restrictions against dialing and driving. The latest comes from California, where a new law that will prevent 16- and 17-year-old drivers (and only 16- and 17-year-old drivers) from using cell phones, PDAs, laptops, or pagers while driving. The law goes into effect on July 1, 2008. I first thought the age-limited law was unique, but it turns out 15 other states and D.C. already have similar laws on the books.
The impetus for such a law is pretty compelling: Auto accidents are the cause of 44 percent of all teen deaths, and cell phone use has been implicated as the cause for a large number of those. A third of teen drivers admit to being distracted by tech gear while driving their cars, and teen cell phone use while driving is rapidly on the rise.
As laws go, however, this one is pretty toothless: A $20 fine for the first offense and $50 after that, no points on your license, and cops can't even pull you over just because they see you talking on the phone. I don't know any kid who'd feel threatened by such a weak law enough to change his or her behavior.
And why target kids? Sure, they are statistically worse drivers, but there are plenty of grown-ups who are completely incapable of driving their automobiles, too, especially if they're on the phone. (Guy who's trying to dial the phone while heavy traffic is navigating a narrow San Francisco street while everyone waits for you to get through... I'm talking to you.) Ban 'em all, I say.
So, for those of you in those 15 other states, plus D.C., do laws like this have any effect where you live? What would you prefer to see legislated?
LINK: Guv signs law banning minors from using cell phones while driving
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Another example of politicians pretenting to do something but in reality doing nothing. At least it took up their time so they they were too busy to pass another bill that is even more stupid.
Iam a UK Reader of your emals and agree that there should be a ban on everything and not only youngsters. Over here there are bans on texting,chatting on mobiles,eating and even tidying their faces up (mostly women,smile)but nobody seems to worry. Cinders UK.
I've never heard of such an impotent law in my life! What genius came up with this? You better put some bite into this law,Arnold,or every punk or punkette cruising around in daddy's high dollar ride is going to be laughing at you!! This law should include everyone,and include substantial penalties. Come on California legislators,WAKE UP!!!!
People don't use bluetooth headsets because they are expensive. This law they passed is ridiculous, how can you possibly expect it to be effective if you can't even get pulled over for it?
It appears that the only thing this law is going to accomplish is wasted space on the books and wasted tax-payer money for the time it took lawmakers to write it. A couple of years ago, I was in a severe auto accident that totalled my car (had it only about a month). A real estate agent made a u-turn right in front of me without looking for oncoming traffic. She was talking on her cell phone, and I suffered 1st and 2nd degree airbag burns and several contusions on my upper body. Ban them all! I agree with the comment posted by #5..the reason more people do not use bluetooth technology is because it is too expensive, and other hands-free deals you see on TV ads and in catalogs are cheap and do not work like they're supposed to. Mr. Schwarzenegger, please put some backbone in this law, & make it enforceable. If a policeman cannot pull someone over when he or she observes this law being broken, then you have left them powerless and made a mockery of them. Shame on you. This ineffective law allows very young teenagers, some of whom already are obstinate, rebellious and disrespectful, to laugh at authority and fear no repercussion. Please make this law enforceable!
won't work- never has never will. The governor in my state is thinking about the same thing, but here you'll be able to get pulled over for it. a waste of time, and a waste of resources.
I do not understand this impulse to legislate responsibility. Does it make any sense to ban / legislate only one specific type of irresponsible behavior? If you're going to ban talking on a cell phone or texting while driving because it distracts the driver then all behavior that distracts should be banned. I've included a short list of my favorites: Shaving while driving; applying makeup while driving; using a laptop computer while driving; reading a newspaper while driving; folding a map while driving; yelling at your kids while driving; checking out the hottie in the next lane while driving; drinking coffee while driving; eating while driving; changing the radio station while driving; finding the right CD while driving; retrieving the right CD from the floorboard after you dropped it while driving; performing or receiving acts of an intimate nature while driving; sleeping while driving; listening to an iPod while driving; having a conversation with the person in the passenger seat while driving; daydreaming while driving; watching every other driver to see if they are distracted while driving... my list alone should keep the Cali lawmakers busy for the next 20 years. I'm thinking that if a person allows themself to become distracted and causes damage they should be held liable. Don't clutter the books with silly ineffective laws in an attempt to compensate for poor judgement, because really, you can't fix stupid. As for a hands-free devices being too expensive... you can afford a car and a cell phone with it's monthly service plan but not a bluetooth device?
this is so wack yo
this is so wack yo
1 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse
They need to ban text messaging while driving and make it mandatory for everyone to use hands free alternatives for talking on the phone. I just dont understand why people dont use bluetooth headsets... I also dont understand why people are text messaging while driving for the love of pete! WHY???